All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

T
Joined: 11/23/1999
Posts: 4,258
Likes: 994
Founder

We should hold firm on slightly more than the 6th game.

If we were to bring in Stanford and Cal, I say we hold tough on several points wrt ND. ND has to play Cal and Stanford alternating as a "6th" ACC/ND game. Effectively this puts ND into a pod with them. ND has permanent home and aways with all Stanford/Cal teams. ND has to allow us to treat their games as "in-conference games" ND gets a slot into our championship game, if they have a higher "in-conference" and total win percentage. ND does not have to join the ACC for football. I think they could sell this to their fans, as "keeping independence", while helping out a "friend" (Stanford). The ACC can keep to the official line that they got some concessions from ND, but darn it, they just won't give up their independence. This gives the ACC something real to sell for more TV money, and it removes some of the extra travel costs from the full time ACC teams, including the CA teams, and onto ND. If ND is "national" then that should be fine with them. Otherwise, forget it. To pull this off, ND has to give something up, they can't use it as an opportunity to simply gain something for themselves, like the ability to include their Stanford rivalry as an ACC game without giving anything up. That should be a complete non-starter. ** Edited by Truthahn at 8/11/2023, 11:09:01 AM
Posted: 08/11/2023 at 11:06 AM ET
(In response to this post by Maroon Baboon)

Thread Replies (38)

Full Thread →
On Notre Dame 🍀.
Maroon Baboon 08/10/23 10:49 PM ET
We should hold firm on slightly more than the 6th game.
Truthahn 08/11/23 11:06 AM ET
Agree on your first three points, especially #3
cburgroop 08/11/23 12:35 PM ET
Hard pass. I don't want to do anything more for ND. Done with the favors
hokiesrule98 08/11/23 11:37 AM ET
When you say "we should hold firm" on a 6th game, it that the fans
Big12 guy 08/11/23 11:13 AM ET
I haven't followed the negotiations.
Truthahn 08/11/23 11:26 AM ET
If this is about saving the CA teams, I agree with you, the ACC
Big12 guy 08/11/23 11:47 AM ET
ND’s whole play in this is self serving…
JLM-Hokie 08/11/23 09:40 AM ET
It always has been
Millpoint 08/11/23 11:01 AM ET
The AAC would give ND the same deal as the ACC, maybe the Big12 would too**
tarheelblue 08/11/23 10:58 AM ET
In a New York minute. **
Big12 guy 08/11/23 11:48 AM ET
It always is**
WestyHokie 08/11/23 10:32 AM ET
Notre Dame is looking to keep the ACC alive after it's top football
wwhokie1 08/11/23 10:01 AM ET
The end game for ND is to be in the group we now call
VTCALS72 08/11/23 09:38 AM ET
I don't understand this with ND and Expansion voteThe
Mercury 08/11/23 09:14 AM ET
This could be HUGE for ESPN
obguthr 08/11/23 09:09 AM ET
I don’t know why Notre Dame has any interest in saving Cal or Stanford.
HolidayInnHokie 08/10/23 11:39 PM ET
ND wants to save independence, not Stanford or Cal
TerryD 08/11/23 05:37 AM ET
Well said. Notre dame is acting to protect its independence
Hokie1992 08/11/23 06:50 AM ET
That’s fine, but it needs to be a win-win, add them, but ND needs 6th game,
Stech 08/11/23 07:18 AM ET
We are a partner that has boundaries. A 6th game would be lame
goldendomer 08/11/23 07:58 AM ET
The only thing that is ridiculous is this response to 1 game, especially
Stech 08/11/23 09:52 AM ET
Six games is nowhere near independent. Heck, 5 games isn't either
goldendomer 08/11/23 10:18 AM ET
What if it stayed 5 ACC games, but Cal & Stan don't count towards the 5?**
SpeakToDamien 08/11/23 10:55 AM ET
If we do not HAVE to play them it is fine
goldendomer 08/11/23 11:18 AM ET
You'd still be indy where it counts. Keeping all the NBC money to yourself.**
tarheelblue 08/11/23 10:49 AM ET
You are already semi independent in football, this is one game and USC has
Stech 08/11/23 10:33 AM ET
There is not a football school in the nation that would walk away from
Big12 guy 08/11/23 10:37 AM ET
They can get games, but to get the big money they need matchups, it's
Stech 08/11/23 10:53 AM ET
Independence is the kiss of death for all but a few.
Big12 guy 08/11/23 10:58 AM ET
They will want to play them, but I think you are underestimating how much
Stech 08/11/23 11:15 AM ET
I think what is missing is that ND needed a home for their basketball and
Big12 guy 08/11/23 08:13 AM ET
For that amount of difference, I think they want someone who they are
132863Hokie 08/11/23 08:44 AM ET
It takes as many votes to expel teams as it does to add them.
tarheelblue 08/11/23 01:00 AM ET
Even if ND joined for football, I doubt it would save the ACC in the end.
tarheelblue 08/10/23 11:12 PM ET
That’s right ND 🏈 would not be that much of an increase, especially playin
Stech 08/11/23 07:06 AM ET
Agree - the future of the ACC won't (and frankly shouldn't) be determined
VPI_1998 08/11/23 04:39 AM ET
It would be close enough**
SpeakToDamien 08/11/23 03:36 AM ET
ND in the ACC would easily be close enough to the B10.
Truthahn 08/11/23 11:23 AM ET