All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

V
Va AandM OP
Jan 13, 2025 at 03:38 PM ET
And now for some good news? You might find Pappy Van Winkle soon
And maybe at a lower price. The Bourbon boom is going bust
Link: -LINK-

19 Replies

G
GOHOKEE
Not just bourbon. Beer/liquor sales are down across all segments
Follow the stocks and their distribution networks. Everything is down. Convergence of multiple factors: GLPs, young people not drinking as much, etc. and now new push for cancer labeling.
Beerman Beerman
Buddy of mine at a beer distributor agrees
Hard seltzers and similar items are doing great. More traditional booze sales are softening.
UTPr0sim UTPr0sim
And wine. We just aren't drinking as much or the big drinkers are dying off
V
Va AandM OP
The Youth have reefer madness
WestyHokie WestyHokie
About time
G
GreenvilleVT
Market for lower end stuff is in total collapse.
Has been for over six months. Too many producers that can’t afford storage which is in very short supply. A lot of leverage in the industry and many thought rates were going back down. You could buy a barrell of new make for $200 in October. Alot of firms tried to fire sale bourbon in barrels at year end but clean balance sheets but there was very little buying. Many of the newer producers are dead especially the folks that were buying bourbon from the mass producers then aging and branding it. Pappy won’t fall to far though. Regardless of tariffs it is still swarmed in auctions and by the foreign crowd. The brands with pretty bottles but mediocre bourbon are “toasted”. The cocktail culture from Covid is also falling off. If you want to buy a barrel of bourbon to store at your farm or house it’s a very good time to buy one.
chumley chumley
…pass the biscuits Pappy
O’Daniel
UTPr0sim UTPr0sim
So if they offered it @$250 a bottle would you buy more than 1?
Vienna_Hokie Vienna_Hokie
I wouldn't buy 1 at that price
it's good, but not 5x the price of real good stuff good.
E
EDGEMAN
My palate isn't discriminating enough to taste the difference between...
Pappy and a reasonable priced bottle of quality bourbon.
Vienna_Hokie Vienna_Hokie
I'm not sure that result is gonna happen anytime soon
The question is, has BT increased production of Pappy, which I doubt they have, but if they have, when did they start and when will that production enter the market. There is a multi-year lead time in bourbon. I would also suspect that the big name stuff will be the last to come down. The driver of the bust is over saturation of the market, so the impact will first be some of the new brands/products that are being introduced that won't sell.
UTPr0sim UTPr0sim
I suspect the crappy $50+ bottles from no names will all but disappear.
Vienna_Hokie Vienna_Hokie
Agree, there is a lot of overpriced Meh on the market right now
There is some great stuff in the $30-$50 range and a lot of stuff just like it in the $50-$90 range in a fancy bottle.
Tafkam Hokie Tafkam Hokie
Like in any booming market, there is money to be made in offering mediocre
product at inflated prices. But once the boom ends, the strong will survive. The good bottles at each price point are likely to stay strong and the distilleries that threw something out there just to ride the wave are going to die.
Tafkam Hokie Tafkam Hokie
Last time we played at Louisville in football, we went for a long weekend
and toured several distilleries (Trace, Beam, Woodford, Makers, and we stopped at a couple others too). One of the questions I asked all of them was how do you business plan when your product has a 3 to 9 year lead time? There has been a tremendous uptick in bourbon in recent years, kinda replacing the craft beer boom of the 2000's. How do you position yourself for seismic shifts like that? I never really did get a good answer since I was asking tour guides and not VP's of marketing or product development. But that seems a uniquely challenging business planning problem.
E
EDGEMAN
I don't see it happening anytime soon either...
At least not with Pappy.
N
No Clue
It needed to. Add cars to the list.
E
EDGEMAN
I've been seeing a slightly downward trend on the auction sites.
It dropped significantly after the pandemic when it got really hard to find cars, and the area markups were crazy, but I've seen prices come down a bit over the last few months. Talking about prices on cars like Boxers, Caymans, BMW M-cars, etc. If someone wanted to sell their "driver level" car, they've probably just missed their window for max profit. But if they have a true classic, those are still holding (or increasing) their value. Just saw Steve McQueen's old 917 is going up for auction, and that's probably going to sell for $25M+. It's changed hands several times since Steve owned it, and I think the last time it sold was in the late 70s/early 80s when it sold for <$20K. It might have changed hands since then, but that one sale really stood out to me...lol
N
No Clue
Backing off of MSRP was a start. Still a ways to go