All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

David Cunningham David Cunningham OP
Apr 03, 2026 at 02:53 PM ET
Virginia Tech Women’s Basketball Guard Sophie Swanson To Transfer
Link: Story

19 Replies

J
j9hokie
4mo
Nice little opening for Lanie Grant :D. If money grew on trees...
But maybe Kate Sears can earn that spot on the wing
V
VAHokie89
4mo
The 2 mins a game spot?
J
j9hokie
4mo
The "we are looking for somehone who can shoot the 3" spot. Were
hoping Swanson could be that, but wasn't. Bet Lanie could fill that sharpshooter slot. BTW, no need to be snide. Not impressive. ** Edited by j9hokie at 4/3/2026, 9:31:22 PM
V
VAHokie89
4mo
Wasn't being snide. There has been this "Sears" talk
Suffren and Wells are more likely to earn that 3 spot barring another transfer in... IF Sears was going to kind of replace Swanson, it is a 2-minutes a game role. ** Edited by VAHokie89 at 4/3/2026, 9:56:22 PM
M
mrknowitall
4mo
Why are you always belittling Sears when you haven't seen her play?
V
VAHokie89
3mo
Belittling?
I am not belittling her. I am not verbally or emotionally abusing her, causing her mental anguish of self-esteem because of disrespect. I am arguing against the hero-worship, automatic assumption that she will be great this coming season, that she will automatically move into a starting role simply because of her high school accolades. I have provided largely rational reasons why, such as having 5 players in front of her all of whom have had significant playing time or starting roles that are not likely to change. Nelson and wenzel are going to play 30+ mins a game. Wells and suffren are likely to get their 15-20 mins a game. I have also given the caveat that it is possible that one of those 5 may not be here or we might bring in a transfer that might provide another barrier to playing time or that baker might get time at the three. We have also seem other freshman with accolades get limited time, so nothing is automatic. I have not precluded the potential for sears to contribute or make an impact. When it is time to preview next year’s team, she will be discussed as a guard who has the possibility of making an impact. But there are takes out there that assume she will automatically have a big impact and some of those takes don’t take into account the factors that can limit that potential. .
M
mrknowitall
3mo
We will see,that's all we can say
J
j9hokie
4mo
Ah, I see. Thanks for the clarification
Stork Stork
4mo
Bet Coach has a sharpshooter lined up.
UpstateSCHokie UpstateSCHokie
4mo
Do you think her injury set her back to the point she just couldn't recover
V
VAHokie89
4mo
Not really
The injury was not a season-long one. There were five players in front of her, she shot poorly, and defensively she was not a strong player against ACC-competition
R
RandomAsianGuy
3mo
This is true.
David Cunningham David Cunningham OP
4mo
Mmmm. Maybe a little bit, but not entirely.
I bet it played a role, but the thing to keep in mind is that portal players come from all different backgrounds. The toughest part is getting them acclimated to what you want them to do in your program. Often times, players coming from bad teams were allowed to do just about whatever they wanted to do, and there was probably a lack of attention to detail or effort or consequence. So, you get players into your program who have sort of been in this "I can do whatever I'd like" mode and they've got to play good defense now, make the right decisions and have a coach that's tough on them like they haven't had in a while (or ever?). Some players respond immediately, some respond gradually, but some don't at all. My feeling was it was the latter for Swanson, who wasn't a great defender and, to be frank, didn't really add much value on either end of the court. Just didn't click for her.
Stork Stork
4mo
So how do coaches minimize the likelihood of that happening? Better
scouting? Because that is a huge loss to take someone like that (and the NIL cost) and pass on someone who might have been just what we needed. The good coaches minimize the portal misses.
V
VAHokie89
4mo
Odds are she didnt take
A position or money from any impact players. You could argue daley might have. Every team has the 10th-11th-12th players who seemingly cant get much time despite being recruited to play there. It is funny how so many players cant play or are not trusted to play on rosters around the country
1977hokie 1977hokie
4mo
Certainly kept her from getting off to decent start
Stork Stork
4mo
My guess is Duffy’s emphasis on defense.
HokieR HokieR
4mo
She was a bit slow to respond on defense
J
j9hokie
4mo
She was a bt slow for our team period. Might have been ok if she had a high
3pt percentage, but for whatever reason she never got in the groove there.