All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

S
Stech OP
Jan 09, 2023 at 09:37 PM ET
So w/ no draft, no limit on staff, no limit on NIL, you have 2-4 teams 4 NC
NASCAR did the same thing, so that only 2-4 cars got the money and could win a championship. How is that working for them? How is this going to keep national interest in D1 college football? What do you say?

15 Replies

J
J-Dub
CFB will never have a draft. Can't force anyone to attend a school.
S
Stech OP
I realize that. then add no restrictions on Coaching Staff & now NIL, which
are two things they could change, the game is going to lose a lot of fans, and it already is losing them. Expect it to get worse if they don't try to create a more equal playing field for teams to compete. I am not a big NFL fan, but at least their leaders get how long term it is bad for the game to have same champions every year. Markets are just going to tune out of college football and find other things to spend their time and money. That's exactly what happened to NASCAR, and it doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that it is happening in college football. Especially with the younger generations.
H
Hokester
Parity is desperately needed. How to get there is the $64000 question.
H
HokieHollar
fewer scholarships. p5 rev share. never happening
S
Stech OP
I would start with limiting the staff, limiting the amount a coach can make
and limiting the amount of NIL. That’s where I would start.
3
33laszlo99
NIL is a beast that needs to be tamed.
Stech, as for limiting the size of staff, it might be possible. Paying players as employees will have numbers set by bargaining with players unions. But as to limiting NIL and coaching salaries, the courts won’t allow it. The lawsuits are likely already written and waiting for the University’s name to be typed into the space designated for “Defendant.” There are going to be some “corrections” to the system in the coming years: The transfer portal will cool down when these players are required to sign employment contracts. NIL sponsors will become more cautious and conservative when a few of their 5 star “sure things” pull up lame and fall into obscurity. (New field of business insurance.) We really don’t know what the NIL arena will look like, even next year. There needs to be a substantial oversight army and painful penalties for crimi-NILs.
E
EDGEMAN
How about defining NIL?
When it was introduced, NIL was supposed to be an avenue where players could be compensated for their name and likeness. What happened is all of the ugly under the table money was brought to the surface, and players are being paid far more than the signers expected. But if you redefine NIL, those under the table payouts will go back under the table, so there's no clear answer.
S
Stech OP
I understand what you’re saying, but Salary Caps r legal in all Pro Sports.
So if they are legal in Pro Sports, why not something similar for College Sports?
3
33laszlo99
MLB got a Congressional exemption from antitrust laws "waaay back when""
to keep the Yankees from buying all the talent and killing the sport. Other pro sports got similar exemptions along the way. That kind of arrangement could be permitted in NCAA sports when it comes to schools paying the players under collective bargaining. But "NIL" is different. It got its name because "name, image, likeness" was the subject of the court cases that outlawed players identity being used in video games without compensating the players. In the big picture it means that college athletes cannot legally be restricted from earning in any legal way. Just as pro athletes can earn money for public appearances, advertising or whatever, restricting college athletes from earning money loke that was always illegal; it just took lawsuits to prove it. Now we regard it as a "new law" called NIL, but schools were simply told by the courts to backoff.
mrcaniac mrcaniac
Anti trust laws forbid salary caps
The only way around them is a collective bargaining agreement, so all college athletes would have to join a college athletes union. Many states forbid government employees from joining unions, and since most of D1 schools are public entities, their athletes would be barred from joining the union. Most of those states are ones that have the ACC, SEC, and Big XII schools, while some states that would allow union state employees would be the PAC and B1G schools. Private school athletes would be able to join the union.
H
HOO86
It's why expanding past 4 up to 12 is pushing it.
There aren't 12 that can win it. 8 is pushing it. But they want us to watch blowout games I guess. This year the Semifinals were competitive, but the final was a blowout. Not sure what happened there. I guess if you give the top 4 byes, then the other 8 might have some competitive games the first weekend. Makes me long for the Bowl Games again. We're not going to have parity with this NIL thing and no limitations. I saw a tweet earlier from the Pittsburgh coach saying that 2 schools were trying to entice the UNC quarterback Blake May with $1 million offers. With this kind of stuff, it will be wild west. SEC will dominate that especially with Texas and Texas A&M in there.
M
MrFantastic!
Spot on
H
Hokester
As someone who loves college football...
it is tearing my heart out to see the way things are going. I likely will not pay much attention to what is going on nationally and only care what happens in the ACC. Even if lightening were to strike and VT ended up in the SEC or BIG, I think the chances of being relevant nationwide like we were from 2000 to 2010 are pretty slim.
S
Stech OP
It breaks my heart too, but I’m an older adult, I think the younger adults
really don’t care about college football, except in the SEC areas. Even then, there are plenty of reports of students at Alabama and other SEC schools leaving the games early or not showing up at all. That will eventually come back to haunt you.
SAMMYNOLE SAMMYNOLE
Things Change. Baseball used to be the nation's number one sport.