All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

BUGGZY
Joined: 08/15/2002
Posts: 14,814
Likes: 134

It's wild to me any AQ model with different numbers of AQs is even a thing

if you have AQs, every conference/division/league/member group of your chosen name should have the exact same number of AQs, period. the whole purpose of at-larges is to give more spots to the bigger/better/richer members. NFL: every division gets 1 AQ, 6 at larges MLB: every division gets 1 AQ, 4 at larges NBA: every division gets 1 AQ, 6 at larges, 8 play-ins for final 4 spots NHL: every division gets 3 AQ, 4 at larges NCAA: every conference gets 1 AQ, 37 at larges etc etc If the SEC and the B1G are so great, they will get the lion's share of at-larges anyway. Even considering an unbalanced AQ model is short sighted and flat out stupid. EDIT: European Soccer comps have uneven AQs, BUT they are changed annually based on performance, so no nation is guaranteed more spots (though the usual suspects of England, Spain, Germany and Italy tend to keep the most spots year in and year out). So if the SEC and B1G want uneven AQs, base it on past results in the playoff...conferences that go deeper more often will get more spots the next year! ** Edited by BUGGZY at 5/29/2025, 10:11:24 PM ** Edited by BUGGZY at 5/29/2025, 10:32:50 PM
Posted: 05/29/2025 at 10:05 PM ET
(In response to this post by RandomAsianGuy)

Thread Replies (11)

Full Thread →
Phillips should speak up.
RandomAsianGuy 05/29/25 08:25 PM ET
Phillips' position doesn't matter, nor does Yormark's...
BROman Hokie 05/30/25 12:36 PM ET
It's wild to me any AQ model with different numbers of AQs is even a thing
BUGGZY 05/29/25 10:05 PM ET
The point of them this time is to allow the 3v6 and 4v5 play-ins.
Truthahn 05/30/25 02:51 PM ET
You're spot on.
Baltimore_Hokie 05/30/25 09:46 AM ET
I you don't know, look up what a "Hobson's Choice" is.
VTCALS72 05/30/25 01:19 PM ET
Even if this is a Hobson's Choice scenario, the correct choice is the-
Baltimore_Hokie 05/30/25 03:10 PM ET
So you think VT has a de Gaul on the bench?
VTCALS72 05/30/25 04:36 PM ET
So, let me just get this straight here-
Baltimore_Hokie 05/30/25 04:54 PM ET
Well, you got it as crooked as possible
VTCALS72 05/30/25 07:42 PM ET
Agree, but with a caution. The G5 conferences are hostages
HokieAl 05/30/25 12:50 PM ET
Anything that is bad for the ACC and Big 12 is doubly bad for the G5.
Baltimore_Hokie 05/30/25 03:14 PM ET