All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

E
EDGEMAN OP
Oct 29, 2025 at 04:29 PM ET
Halloween Candy Rankings: Reese’s PB Cups Still Rules
I concur! According to Forbes.com, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups remain the favorite. The tasty treat has boasted this top honor for a decade. The other top choices include Snickers, M&M’s and Hersey’s Chocolate Bars. Farther down the list you’ll find Twix and Kit Kat.

23 Replies

Tafkam Hokie Tafkam Hokie
9mo
I will die on the hill that Take 5 is the most underrated candy
Not necessarily the best, but definitely does not get the respect it deserves for being top-tier.
91HokieBob 91HokieBob
9mo
Reeses Pieces kept in refrigerator cold. MMMMMM my favorite! Reeses Peanut
Butter Cups my #2 the same way. :)
Galenahokie Galenahokie
9mo
No contest
89HOKIE 89HOKIE
9mo
Nothing beats a Butterfinger for me.
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
9mo
This guy agrees:
coshokie coshokie
9mo
Mmmm, love a butterfinger, still eat it out of teeth long after "eating" it
Coach McGuirk Coach McGuirk
9mo
Just put Reese's on my shopping list. We've never had any kids - ever
buuuutttt, I better play it safe ha.
E
EDGEMAN OP
9mo
I buy the Costco bag of mixed chocolate bars for Halloween to hand out...
...but I tend to pick out the Reese's PB cups and Snickers for my own consumption...lol. I never have enough kids to go through a bag, so I don't feel bad about snacking on my favorites.
reestuart reestuart
9mo
I told my wife I may egg our house since she bought zero Reese's for Friday
V
Va AandM
9mo
Truly the best…
bigbadbird bigbadbird
9mo
I wish they still made Candy CIgarettes- I used to smoke 5 packs a day
Spudnut Spudnut
9mo
Can get them at Brownsville Market west of zimaville
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
9mo
They still do. You just can't find them in very many stores anymore.
kjhokie kjhokie
9mo
Those aren't the real real ones from back in the day....
The real ones were gum in a tube wrapper, you could blow out of them for a fake puff of smoke.... The ones you linked are just sh*tty candy....I know because i bought them.....still handing them out this year for Halloween though...
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
9mo
Are you talking about these?
kjhokie kjhokie
9mo
Hells yeah! Now you are talking!
Not sure I can get those in time to hand out on Friday! Thanks!
bigbadbird bigbadbird
9mo
menthols?
Stork Stork
9mo
Candy corn rules!
Hokerer Hokerer
9mo
And the pumpkins are even better
RhinoVT RhinoVT
9mo
Can you taste the difference between the different colors?
reestuart reestuart
9mo
On their own, I'm not a fan. Mix with salted peanuts, and they are great.
E
EDGEMAN OP
9mo
Kids hate houses that hand out candy corn...lol
Stork Stork
9mo
Snotty Nosed Brats
** Edited by Stork at 10/29/2025, 4:48:00 PM