All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

HokieJay HokieJay OP
Sep 01, 2023 at 04:51 PM ET
All three new ACC schools are private.
I believe this makes the majority of ACC schools private, each an anchor, holding back the larger state schools in athletics. Stanford would seem to be an exception to that rule but let's face it, the private schools in the ACC are overall far less successful across all sports than their bigger state school ACC members. Discuss.

15 Replies

HokieAl HokieAl
I posted on this earlier. 10 public schools and 8 private
The privates are not a majority. They do have smaller populations but they have bigger endowments. Athletics depends on your point of view. Duke is great in bball. Stanford in great in almost all olympic sports. ND is solid. etc.
HokieJay HokieJay OP
Point of view? OK, let's look at Championships and Revenue...
Per the link below the ACC private schools are woefully behind ACC state school championships over the ACC's history. The stats in the link below show total conference championships since joining the conference but not average champs per year, especially since expansion. If you do that math the private schools in the ACC are abject failures compared to the state schools. Duke has a bunch since they go back to the 1950s but lately almost nothing but hoops. Notre Dame's championships are 50% fencing, meaningless. BC, Syracuse, embarrassing. You make good points about private school endowments and success (however you measure it), but they just don't matter, only TV ratings and TV revenue matter now. Stanford might be the best athletic program in the ACC next year but they will still get awful ratings on the ACCN, just like Wake Forest, BC, Duke, Syracuse, and Miami. Are you going to watch the ACCN or ESPN Plus to see Stanford? Of course not, and almost no one in California is going to watch VT either. The ACC is a lifeboat right now and while Cal, Stanford, and SMU are going to help bail the water out of the boat, it will sink, eventually, pulled down by the weight of the private school members who cannot drive cable or streaming revenue. The SEC and BIG know what they are doing, and they know private isn't great for business. It's hard to imagine the ACC without UNC but I'll wager they will join the SEC within 3 years. I hope we follow.
H
Hokie 04
Let's give Duke five years post K to figure out their basketball future
Far from a certainty that they continue as a cream of the crop program post K
mrcaniac mrcaniac
Stanford has the most NCAA championships of any school
Cal is number 10. For comparison, in the ACC, UNC is number 8, and UVA is number 16 in total team championships. Stanford and Cal are the definition of elite athletic schools.
C
Cali Hokie Esq
I read that Cal and Stanford had a 100 Olympians at the last Olympics.
From a purely selfish standpoint of rooting for the USA in the Olympics, I'm happy they will be still relevant and sending Olympians to the Olympics, and therefore bringing more medals home.
HokieJay HokieJay OP
Agreed, I named Stanford as the exception to the "private school effect".
Cal as a top 10 is a bit of a surprise, though, thanks for pointing that out.
2
2hhoop3
Cal is not......
it is a public and part of UC system. The other two are deep pockets private schools.
Old Line Hokie Old Line Hokie
Next you'll be saying UVA is a public university? ;)
HokieJay HokieJay OP
Sorry, you are correct.
2
2hhoop3
I think your public/private.....
distinction is important and not inaccurate but, there are variables(money, size, reach, longevity) where privates are not an anchor. SMU is on the fence but, there history says they are all in. Stanford is wealthy enough to do what it wants just like some other well heeled privates like ND, USC-W, etc., in fact, of the three the public(Cal) is likely to be the anchor here, if one exists. ** Edited by 2hhoop3 at 9/1/2023, 5:04:42 PM
mrcaniac mrcaniac
Cal is literally the University of California
It is the flagship university of the California university system. It is very much a public university, and one of the top in institutions in the world.
H
Hokie 04
That rule doesn't always work - the University of Pennsylvania is private
But yeah, generally speaking, those schools are public.
L
LonghornHokie
Also now has the largest enrollment in ACC
neworleanshoo neworleanshoo
And Stanford, while private, is an international brand. Not comparable.
V
VT ChemE 1986
UC Berkley (CAL) is public
It is part of the UC system just like UCLA, UCSD, UC Santa Cruz, etc. ** Edited by VT ChemE 1986 at 9/1/2023, 4:54:59 PM ** Edited by VT ChemE 1986 at 9/1/2023, 4:55:19 PM