All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

vtchem75 vtchem75 OP
Aug 24, 2023 at 02:12 PM ET
Whit Stated Last Night at Bburg Sports Club....Ambivalence about Expansion
He detailed the pluses and minuses, which are many. He said its not his decision, but that T. Sands and the powers that be are in FAVOR of it.

28 Replies

H
HokieNoVA
Conference affiliation should be an AD-level decision. Its got nothing
to do with the academic side of the house. And those on the academic side appear to be ill equipped to deal with these sorts of issues.
Gator Hokie Gator Hokie
Sands is just awful.
hokie77 hokie77
Minus this potential expansion decision, why do you say he's awful?
M
Mercury
good to challenge him thanks
First his name is Gator Hokie. I would assume from the state of the Florida (and we see how crazy that state is). and the crazies out of control governance of FSU. Sands does quite well; grown the University , to around 40,000; increased significantly the university R&D base and ranking. Some of those folks with lacking academic well with all, normally takes that position on a university president. For the expansion, its very simple, if VT (as well as UVA feels), that the university is going to get more money without leaving the ACC, they are for it.
H
Hokie 04
He really is. Should have been more uproar at the time he was considered.
He seems like the type of guy who just hates everything about Tech. Let's put him in charge! Deceptive, subversive, destroying from within. But hey, he effectively infected Tech with his Berkeley values!
F
Femoyer74
Like what? Give example of your premise…
3TechFanz 3TechFanz
Of course sands would be. He’s a cal grad
Old Line Hokie Old Line Hokie
If the ACC adds those 3, the ACC will have added 6 private universities...
since 2004 (Miami, BC, Syracuse, Notre Dame, Stanford and SMU), 1 private-public in Pitt and 2 public universities (Tech and Louisville). Virginia Tech is the only true traditional large state university that the ACC has added. Meanwhile, the Big Ten and SEC have expanded with all large state universities except for USC. I'm disappointed that Tech is in favor of adding Calford and SMU but Tim Sands is a proud Cal guy and San Francisco native and has influenced the BOV to support the Calford expansion. I know some on here have "corrected" me that the BOV makes the decision but every article and podcast I've read or listened to has only mentioned the ACC presidents. I'm sure the folks at Cal have put some pressure on Sands since he got all three of his degrees from Berkeley.
S
Sunsetunderground
Not sure why everyone's down on Stanford
$36 Billion endowment. They plan to tap that to compete and fund a move to the ACC. They historically have excellent athletics. NIL will only help. Tied with Harvard as the number 3 school in the nation. What else do you need?
H
HOO86
Jim Harbaugh and David Shaw had very good football teams
Shaw faltered since COVID, and has been replaced. Stanford has proven to be very capable in football. I look at it as pulling in new P5 members doesn't come around very often for the ACC. So the ACC is taking advantage of it while it's an option. ** Edited by HOO86 at 8/24/2023, 4:53:35 PM
reestuart reestuart
combined average attendance of the 3 schools would barely break top 10
in the country. They combined for something like 90k per game. The ACC doesn't need more of that. I've warmed to the Pitt addition some (should have been WVU), but I think every other addition since VT/Miami have been flops that do nothing to enhance the conference.
VT Pez4Life VT Pez4Life
relax, the system will blow up within the decade. this is just temp
Old Line Hokie Old Line Hokie
I guess the next move will be to remove the P-2 schools that don't carry..
their weight.
H
HOO86
I'd like to see Northwestern come to the ACC
But I'm not counting on the Big Ten kicking anyone out. They can keep Rutgers. In the SEC I guess it would be Vandy. I'd bet the ACC would love to have them too.
H
Hokie 04
Dude, WHY?!
The last thing the ACC needs is more private (or wannabe private) schools who don't care.
S
Stech
3 new teams & 1 game makes it the same? Also, ND th ratings pull is reduced
Old Line Hokie Old Line Hokie
I forgot Cal because they always act like a private. ;)
Like a few ACC state schools do.
L
LonghornHokie
Cal is the biggest public university available on the board.
That said, if Calfordsmu is going to be a thing, I'd rather see the ACC go all in with OSU, WSU, and 1-3 more schools to create a legit western branch to the conference. Guess it's just too complicated and risky to go all in though.
S
Stech
Less Clemson 🏈, less FSU, less ND, less Miami what a disaster Jim Phillips
Time for you to retire with Larry Scott the Conference Killer!!
H
HOO86
You can solve that by adding a 9th Game.
The schools that play an annual SEC game will not want to because they all want a cupcake game OOC. Everybody else will probably want to.
BROman Hokie BROman Hokie
Yep, with 17, a 7-7-2 model would be close to what we have now
reestuart reestuart
i think Phillips was screwed from day 1. I don't know if he could have
done a decent job with a stronger foundation, but the ACC was screwed with that GOR.
H
Hokie83
Miami supposedly is in favor fwiw
** Edited by Hokie83 at 8/24/2023, 2:40:14 PM
S
Stech
I think you mean they were in favor of all of this, we need to stop listen-
ing to Miami and Notre Dame, we get weaker as a Conference every time.
S
Stech
Thanks, as in a favor to us?
vtchem75 vtchem75 OP
As,,,,,,in FAVOR of this expansion deal. Don't know its US, or not.
Depends where you stand on this issue, I guess. Seems like most Tech alums are not really pushing for this.
J
JohnsonCItyHokie
Of course they are. Disappointed and think these teams will weaken the
conference, but no surprise. ACC loves to sabotage itself.
T
TOUGH TURKEY
Weaken the ACC? With football powerhouses BC, WF and Duke
already in the conference , you must be kidding.