All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

B
BigDaddyHokie OP
May 08, 2026 at 11:14 AM ET
Well with 1 out and the bases loaded and a pitch in the dirt
and a walk to score a run I would have subbed for another pitcher. That's why I'm watching on TV I guess. That home plate ump was inconsistent and made some bad calls IMO.

28 Replies

TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
To lose track of the count is inexcusable. All four umps should carry...
...indicators. HP should indicate key counts with the fingers on each hand, e.g., 3 and 2 for a full count. Any of the four could correct the unofficial scoreboard for count and outs. Inexcusable!
King of Hokies King of Hokies
2mo
He lost track of the count because he called a ball on a strike right down
the middle of the plate. Then his brain told him, "that should have been a strike, and he recorded in his brain as such." Guarantee that's what happened.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
Possibly since it only happened once...that we're aware.
hokiepro hokiepro
2mo
Might be true but Addy wouldn’t have K’d if she knew it was 2 strikes
That guy was really not good behind the plate. It didn’t hurt one team more than the other though. He seemed to be calling the outside corner vs LHH or inside to RHB The WORST was the called strike vs Castine. That was as bad as the one vs Nora last weekend Speaking of Noraâ€Ļshe seemed visibly frustrated last night with her ABs. Hope to see her bounce back big today. And I just KNEW that HR last weekend was what Zoe neededâ€ĻHuge RBI double going with the pitch away to RC And Annika may have had a HR at TSP; Palmer is maybe 210 down linesâ€Ļat TSP that’s probably just over the wall inside the fair pole
KiloZulu KiloZulu
2mo
I umpire slow pitch softball in the winters down in FL...
And all of the umpires carry clickers regardless of behind the plate or in the field.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
It's called quality assurance or CYA
V
VTsportscaster
2mo
On occasion, the ump will correct me but not very often
The incident yesterday we would have been making fun of the ump for ringing her up. We’d all be saying, that’s only 2 strikes idiot, lol. What happened this season, a base umpire wasn’t being demonstrative in their illegal pitch call so we were unaware in the press box. Home plate would correct me with the count and we’d all say “what that’s not the count” but then figured out what was happening. Got a little more eagle eye on the base umps that game.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
"Communication is the problem to the answer," according to 10CC.
One of an ump's prime directives is communicating to the teams, scoreboard operator, and fans. No excuses!
V
VTsportscaster
2mo
Oh for sure, most times if I think I’m off, ump corrects me
Most are pretty good with communication, but apparently not last night. UVA was asleep at the wheel if the scoreboard was wrong and if that’s why he rung her up. I would have been embarrassed if that happened to me. Announcer even mentioned it, bad look all around.
King of Hokies King of Hokies
2mo
See my post above. He knew she should have been out because he previously
called a pitch right down the middle a ball. His brain overcorrected and he told himself there were now 2 strikes even though he called the ball. That ball call was worse than the strike call 1 ft outside and low later on Castine.
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
That wasn't the incident I was referring to but you're correct. There are
3 teams on the field. Sometimes the officiating crew is the best team on the field. Not last night which is bad because this is the championship tournament - supposed to have the best of the best, not some jackleg who can't remember the count. Some umps think they're so good they don't need the indicator. Well if you're so good you don't need an indicator how about being so good you don't need a cup umping behind the plate?
V
VAHokie89
2mo
At least the other umpires had the sense to update him
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
I was just piling on. Used rubber bands for downs in REC FB. Each official!
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
Rachel got robbed of a walk on an awful 3rd strike call.
Raleigh Hokie Raleigh Hokie
2mo
He either blinked, burped, or both on that one.
Everybody laughed at that call, including Rachel.
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
Expect he farted. . . .one in the brain and the other. . . .well, you know!
KiloZulu KiloZulu
2mo
That said, why not wait for the call instead of assuming a ball and looking
foolish?
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
I don't think Rachel looked foolish if that's what you mean. Rachel didn't
assume anything - it WAS a ball. It was the ump who assumed it was a strike and it was he who looked foolish and I'll bet even the pitcher was surprised.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
Only the ump looked foolish.
D
drc1956
2mo
I mostly agree but ...
That pitch was soooo obviously a ball.
KiloZulu KiloZulu
2mo
If you drop your bat and head toward first base because as a batter you
Think it was ball four, are you batting or umpiring? Not a good umpire but again, as a batter, bat not umpire.
T
Techdady
2mo
It’s called ‘selling the call’ and oftentimes works against poor umpiring
T
Techdady
2mo
Zoe Yeager is a master at that technique, no wonder she leads the team in
Walks with 33. Aldridge very good at it also.
S
SHPHOKIE
2mo
In the next inning that same pitch was called a ball for the hoo batter.
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
It was like that guy was trying to use The Force like he was a Jedi knight.
Kind of looked like Obi Wan.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
"I have a bad feeling about this!"
laphroaig laphroaig
2mo
I am your FATHER!
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
Not so loud! đŸ˜ŗ