All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

JRHokie JRHokie OP
Apr 17, 2025 at 06:10 AM ET
Just a True Answer if One Knows...
How much NIL $$$ is Whit giving this Program ??? PS.. I hope the hell he is not short changing it like he did the men's basketball program. Carry on..

60 Replies

I
I love VT!
I'll just say this and then "carry on"...
WBB and MBB are two very different situations...for a variety of reasons. That, IMO, is good news for WBB.
S
saret
Technically, Whit isn't giving any program any NIL money.
It's what I call a true lie. Technically, NIL is between a student-athlete and a 3rd party (for VT, that would be Triumph and The Hokie Way). We all know this whole NIL thing is a charade, or a true lie. But, as this true lie has become known as what it is, all schools are starting to be hoisted on their own petards.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Well............ ask Mike Young... carry on..
Whit has the say, Sands has the say, and I guess the BOV . Sure as hell not the NCAA ..LOL
S
saret
I think @Chris Coleman has written about MBB's situation.
I repeat, I said technically. Of course Whit is responsible. The NILs are responsible. From Whit's viewpoint the current NIL grift is a wonderful thing. It gives him somewhat of a plausible deniability. Everyone knows this whole NIL system is a charade.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
You know the News Doesn't just come from TSL .......
Which is Great. Enough said by me ... Is Whit telling TSL these things? I remember Jim Weaver has great standards on things like this. I bet Will can tell ya about Jim W.
S
saret
Those of us who have been on here (looking at your Joined date)
a while, remember Jim Weaver. Probably more fondly now with our current financial situation. JW ran in the black. Unfortunately, most of our "News" does come from TSL at present, because Whit doesn't communicate, and when he does, he does it poorly. I think we get what news we get because of good "investigative" reporting by TSL, and from members of this board. But I'll let @Will Stewart speak to that. ** Edited by saret at 4/17/2025, 5:01:16 PM
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Good...
I go back with VT sports in the 60's, way before these sites was around. I figure you do too which really doesn't matter. Just saying everything doesn't stay in Blacksburg or with your connections. I quit even wanting inside gossip about eight years ago..But if I need to know things like you. I can.. Carry on..Go Hoikes..
S
saret
Yeah, I was at VT from 67 to 71. And, as far as "inside gossip" goes
I must admit that there was some tranquility about VT before I retired to Blacksburg (2003). That was also true for my first few years of retirement. Being up close and seeing what's going on has its disadvantages.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Love It.. yep... Go Hokies
H
Hokster
Coach Duffy is not going to be here long or any other coach worth the money
if there are not enough funds with NIL to develop and support an NCAA Tournament level team. Plus we don't want to just be an NCAA Tournament team, we want to be a successful NCAA Tournament team and sustain the success. Seriously makes you wonder how much is available to the women's program. Seems like we are very limited. Kind of odd that we only have gotten one commitment from the transfer portal and one that wouldn't take much NIL money. Especially when we desperately need post players. I mean there is basically a starting position up for grabs and we can't seem to find a post player at all. Do we not have the money? Makes you wonder.
I
I love VT!
So the answer is no, you don't know how much NIL is available to WBB.
S
saret
No one knows how much NIL money is available to any team at any school.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
You painting a big brush with that statement .. LOL..
Goodness !!
S
saret
Okay, Am I wrong?
I
I love VT!
...which obviously doesn't stop anyone from assuming the worst.
S
saret
Couldn't agree more. It's utter chaos. But in the end, who's paying for
this chaos,..........fans/donors.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Look No farther than the AD & Sands !!
They would love for VT to drop back a division level in sports !! Mark me down for saying this again !!!
V
VTCALS72
I pretty much agree, Sands and the BOV set the priority
and that priority clearly has not been to go all in on providing athletics with the funding required to at least be competitive with the P2. Again JMHO but I think Sands and the BOV are calling the shots that many blame on the AD.
M
mghokie
I'm confident you are wrong about that. Sands believes
we can be competitive. So, a question to you, where do you think the funds would come from that the are supposedly withholding?
V
VTCALS72
Thanks fo a real good question
If the admin of VT wanted to, they are the ones who can raise the money through, not the Hokie Club, but the much bigger, more professional University wide sources of funding that are pushing VT ever closer to AAU status. Heck maybe even that level providing the scholarship $$$ as an example. And given todays revenue players come from all over, maybe paying the difference in the in state and out of state tuition, freeing those $$$ to revenue sports operations would be helpful. That and for sure, one university wide funding raising campaign so no departments are fighting each other for the same $$$. Then raise student activity fees. Seems we had a thread sometimes back that JMU, through their activity fees essentially makes all their students the old Golden Hokie contributors. But be clear about one thing, I have said our admin has not, IMHO provided Whit the funding it would take to cover some to a lot of the complaints against him. I really do think Whit is having to juggle available money way more than most think. There is a place that DR Sands could be all in on funding at a higher than competitive level and that is after all of college sports realignment or at least this phase of it, stops. I can see a strategy to just get through this re alignment, then see the exact level VT will be at. Realignment will never go all the way away going forward but the current one is the big one for the short and intermediate future. Once this is behind us, then I expect Dr. Sands will go (comparatively) more all in than now. The overwhelming odds are that no school can break out of the levels the big media has already assigned. So until that re alignment of schools and TV money gets all the schools the big media has use for in the places they want them is complete, it may not necessarily a bad strategy to know this is a time to "hold em." Then post realignment, go all in on making VT the best of the level we are assigned. Of course the budgets for a mid level conference will probably be more in line with what we spend now. Being #1 in revenue support for a FSU,Clemson, UNC and Miami less ACC will be a lot less than now.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Whoever or Whatever.. WE SEE IT..
And being in a Division of 5P schools. It Sucks for the Sports at all levels. Either Get the Hell In or Drop back !! No in betweens ..
V
VTCALS72
Only disagreement with this post is the division of 5P schools
Seems to me we are in a division of currently 2 conferences and not the top division.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Still P5.. Division 1 , if that helps..
Next level down is what the powers in charge would like for VT !! Sad but true, they want to stay out of Money Game for Div.1 sports. But Charging for it like we are in Big Time Football !! Only time and ESPN $$$ will make things clearer by their Money given to the "Elite" Conferences..
M
MrFantastic!
I doubt that but
Sands doesn't have Torgerson feel for VT athletics. Whit has been dealt bad hand in some ways. I do think we need reset but i will not blame it all on him,
2
2hhoop3
While hand dealt.....
almost certainly has an impact, Whit particularly, and Sands/BOV tangentially, bear responsibility for the current state of things. There is more than a decade of opportunity to have been proactive versus reactive to the changes both in conference and in collegiate athletics and I think being dealt a bad hand is likely as much excuse as a realistic explanation and most would agree that a decade makes the situation their own.
M
MrFantastic!
Burrus hall is a HUGE reason
2
2hhoop3
The admin plays a part......
no doubt, however, despite the continued protestations of some, the bus stops first in the athletic complex and there really is little doubt about that for people close to the matter.
UTPr0sim UTPr0sim
Duffy isn't a strong portal person. (See last year). So I wouldn't get
too upset. It may be a weakness that does her in long term if the NIL gets crazy in Womans BB.
J
j9hokie
A little early to make sure a firm conclusion. Only a year in the ACC, on
the east coast, and with this new staff (which, in my personal opinion, was partially selected because they can recruit). Personally I think she is gonna be great. Give her some time.
S
saret
I don't know if that is true or not. We have such a small
sample size. Unless you know more than we do.
M
MrFantastic!
She desires
Recruiting and retaining. Portal is dirty business VT not strong at.
Stork Stork
Unfortunately, this year she doesn’t have much choice. 5 gone from a 11
player team. And 3 freshman won’t be able to step right in. Last year she got a very late start with the portal due to her coaching hire. So I think she’s working hard at the portal. It’s still very early in the process. She’ll get it done. Patience as David Cunningham reminded everyone.
H
Hokster
It is just frustrating seeing so many other teams get multiple commitments.
T
thunar
We are returning a lot of talent. The way i see it.
We need a big and bench players. ** Edited by thunar at 4/17/2025, 12:41:16 PM
Stork Stork
Patience grasshopper
M
mrknowitall
until Nil money is capped , the money teams will get the best players
S
saret
Being nitpicky here, but how do you cap something when you
don't know any amounts?
T
thunar
The conferences are already looking at Congress to regulate it.
Then it would be against the law for people to not know amounts.
S
saret
I think that would be difficult for Congress to do that, especially in
light of their stance on dark money/PACs in politics (as an aside, @Will Stewart , this is not meant as a political post. If you want to strike it, please do). Now, that being said, Congress has no problem being hypocritical.
T
thunar
They have done it before. All the charges that people would get back in
day (prior to NIL). Would be laws enacted by Congress.
S
saret
Again, I'm not arguing. I'm just not optimistic at all that
Congress can be a solution.
T
thunar
Oh i am just pointing it out. And yeah congress hasnt exactly jumped at it.
M
mrknowitall
congress and solution is rarely used in the same sentence
M
MrFantastic!
I think she likes VT more than Brooks
S
saret
Right now.
M
MrFantastic!
True but
if she leaves I think it will be harder than most think. ND and few the blue bloods sure she will leave. That said this job is good one and can be better if invested better.
S
saret
I agree. This job was a step up from Marquette. She's still
proving herself. I don't think she'll be looking anytime soon (however long that is). I think she'll be successful in her own right, at some point. And, if she is that successful, and an opportunity presents itself to move up, I hope she takes it. Why? Because that would mean she'll have been successful.
V
VAHokie89
There would likely be no impetus to move on barring a series of successful
of successful runs deep in the NCAA. Right now, barring getting VT into the top 2-3 of the ACC and sweet 16 or 8 runs... I don't see her leaving. Of course, an alma mater could come calling or there could be an issue. However, to move UP would require a significant degree of sucess. That may take some more recruiting classes/portal hits over time. ** Edited by VAHokie89 at 4/18/2025, 1:32:33 PM
S
saret
Agreed. That's why I said her leaving would be a good thing.
It would probably mean she was successful.
J
j9hokie
Hoping no need to "move up" cause we will be "up"! That is what CMD is
going for. She wants to earn it and put us on top.
S
saret
I concur. I'm really pleased with her.
One of our few bright spots.
Stork Stork
I don’t fret about it in the least.
I feel womens’ sports are so much different than men’s. In many different ways. And also, you’re telling me we went from having enough NIL $ to support a #24 WNBA drafted player, and a #6 wnba drafted player at the same time. Along with bringing in very strong portal players over several years, all less than 2 years ago? And now that money is non-existent? Sorry, not buying it. There are plenty of other reasonable factors involved, that explain things very well. No worries. Of course, if VVV stops dumping his boatloads of cash in Duffy’s lap, then maybe we would have a crisis. ** Edited by Stork at 4/17/2025, 8:03:51 AM
G
George Baylor
Maybe WHY we haven't got Portals. Shame if true!
Stork Stork
Hey George, Matilda, Rose, Lani, Olivia, D’asia, Taylor, Ashley, and Kayana
all say you’re full of baloney.
WestEndHokie39 WestEndHokie39
What do they know?
1977hokie 1977hokie
Have to admit it’s concerning to me too,
I’ll not draw a conclusion until this portal cycle is completed, but we have a few big needs to fill if we want to climb to contender status in the ACC. I’ve stated before, if CMD is short on NIL funds, let it be known to the loyal fan base, fund raise to cure it
J
j9hokie
I would be all in on a fund raiser for WBB NIL. Wish we would have one.
S
saret
Or, we need to find a @VTChip for WBB.
JRHokie JRHokie OP
Damn right.. only $$$ I would give..
Angry Birds Angry Birds
While I don’t know the answer
I feel like the way KB left, feeling like he needed more, fired up whit to an extent. I’m sure Duffy was promised something fairly well in order to come here. Her assistant pool would seem to bear that out. They’re all qualified to be head coach’s in their own respect. Not that I want to defend whit, but that was the optics I gathered last year.