All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

T
Tay790 OP
Apr 04, 2024 at 12:08 AM ET
Any Marquette WBB? Wonder if they’re in a soap opera @ the moment.

34 Replies

F
Flemington Hokie
I’d compare MB Marquette to KB JMU records
He made NCAA second round in 1of 6 appearances over 15 years. She made NCAA 1st round 3x over 4 years. Would have in COVID year. If you (unfairly) extrapolate, she’d have ~12 NCAAs in 15 years at a non-P5 school Given better recruiting available to her at VT, I’d expect strong results. The BE is still tougher than the CAA KB coached in. ** Edited by Flemington Hokie at 4/4/2024, 9:06:11 AM
V
Va AandM
Agree. Add 2 years at Miami OH. KB % fell a lot at VT
and she’s always been in post-season play. Her Marquette win % is better than KB at VT. I’ve seen absolute % quoted. KB James Madison University: 337–122 (.734) 193–56 (.775) Virginia Tech: 180–82 (.687) ACC 76–60 (.559) MB Marquette: 110–46 (.705) BE 64–30 (.681) Miami (OH): 44–20 (.688) MAC 25–11 (.694) ** Edited by Va AandM at 4/4/2024, 9:20:48 AM
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
The only board I can find is the 247 board. The few posters over there....
...don't seem to be too upset at her leaving. I don't wanna be that guy, but so far I have two observations: 1) Her record against UConn was not great. 2) I get Courtney Banghart vibes from her.
D
dallasvt
From reading muscoop (different board) when Buzz was leaving, I discovered
a few opinions that many Marquette fans on that board have about Tech: - Marquette is superior to Tech as a university in every way except football - No coach would leave Marquette for Tech unless the coach is very bad and is going to be fired by Marquette anyway
G
Glen Allen Hokie
Let's see...
Tall - check Blonde - check Long Hair - check Active on Sideline - check She MUST be a Banghart clone. Unbelievable...
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
That has nothing to do with it.
It was her demeanor in her post game press conferences, of which I watched she
S
Stech
Message Board self proclaimed experts, the fantasy experts w/ no experience
do make you think 🤔🤔 though, which is good, as long as you don’t take their advice without knowing their experience, like pretty much everything in life. Be careful of plane passengers with no experience telling you how to fly the plane.
V
VTCALS72
Wow, just wow!!!!
So your #1 priority is to beat the best on a regular basis without the best players and $$$$$?
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
No, my #1 priority is to win the conference which usually means you have to
be able to be the best teams in your own leaugue.
V
VTCALS72
????????
O
ombandit
Is anybody’s record against UConn great,… KB’s record against…
Iowa and LSU wasn’t “great” either. And besides that, of course WE know that some posters are NEVER satisfied… ** Edited by ombandit at 4/4/2024, 6:40:22 AM ** Edited by ombandit at 4/4/2024, 6:50:30 AM
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
Yeah but he didn't play Iowa & LSU every year like Marquette does w/ UConn
in fact it looks like they play 2-3 times a year. Her record against them was: 0-3 in '23-24 1-2 in '22-23 0-2 in '21-22 0-3 in '20-'21 We can say, "oh no one beats UConn" but is that how we're going to feel if we get beat constantly by Stanford, ND, NCST, and Louisville? We need a coach that knows how to beat the top teams. I'm not saying she's going to be a bad coach or she's a bad hire, but this is a red flag for me. JMO.
R
Rockfish40
Beamer's record against and VT's for that matter against Miami was 0 for
before 1995 in football. I believe we can give her a chance to beat better teams as we have more resources here than Marquette does. (different sport but same principle) ** Edited by Rockfish40 at 4/4/2024, 10:11:23 AM
M
MrFantastic!
Success is hosting regionals
VT has done that for two coaches
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
Yes and won the ACC. So yeah, that's a big difference from what Duffy has
done so far.
M
MrFantastic!
Not yet
Brooks never did at jmu Time tells
HokieAllMyLife HokieAllMyLife
What was KB’s record against ND?
H
Hokie1992
But who beats UConn, LSU and South Carolina?
To beat them you have to out-recruit them. I’d say nobody is deciding between Marquette and UConn to play WBB. How many times did Kenny Brooks go head to head with South Carolina for recruits. If we define success as beating UConn or South Carolina, all of our other spending and effort should reflect that. As has been documented, we’re defining success as winning an ACC football championship. If Hicks can have the WBB in the upper half of the ACC, that will be a success
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
I'm not definind success as beating UConn or South Carolina. I'm defining
success as being able to beat the top teams in your own league. That's what you have to do to win your league. Marquette was not able to beat UConn more than once while Duffy was their coach. And thus she never won that league. So my concern is, can she beat the top teasm in the ACC? I hope so, but great coaches find a way to do more with less. Now if you want to say that winning the ACC is not our goal, then fine we can lower our expectations. BTW, ND has a 2-1 record against UConn over the last 3 years so there are teams that can beat them.
hokiepro hokiepro
We won our league without beating ND under Brooks
He was 0-3 the last 2 seasons vs ND If she can beat them it’ll be an improvement Matter of fact they beat us by double digits each of those 3 Ls ** Edited by hokiepro at 4/4/2024, 7:25:44 AM
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
Yes but the difference is, he won the league. Duffy never did.
Kenny also consistently beat NCST, Louisville, UNC, and Duke over the last few years. I don't want this to sound like I'm bashing Duffy, but I'm not seeing any "oh wow look at thats" on her resume. ** Edited by UpstateSCHokie at 4/4/2024, 7:26:30 AM ** Edited by UpstateSCHokie at 4/4/2024, 7:29:24 AM
H
Hokie1992
Duffy still has a great resume
She played at Notre Dame. She has a .700 winning percentage. She’s win 20+ games every year accept the Covid year when she won 19. Duffy’s teams made three trips to the WNIT and three to the NCAA tourney. Now a critique might be her teams have never lasted past the first round. But overall, Duffy has had a great career in women’s basketball as a player and coach. We’ll see if she can beat Notre Dame, Stanford, UVa, Duke and UNC. But given the resources, there is zero reason to think she’s not able to keep the women’s basketball program roughly where it was under Brooks.
hokiepro hokiepro
Difference here is that we should be able to draw better level of recruits
Than Marquette So we can compete with those teams We have an ACC & Final 4 banner to show recruits whether Duffy brought it here or not
J
j9hokie
There will be some rebuild time no matter what
Need to recruit players, teach them your system, get a staff in place, adjust to the new administration. It is not push button.
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
I hope you're right!
Marquette as also won their conference (regular season champs in 2018 and 2019) and tournament champs in 2017. Admittedly they have never made a final four, or even sweet 16 but they've been to the NCAA 15 out of the last 30 years.
H
Hokie83
I think she is about as good of a hire Whit could have made
I think she will do very well at VT jmo
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
And again, I'm not complaining - just point out a couple of minor areas
of concern. I hope she makes us all forget about everything Kenny has done.
O
ombandit
Don’t know if that would be a red flag for me, but I understand your logic-
WBB is so dependent on height in the front court. You’ve got to have that aircraft carrier at least at center or forward and UConn always has/had that. I’d have to look at how Duffy’s teams matched up against UConn position wise.
hokiepro hokiepro
They won one! That’s NOT bad for that league
vs UCONN ** Edited by hokiepro at 4/4/2024, 7:23:09 AM
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
Also, the last time Marquette won the BE tournament was the yr before Duffy
was hired as the coach - and of course UConn was not in the BE that year.
O
ombandit
You’re right, terrible hire-LOL
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
I never said that.
G
goatdriver
I am glad we have a coach, and one that looks promising as well.
She IS OUR coach now, so we should get on board and give her our support. This is a big move to the ACC as you allude, so having us behind her can only be positive.
H
H0KIEFAN
They should hire Lindsey Hicks
poetic justice for KB to set that in motion?