Truthahn
T
4,258
Posts
0
Threads
994
Likes
Member since:
November 23, 1999
Last post:
05/25/2022 08:23 AM ET
Posting History (1,548)
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
All three are in their first trans year to FBS.
Kenn State, Mo State, and Delaware. The NCAA trashed their rules to make that happen.
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
JMU tried the waiver, maybe even both years, but were turned down.
The Sun Belt was really good about getting them into a proper FBS schedule right away. Both years JMU played enough FBS teams, etc. But the NCAA denied their waiver (at least in year two) even though they were obviously ready.
My how times have changed in just three years. The NCAA apparently gave out three waivers!
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Plus everyone plays a national schedule now.
We play in California, Texas, Florida and Massachusetts next year.
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Interesting to see all of the ineligible teams in bowls.
Missouri State and Delaware are in their first year in the FBS. Aren't they both ineligible?
And Kennesaw State is in their second year.
JMU had to wait until their third year to be allowed to go to a bowl game.
I guess all of the opt outs allowed that?
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
The one very big institution?
I would guess one of those that are complaining about the B10 venture capital push, Michigan or USC. Either are probably arrogant enough to think life outside a conference might be better for them, even when the conference is the Big Ten.
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
I love this. You would need golden handcuffs to keep defections low
Any time a team wins this a few times, the top group will steal them away just to maintain the imbalance. The P2 would keep taking the top teams from us every so often.
Maybe the money could go to the groups and be doled out over a long time, like the NCAA BB tourney, so defector money stays behind.
Football Board
7 mo ago
Football Board
7 mo ago
ND is good for a couple big TV games a year for us
A few million a year, I guess for each school if that. Could it be that much?
They seem replaceable to me, but the way I see it, we are both getting the same thing from each other, consistent access to big games. We provide them with FSU, Clemson, Miami and a few more from time to time that end up as big games for them, and they provide ND to play our teams in exchange.
If we cancel that, then we are just competing against each other to get big OOC games on our schedules. Not great for either. For us, we just get put into the same boat as the B12 in that respect.
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Phillips needs to have Pop Tarts at his next meeting.
"Oh these? No, we just love pop tarts. We have them every meeting."
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Replacing the ACC with the top of the P2 will not be easy for them.
Those teams will not be very flexible, IMO. I believe few of them will play ND late at least, leaving ND with only lower teams near the end of each season.
Conference Realignment Board
7 mo ago
Football Board
7 mo ago
Unfortunately, it won't happen.
I'd even be OK with the ACC including ND in the championship. ND could call it whatever they want to sell it to their alumni.
They would have to give up something pretty big to make that happen, of course, too, like adding one more game to the mix, playing six every year. That way, we could count the ND games times 1.5 to make it match.
I think we could get a lot more money from ESPN to make it worth it, and that could really separate the ACC from the B12.
Football Board
7 mo ago
IMO, yes.
I think the committee was embarrassed by ND's loss to Miami and otherwise almost identical stats between the two, but just barely enough to make the switch.
Football Board
7 mo ago
Our first tiebreaker should be the CFP ranking
Time to be pragmatic. We should be trying to get the most teams into the CFP, so we should use their criteria.
Football Board
7 mo ago
Football Board
7 mo ago
Football Board
8 mo ago
Go get some Crumbl cookies today.
BYU booster owns that company and he is ponying up to keep their coach from be hired away by PSU. If he stays then PSU might be stuck with real crumbs for a coach.
I assume there are several good players at PSU that are waiting to hear who their new coach will be before deciding to transfer.
Football Board
8 mo ago
If all of the favs win, probably Ole Miss or Texas A&M
The field should be this in that case.
OSU
Georgia
Indiana
Texas Tech
#5 Oregon
#6 Ole Miss
#7 Texas A&M
#8 OK
#9 ND
#10 Miami
#11 UVa
#12 North Texas or JMU
I doubt UVa would jump over Miami.
Also, I assume Alabama would drop out, but maybe not. UVa might be #10, in that case.
Football Board
8 mo ago
I think Miami would need Alabama and BYU to lose.
That will probably happen, though, IMO, so Miami might be closer then we think.
Football Board
8 mo ago
Wow. Franklin must be salivating thinking about his chances in the ACC.
If Duke wins, we need JMU to lose. And maybe UNLV, too?
If JMU or UNLV win, they should be ahead of Duke as the 12th team.
Otherwise, Miami could still get in, if Alabama and BYU both lose.
On the bright side, technically we could get two teams in, UVa and Miami.
No one looks good in this bunch (except um UVa, I guess).
** Edited by Truthahn at 11/30/2025, 2:48:52 PM
Conference Realignment Board
8 mo ago
Football Board
8 mo ago
We should try to flip this guy from Florida
Fletcher Westphal OL from Leesburg, VA, currently at Florida. Maybe the SEC is not looking so great to him anymore, and he would like playing at VT under Franklin. During his recruitment, he only had a few SEC blue bloods on his list, plus Clemson.
Conference Realignment Board
8 mo ago
I'd love to see some data about how well this predicts outcomes.
Also, for the AP, CFP, and the other computer models. It would be nice to have some data backing up our suspicions of SEC, B10 and ND bias.
Football Board
8 mo ago
I went to the restroom just before the fourth quarter, on the UVa side.
There were a bunch of loud UVa kids yelling insults about VT in there (What the h%#$ is a Hokie? A Hokie is a %$#@ chicken! and so on). They were having a great time.
It was sweet to be back on the hill a few minutes later watching the best 4th quarter comeback ever, thinking about how their day was going.
Conference Realignment Board
8 mo ago
I wanted this for Texas back just after ND joined the ACC.
A ND deal for Texas, too, back then would have been great for the ACC and Texas. Plus, they could even play each other in a big game. Michigan is another one that could pull this off.
However, if I were the B10, I'd be more afraid of USC and Michigan joining the SEC, bringing along Ohio State and Penn State.
Conference Realignment Board
8 mo ago
If I were Jim Phillips I would fly to Ann Arbor for a few days.
Spend a day walking in and out of the admin building and telling people he is just there on vacation.
Conference Realignment Board
8 mo ago
Football Board
8 mo ago
I think Chesney makes around $1 Million a year.
I suppose he will get a big boost this off season, however.
But still I would think something like Pry's contract would be enough to get him.
Conference Realignment Board
9 mo ago
We would be in the AAC right now, if this advice had been taken in 2003.
The state government was very involved back then. I don't want dignity or staying in lanes. I want results.
Football Board
9 mo ago
Football Board
9 mo ago
VT has been bad since 1999 apparently.
Didn't we go to six or seven new years days bowls in the 12 or so years after that, ranked in the top 10 during a lot of that time?
Also, he assumes the path to the playoffs is easier in the ACC than the B10 "because the ACC is so weak", ignoring the CFP trend to obviously favor the B10 and SEC. PSU might have a tough time winning the B10, but getting into the playoffs is easier for them than for ACC non champs, see Miami last year.
IMO PSU fans generally know nothing about us and assume PSU has always been better than us. Their opinion on what would be good for us is worthless.
Football Board
9 mo ago
True Story: I saw Franklin and wife at a mall just after his PSU hiring.
They were looking at appliances. I did a double take when they passed me. Definitely him, so keep your eyes peeled.
Football Board
9 mo ago
+1
We should be able to get him for Pry money and a four year contract, a huge $ gain for him, with some massive performance bonuses, and lots of money left for high quality staff.
Chesney has won big everywhere he has gone, and we need knock JMU down a peg anyway.
Football Board
10 mo ago
Comparing the student fee to taxes is about right tho.
The only things that are certain are death and taxes, and student fees.
Football Board
10 mo ago
Time to hate watch FSU again.
Thanks for reminding me that they play Miami next.
I've been ignoring them so far.
Conference Realignment Board
10 mo ago
I see UConn as more interesting to us as an independent.
The ACC could bring them into a scheduling agreement and put their home games onto the ACCN. Maybe there is a way to get us and them some more money that way? UConn home games on the ACCN might be worth something to ESPN, especially if they host a couple of ACC teams each year. They host Duke this year, and play Syracuse and BC.
Heck, isn't ESPN from Hartford? Maybe they like the idea of throwing a bone to UConn?
Conference Realignment Board
10 mo ago
We've added schools over objections from Clemson, FSU and UNC.
We could do it over BC's, too, if need be.
Conference Realignment Board
10 mo ago
Football Board
10 mo ago
Football Board
10 mo ago
Can you make this threat after you have already stopped?
You say below that you stopped donating over the Summer.
Football Board
11 mo ago
You get your wish next year with two pre-season warm ups.
VMI warms up for ODU, who warms up for Maryland (who warms up for JMU!)
For the record, I think we should try to engineer wins with our non-conferences games as much as possible.
First games should be no higher than a low-range G6
Second game should be no higher than a mid-range G6
Third game should be a lower half P2 or a B12 team at the highest (I know the B12 has some great teams).
Then ACC schedule
Then another max mid-range G6 around week nine.
Then the rest of the ACC schedule
Nothing helps you more than wins, IMO. We should never schedule a team we will probably lose to, especially a neutral game that is closer to the other team's stadium.
Our 2026 schedule is almost perfect, IMO. We should avoid the neutral, Alabama in Atlanta type games. They are traps, IMO.
Look at Ole Miss this year, for another near perfect one. They mix theirs up a bit more, GSU, Tulane, Wash State, with some SEC in between, and then the Citadel in week 10, to give themselves a rest for the final two SEC games. They get a chef's kiss. No blockbuster one off preseason neutral games against Michigan in Detroit on that schedule.
Conference Realignment Board
1 y ago
Maybe uneven distro should morph into de facto relegation?
That is, confs could divide into two or more scheduling groups, reranked by performance (either by record or by some sort of power ranking) after each year. Teams get significantly less money as they go down into the lesser groups. You don't need to kick anyone out. Just let them settle into the bottom group.
For the ACC, how about this? Three groups; six, six, and five teams. Each group has to play four others in it's group, and draw as evenly as possible from the other two. Bottom group does not play Notre Dame.
** Edited by Truthahn at 7/28/2025, 8:41:38 AM
Conference Realignment Board
1 y ago
Yes, "FSU and Clemson to the P2 NOW!" posts no longer get clicked.
So now we have a bunch of "SHOCKING NEWS: UNC is leaving the ACC NOW!" content, because it sounds plausible and people are clicking again.
Conference Realignment Board
1 y ago
I can't imagine that being a trustworthy dialogue.
It will be an interesting day when the SEC offers membership to Michigan, PSU and Ohio State (and Notre Dame).