All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

T
The_VT_Rock OP
Jul 28, 2025 at 10:30 AM ET
Of those that are rooting for a merger of B12-ACC
In this scenario, the B12-ACC "best" produce a 20-24 team conference. Part of them combining would be under the AQ 16-team CFP where the SEC gets 4, B10 gets 4, and this combo would get 4 (though the combo would need ND to secure the 4 AQs). Would people prefer the ACC name stand around w/ B12 schools joining ACC, B12 name staying w/ ACC schools going to B12, or would a "new" conference get formed to incorporate a different name? If it would happen, I think whatever way that allows the fewest lawsuits would win out.

17 Replies

V
VTCALS72
I could see a merger between the left behinds in the little 2 +PAC
to where there is one commissioner and 3 fairly independent division, easters, central and western. I think the idea that a 3rd big P league is a pipedream.
hokieball hokieball
Kind of depends on who doesn’t get B1G and SEC invites, but…
for this I’ll assume FSU, Clemson, UNC, and UVA go to the SEC and Miami and Notre Dame go to the B1G. I think the best 20-team conference cobbled together from those still in the ACC and XII would be something like this: VT NCSU Duke GT UCF WVU Pitt Louisville Iowa State Kansas Kansas State Colorado BYU OK State Texas Tech Utah Arizona Arizona State Stanford Cal Next 4 in: TCU Baylor Cincinnati Syracuse Last 4 in: Houston SMU Wake Forest Boston College I think the focus should be on large public schools and brand name schools to maximize fan interest. There’s probably other schools I’d consider before some of the ones listed towards the end, like UConn instead of BC, Memphis instead of SMU, and South Florida instead of Wake.
O
OrlandoHokie
Here is what I would like to see based on your criteria.
VT NC State GT Pitt West Virginia Louisville UCF USF UCONN or Temple Nine team conference. Every body plays each other head to head in football every year. No conference championship game in football. Whoever has the best regular season conference record is the champ in football. Every body plays a home and home in basketball every year. Everybody makes the basketball conference championship. In football we can still schedule OOC games with Virginia every year and rotate in ODU, William and Mary, VMI, Wofford, and Furman. Nobody would want to televise this conference but I sure would enjoy it. These are (9) public schools that I see as peers that like to put resources into football and basketball. I don't care about the Olympic sports. ** Edited by OrlandoHokie at 7/29/2025, 12:40:35 PM ** Edited by OrlandoHokie at 7/29/2025, 1:55:30 PM
M
Marooned
The name choice is obvious - the Big Atlantic Conference
We’re BAC baby! 🤪
R
RandomAsianGuy
I don’t see any merger happening.
H
HouClone
Possible compromise solution
The ACC is going through a very similar path as the Pac. The Pac touted the brands, the tv network, and the academics as superior to the Big 12. And they were right. But they experienced the same fate, actually worse, than the Big 12 when the Big 12 lost its brands. Their arrogance and losing the brands did them in. If the ACC loses its brands, the ACC still would have two things the Pac didn't have: a tv deal and a tv network tied to ESPN. However, the tv deal likely will be renegotiated by ESPN for the brands leaving. The ACC can backfill or try to lure some Big 12 teams, but the ACC would not be in position of strength. There is a solution that would benefit the Big 12 and most of the remaining ACC. VTech, Pitt, NC State, Duke, and Louisville leave with the brands but are able to keep the ACC name and commissioner. This new ACC would invite the Big 12 in its entirety for a 24 team conference. The 23rd and 24th teams are up for debate. ESPN and Fox may make this worthwhile to this new ACC also. Strength in numbers of good teams is the only way to combat the Big 10 and SEC.
V
VTCALS72
I think the ACC already knows where big media is positioning them.
They have already had those discussions or had the terms read to them by big media and know about how much money a brands leaving ACC is worth and what the ACC will look like. Adding lower league teams to keep some number is probably not a requirement for the contract.
A
ancient alien 2018
Or desirable
C
cburgroop
Curious to see who would be everyone's "best" 10-12 Big 12 teams?
To me that's difficult to determine because there's so much parity in the Big 12. No one really stands out either way. This is not a dig on the conference, because you could make a pretty good case for any of the 16 to make the cut for different reasons. The ACC is a bit different as the more obvious "left-outs" would be Wake, BC and Syracuse. Pitt, Duke, Stanford and Cal would be next out IMO but one could make a solid case for any of those four. IMO, SMU would make the cut if the top ACC programs were to branch off and form a new league although that might change in a merger situation with other Texas schools coming in.
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
I see this potential merger as an opportunity to restore rivalries that
have been lost due to the conference realignment. As a result, I do think it should be a more important factor when deciding which schools make the cut. For example, if TCU makes the cut, then naturally SMU should too because I always thought it was a fun/entertaining rivalry even when both teams were horrible. Likewise, if WVU makes the cut, then that opens the door for VT, Pitt, maybe Syracuse (secondary rivalry), and even UVA (who can forget about the bowl games).
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
New name. All the current conference names are stupid.
Big "Ten" 😭 South"Eastern" Conference 😭 Big "XII" 😭 "Atlantic" Coast Conference 😭
T
Truthahn
Call it the BAC, LOL.
B
Big12 guy
A new conference based on athletic minimum budgets, attendance,
viewership, and past success would be a pretty decent conference. Eliminate all preconceived notions, form a conference of the top 20 or 24 schools not in the P2, form regional pods for the non revs, and put the screws to ESPN, FOX, or any other media company to garner a competitive media deal. Being labeled an ACC, PAC, or B12 school is holding both conferences back, and allowing the media companies to pit one conference against the other. Screw the P2 on their AQ's, and schedule games the country would like to see, pitting the top schools from the individual pods playing each other, and allow enough flexibility for future in conference and OOC rivalries to thrive. If a deserving school can not come up with the money, in an objective fashion, or just wants to step aside for altruistic or academic reasons, and will not invest in the money making sports or facilities, ley them go. Call the conference anything you want.
A
ancient alien 2018
Call it the FOOTBALL BOYSTOWN CONFERENCE for deserving teams.
M
mancunian
For some reason your post made me think of this.
“It’s toasted…”
B
Big12 guy
OK, that clip was awesome, but I have to ask, who in
their right mind remembers such things? You belong in Kansas.
M
mancunian
"I don't have to tell you gentlemen what you just saw here."
"I think you do."