All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

hokiepro hokiepro OP
May 26, 2022 at 11:36 PM ET
OkSt pitcher who is shutting out Clemson
Cleared for take off

23 Replies

SouthFLHokie SouthFLHokie
Did she get called for any illegal pitches?
GCHokieof91 GCHokieof91
Clemson pitcher Thompson was just as bad
Stork Stork
I’m convinced it’s the amount of pressure the opposing coach puts on the
umps. Pointing it out. The word is out on her. Especially since she’s so good. Every coach will be pointing it out to the umps.
H
hokietony
IMHO, she is more egregious at it than others ....
there is no doubt that a good percentage of the pitchers leave the ground but what I see is she has more elevation than the others. I think that is why she is getting called but I will admit, that is not what others believe (could be the O&M glasses being worn by others but who knows).
D
dallasvt
I asked you before what constitutes more egregious, and you never
replied (see link). So, it seems, in your mind, more elevation means more egregious. I think you are making it simpler than it it is. By the book, Arkansas' pitcher was illegal on every pitch last night. Clemson's pitcher was illegal on every pitch last night. It was not mentioned once on the telecast because it was not called once. Yet, we have to hear how Lemley is illegal on every pitch as if she is the only one.
H
hokietony
I would say her height off the ground ....
but who knows. There is a reason she is getting called and I believe that is it but it is all wild speculation at this point.
D
dallasvt
I agree that is why, but I think it is further proof of the absurdity of
the rule. For example, is Lemley, who is being called for IPs, getting more of an advantage than a pitcher who covers more horizontal distance on her leap and is not getting called for IPs (rhetorical question)?
HokieAllMyLife HokieAllMyLife
Tony, Tone, Toni..... Where to begin....
Are we discussing elevation or pitching rules as a whole? If elevation, watch Jordy Bahl from Oklahoma. Tell me what you think and then do a deep dive on how many illegal pitches each has had called. Pitching rules as a whole? Watch any screwball pitcher such as Sandercock from FSU. Their lead foot almost always lands outside the pitching lane but yet no calls for that. Seems to me that provides just as much advantage as leaping by adding increased spin on the ball. The issue is selective enforcement. AND I use selective rather than inconsistent because I think umpires are picking when and where and against whom they enforce it. Just makes the application of the rule seem kinda sketchy and agenda driven. Of course, as Hokies, we seem to get the short end of the stick once again. All that aside, Go Hokies! Swamp People is a great show. Love what they do to them gators...
B
bushartbs525
The videos of Bahl that I’ve seen
show she land completely outside the circle, and it appears that she releases the ball outside the circle. Yet it isn’t called.
H
hokietony
It would seem that the number of times Lemley is called ....
seems to confirm my wildly thought out speculation. I don't believe in conspiracies so there would have to be a reason she is getting called and the others are not, correct? The reality is that I will stick to my assumption that she is worse than the others, that is until somebody gives me a better reason or theory. wow, we have been beating this dead horse for a good month know. It sure has legs. VT wins this weekend!!!!
hokiepro hokiepro OP
Leaving the ground is leaving the ground; the rule is dumb
As Pete says; they’re punishing her athleticism. If others aren’t being called, she shouldn’t be either just because she’s more explosive and gets off the ground more
H
hokietony
Nobody is disagreeing about the dumbness of the rule ....
Pete might be right. I just see a little more height with her, I think that is why she is getting called.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
And THAT is the egregious the enforcement. The rule has no nuance built in
hokiepro hokiepro OP
And that’s what I’m saying: off the ground is off the ground
TomTurkey TomTurkey
And everyone should be penalized, in other words.
hokiepro hokiepro OP
Well; here’s the point: if their own ace does it; maybe they’ll be less
Likely to point it out because it could backfire on them when we point out same
Stork Stork
And it certainly is easy enough to forward video of these pitchers
illegally pitching on to the league office. (Or whoever supervises umpires) Start making it a point that everyone does it. And it needs to be called on everyone. Or change the rule. We certainly do it in football. After every game. Why not softball? Minimal staff maybe?
E
EDGEMAN
Coaches try anything when their team is getting smoked
See F$U in Tally.
J
jhs93
FSU didn't even get close to smoked?
E
EDGEMAN
They were getting swept at home, so...
HokieAllMyLife HokieAllMyLife
Would have been swept for the 1st time at home - EVER
which would have been worse than getting smoked. They were smoked in game 2.
D
dallasvt
Arkansas pitcher, Clemson pitcher, etc.
Italian Stallion Italian Stallion
Yes I noticed that as well. Clearly a violation but.......no call.