All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

A
Athens OP
May 10, 2025 at 12:46 PM ET
POTUS creating commission on college sports, issues include realignment
Led by Saban to address NIL, transfer portal, conference realignment and other issues. Surprised this hasn't been discussed yet.

20 Replies

CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie
At least that assures decades of litigation.
R
RVAHokie05
Yep. This needs a durable solution. Congress is the best route for that
Easier said than done of course.
V
VPI 1924
No pay. No portal.
Must be able to read and write.
Pylons Pylons
Good luck with that given the multiple court rulings in favor of both
Pay and portal.
S
Stech
Saban said on ESPN Game Day, there should only b about 30 teams in top tier
Does this mean P1 might be on the way? Does this mean that some SEC and B1G teams would be cut if so? I used to think 4 Conferences with 16 teams , or 64 total in tier 1, but if Saban sticks with what he said on Game Day, we could be cutting that in ~half. ** Edited by Stech at 5/10/2025, 3:50:46 PM
H
HouClone
Funny how the billionaire guy, Cody Campbell, and not Saban
will likely be the voice of reason for this committee for all of college football. Saban may want to look out for all college football's interests, but his subconscious bias for the SEC will be hard for him to do so. Cody Campbell mentioned pooling the media rights, aka sort of revenue sharing of conferences. When Saban thinks revenue sharing, he only thinks players and not conferences.
V
VPI_1998
I bet in his mind it's basically all SEC and B1G teams plus Notre Dame -
and minus the Vandy's and Northwestern's - nobody else allowed. Saban is as big a part of this mess as anyone but his number is wrong - it's only going to be a dozen because those dozen will eventually squeeze out the current mid-tier of the P2. Those dozen want it all and nobody else can play in their sandbox, and I for one say good riddance to them if they go create their super-league.
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
Saban won't be making the call on any of this.
Look. I like Saban. And if I were to form my own commission on college football, I'd like to have him on it. But this committee is not going to make the call on all of this unilaterally. I also think DJT, as a sportsman, wants to genuinely address some of the current problems. But I don't see him as knowledgeable enough on the college game to understand what really needs to be done. I would advise him to add more minds to his committee. I respect him for giving it a go. It's long overdue to be honest. And while DJT strikes me as more of a big city, pro sports guy, I do think he probably would do better than your average legislator. However, in the end, fixing college football will require more than an executive order, which only lasts the length of the president's tenure in office. WRT to the 30-team comment specifically. No matter where the line is drawn (20, 30, 40...), there is gonna be hell to pay. And that is why I don't support a hard floor selected by arbitrary means. Either do relegation and promotion. Or set a standard, and allow any school that meets it to participate (stadium size, home attendance, academic standards, etc.).
S
Stech
Understand your sentiment, but don’t underestimate Saban w/ POTUS backing
him. ** Edited by Stech at 5/10/2025, 6:19:03 PM
N
NokieHokie
LOL those 2 should not be overestimated.
S
Stech
The whole staffing explosion for 🏈 started when Saban left the 🐬, this
move without limits has made it so only a handful of teams could win a National Championship. Then Georgia, Texas, Michigan, Ohio State etc followed. However, he owned the SEC and College Football until they caught up. It’s ironic he is going to be in the lead for creating checks and balances. I guess he’s an expert in how to kill them, but will he really have any desire to create them? Or is he a wolf in sheep’s clothing?
Femoyer Hokie Femoyer Hokie
P1 will require equity. Revenue sharing, etc.
The power schools will not want to share the value they bring with the likes of Mississippi State and Rutgers.
E
EDGEMAN
Or Maryland, NW, Vandy, Kentucky, USC-E, Indiana, Purdue...
V
VPI_1998
shoot - I would go even further - even schools like Auburn, Michigan State,
Ole Miss, Arkansas, Missouri, etc. - they will ALL get squeezed by un-equal revenue sharing. As much as they want to be considered top tier football programs they are not, and the Bama's, Michigan's, Ohio State's and Texas' of the world will take everything if they can. Femoyer is right - let the dozen or so go off and play each other endlessly and everyone else can build a good league that millions of folks will watch - not everyone on earth only watches Bama, OSU, Texas and Michigan.
Femoyer Hokie Femoyer Hokie
Yep. P1 can’t happen soon enough. Let’s get busy building sensible
conferences for the rest of us. We will have plenty of good company. I won’t even feel “left behind”.
G
GCHokie34
You mean to tell me...
The group who wants to "restore" competitive balance to college sports is headed by the former football coaches at Alabama and Auburn? It's almost like that's not what they're after at all
manassashoo manassashoo
There has never been competitive balance in college sports.There were
unlimited scholarships, under the table payments, million dollar facilities, no educational requirements for acceptance or eligibility, etc. Whatever the current situation becomes, competitive balance will not be part of it.
S
Stech
This is true, but U's like UVA & Tech made NYD Bowls after 85 scholarship
limit was finally approved. It's why Welsh and Beamer could get to them when neither school ever came close to them before. Then Nick Saban negotiated an NFL staff with Alabama and he dominated the SEC and all of college football, until a small group like Georgia, Ohio State etc did the same. Now, with NIL IMHO way more than paying players, it is completely slanted to about 5 schools. ESPN and Fox are driving this, I was involved when NASCAR was everywhere and growing at unbelievable rate. However, the networks started focusing on a handful of drivers and teams and they totally blew it. I was on the corporate sponsorship side of it, and you could just see the fans flocking to just a handful of drivers/teams. They are doing the same thing with College Football. Watch Alabama now that they don't have Saban. Georgia is already better than them. What would have happened if Ryan Day lost to Tennessee? He's probably not even coaching right now. That's what happened to NASCAR, some of those drivers got families, and they didn't drive as aggressive. Or the families are not as supportive about them recruiting all the time, and they go to the NFL. The networks are rolling the dice by putting so many eggs in one basket, their goals are so short term focused, they can look invincible, all the way up until they are not anymore.
2
2hhoop3
The irony of all the names.......
mentioned in that article with the backdrop of likely other congressional and senate members who will surely seek to ride the coattails for their own personal agenda makes this a colossal CF in the making that will relegate the original NIL CF to a minor traffic snafu. Adding Saban and Tuberville is akin to putting Bernie Madoff in charge of the SEC(Securities and Exchange Commission to be clear). ** Edited by 2hhoop3 at 5/10/2025, 4:50:42 PM
A
ancient alien 2018
LOL!! The fox and the challenged chicken. What could
possibly go wrong with those two in charge?
Link: help!!