All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

3
Joined: 02/21/2013
Posts: 1,666
Likes: 766

MLB got a Congressional exemption from antitrust laws "waaay back when""

to keep the Yankees from buying all the talent and killing the sport. Other pro sports got similar exemptions along the way. That kind of arrangement could be permitted in NCAA sports when it comes to schools paying the players under collective bargaining. But "NIL" is different. It got its name because "name, image, likeness" was the subject of the court cases that outlawed players identity being used in video games without compensating the players. In the big picture it means that college athletes cannot legally be restricted from earning in any legal way. Just as pro athletes can earn money for public appearances, advertising or whatever, restricting college athletes from earning money loke that was always illegal; it just took lawsuits to prove it. Now we regard it as a "new law" called NIL, but schools were simply told by the courts to backoff.
Posted: 01/12/2023 at 05:10 PM ET
(In response to this post by Stech)

Thread Replies (15)

Full Thread →
So w/ no draft, no limit on staff, no limit on NIL, you have 2-4 teams 4 NC
Stech 01/09/23 09:37 PM ET
CFB will never have a draft. Can't force anyone to attend a school.**
J-Dub 01/10/23 12:17 PM ET
I realize that. then add no restrictions on Coaching Staff & now NIL, which
Stech 01/10/23 12:40 PM ET
Parity is desperately needed. How to get there is the $64000 question. **
Hokester 01/10/23 03:19 PM ET
fewer scholarships. p5 rev share. never happening**
HokieHollar 01/11/23 12:13 AM ET
I would start with limiting the staff, limiting the amount a coach can make
Stech 01/10/23 04:32 PM ET
NIL is a beast that needs to be tamed.
33laszlo99 01/10/23 08:03 PM ET
How about defining NIL?
EDGEMAN 01/12/23 12:43 PM ET
I understand what you’re saying, but Salary Caps r legal in all Pro Sports.
Stech 01/12/23 11:21 AM ET
MLB got a Congressional exemption from antitrust laws "waaay back when""
33laszlo99 01/12/23 05:10 PM ET
Anti trust laws forbid salary caps
mrcaniac 01/12/23 01:53 PM ET
It's why expanding past 4 up to 12 is pushing it.
HOO86 01/10/23 08:57 AM ET
Spot on **
MrFantastic! 01/10/23 10:07 AM ET
As someone who loves college football...
Hokester 01/09/23 11:26 PM ET
It breaks my heart too, but I’m an older adult, I think the younger adults
Stech 01/10/23 10:30 AM ET
Things Change. Baseball used to be the nation's number one sport. **
SAMMYNOLE 01/11/23 10:55 AM ET