All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

PadrosWindup PadrosWindup OP
May 09, 2025 at 04:57 PM ET
Proposal for which ACC teams get a spot in a 16 team CFP
From TigerNet. Via Message Board Geniuses Not really much dumber that any other proposal ** Edited by PadrosWindup at 5/9/2025, 4:57:58 PM

11 Replies

M
Maverick Hokie
There is potential here even if this isn't exactly it...
The more I've sat on this the more I like the potential here. Have a premier division that is only initially established based on some weighting of the last 3-4 years. Then the bottom 1 or 2 premier finishers gets relegated down to the other division while the top 1-2 from the other division move up. The 1-2 would be dependent on how many teams are in the 2 divisions. A 5 team premier division probably only sees the last team get relegated but maybe a 7 team premier division has the bottom 2 get relegated. Thoughts?
M
Marooned
I just see the point in reposting this from a CU Board
unless it’s for laughs.
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
Does ND not want to play any of the other programs in the ACC?
I actually don't hate this idea. But Miami and UNC have won a total of zero ACC championships in the expansion era. Not sure they rate being in the top league. I like an other idea that I heard to let the teams that finish in the Top 5 be the 5 teams that play ND the next year. Probably too merit based for any of the risk-adverse suits in the ACC to support it.
HokieAl HokieAl
LOL on multiple aspects
1. UNC being included 2. ND being included 3. Guaranteed spot for such a small collection of teams. Why even play the games anymore?
E
EDGEMAN
You can say the same for all of them when it comes to recent performance
ND isn't in the ACC, so that guy must be a non-football watching idiot. A total moron! Imbecile! F$U has absolutely sucked lately, and they were excluded from the playoff the one year they were great. That shouldn't have happened, but it did. And the ACC rolled over and took it. Miami only gets results when they have a man in the replay booth who puts a very heavy thumb on the scale. They actually lost at least two games last year that were incorrectly decided to be wins. Miami isn't any better than they've been since joining the ACC. Now if you want to only use data older than 20 years, then sure, count Miami in. UNC - laughable. Don't think they've fielded a decent football team since 1998. Once again, that TigerNet poster is an idiot.
Pylons Pylons
He says ND wouldn't qualify if they don't join the ACC in full.
Still someone without credibility with a silly idea though.
T
TerryD
So.......a total fantasy scheme
A
ancient alien 2018
my fantasy is the ACC telling ND to join or join the BE for all
other sports. No one in the ACC has the nutz to do just that.
T
TerryD
The ACC is now propped up by ND
If ND leaves, the house of cards collapses. The ACC does not hold the leverage in the ND/ACC relationship.
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
They could just take ND out, move about four teams up the top division...
protect rivalries in a a crossover game or two, and just follow the rest of the plan. I hate any AQs that aren't conference champions, but I don't think 2 auto bids for the ACC is a bad deal.
PadrosWindup PadrosWindup OP
Dunno. Message board genius proposals need to be taken as serious as
proposals discussed by conference commissioners. Right???