All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

It may not be just in football though because of Title IX. I'm not sure

the schools have a clear end goal of any kind. As a result, some of their behavior and decisions gives the impression they may be headed in a number of directions. Likewise, if you look at the evolution of collegiate athletics from a historical context, then you can see why schools may think it is heading in that direction. Specifically, I am referring to the motivations that led the schools to decide to create 3 subdivisions within the NCAA in 1971. When you understand the "Why?," then you have to ask yourself whether things today are truly that much different than they were in 1971? I'm not talking about the amount of money on the table or whether student-athletes are able to earn money via NIL deals. I am talking about from the schools' perspective and their desire to want to group themselves together in some fashion in order to hold intercollegiate competitions. Then if you continue on the evolution train to the late '70s, you should focus on the reasons DI schools felt it was time to create the 2 subdivisions in football in 1977 with 1978 being the first year DI-AA awarded the NCAA DI national championship to FAMU (note the irony in that fact). Once again, figure out the answer to the "Why?" question (why then?, why these new rules?, etc.), then you should see that what is going on today may not be that much different for schools looking to appease their desire to be in a like-minded group. If the range of DI members is as wide as the Pacific Ocean and the schools have not created subdivisions in the other sports, then it could suggest the NCAA may be primed for another major decision similar to the 2 examples I gave you. The schools may be in the process whether it is sport specific or for all sports because that will dictate how the bylaws will be written. For example, a non-DI school is currently not allowed to participate in football or basketball at the DI level without becoming a full DI member. If the schools decide to separate football (aka make it sport specific), then that could open the door for DII or DIII schools to want to compete at DI level in basketball without becoming a full DI member. Do the current DI members really want to deal with that scenario? Probably not, which takes separating football off the table for the time being because it is considered a "revenue sport." The reason that matters is because a DII or DIII could take that additional money earned by playing DI football or basketball and use it to fund the remaining DII or DIII sports. Perceptually that school could have unfair competitive advantage in resources from its DII or DIII competitors. Hence why the bylaws were changed to prevent DI schools from competing at the DII or DIII levels in a sport (including football).
Posted: 02/19/2026 at 09:26 PM ET
(In response to this post by Big12 guy)

Thread Replies (43)

Full Thread →
FBS scheduling ridiculously unequal yes, but now w/i same Conf like B10🔗**
Stech 02/18/26 11:25 AM ET
If conferences truly wanted their members to play the same schedule in a
VTHokie2000 02/18/26 05:25 PM ET
They aren’t Conferences anymore, they are TV Alliances for money, if a P1
Stech 02/18/26 11:49 PM ET
Yup. They aren't conferences. They're buying groups.**
VT ChemE 1986 02/20/26 01:57 PM ET
Pretty much, they might as well be stocks since ratings translate to
Stech 02/20/26 02:06 PM ET
I agree they aren't really "conferences" anymore even if "conference" is in
VTHokie2000 02/19/26 01:29 PM ET
Guys, to function as a "pro" league, there
Big12 guy 02/19/26 02:10 PM ET
You said basically the same thing they said before the NFL & AFL merged.
Stech 02/19/26 05:45 PM ET
There might be a break away of the P4, and it very well be fewer
Big12 guy 02/19/26 05:57 PM ET
Because there is even MORE money to be made for the schools involved if
VTHokie2000 02/19/26 06:35 PM ET
Your first line says it all, less schools MORE MONEY!!!
Stech 02/20/26 09:09 AM ET
Good point about golf. However, I don't think everyone gets the golf
VTHokie2000 02/20/26 11:13 AM ET
You are right about Conference Networks covering golf, the Golf Channel is
Stech 02/20/26 11:35 AM ET
You are right about golf being a relationship builder. I never really got
VTHokie2000 02/20/26 11:54 AM ET
Yeah it’s slim pickings for watching Tech Golf right now, but Sharpie is
Stech 02/20/26 12:27 PM ET
Probably take a few more .....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 12:45 PM ET
Yeah, often times in a good cop bad cop situation, the good cop takes over
Stech 02/20/26 01:59 PM ET
My comment had nothing........
2hhoop3 02/20/26 02:13 PM ET
We agree to disagree, I have decades of experience on the subject matter.
Stech 02/20/26 02:25 PM ET
And you ......
2hhoop3 02/20/26 02:30 PM ET
LOL you have no idea who I am and it shows. I can guarantee you Will who
Stech 02/20/26 02:45 PM ET
What I know is......
2hhoop3 02/20/26 02:52 PM ET
Not true, you do exactly what you are accusing me of, let me prove it.
Stech 02/20/26 02:58 PM ET
Already gave you .....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 03:07 PM ET
So your argument is they are adding more collegiate events to fill space?
Stech 02/20/26 03:19 PM ET
You got the argument right?.....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 03:24 PM ET
I just added my answer to the prior post, but here it is again.
Stech 02/20/26 03:26 PM ET
What else are ......
2hhoop3 02/20/26 03:31 PM ET
It’s been increasing for a decade, they would put other things on if it
Stech 02/20/26 03:46 PM ET
Like I said.....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 03:54 PM ET
We mostly agree, if not entirely, I will agree it’s not a large number
Stech 02/20/26 04:11 PM ET
We completely agree....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 04:52 PM ET
💯%**
Stech 02/20/26 04:58 PM ET
I guess this is where.....
2hhoop3 02/20/26 05:19 PM ET
Haha, save me a bite, I earned some 🐦‍⬛ too. 🤣
Stech 02/20/26 05:25 PM ET
If football breaks away to form it's own entity, it's certainly
Big12 guy 02/19/26 06:45 PM ET
It may not be just in football though because of Title IX. I'm not sure
VTHokie2000 02/19/26 09:26 PM ET
OK. That post of yours is
Big12 guy 02/19/26 09:55 PM ET
FWIW I am younger than you (born in '77). However, I probably did have a
VTHokie2000 02/20/26 11:02 AM ET
The networks are where the money comes from, you have it backwards, but you
Stech 02/19/26 06:23 PM ET
A truth and an opinion are certainly
Big12 guy 02/19/26 06:30 PM ET
PLEASE READ MY POST, I have NOT predicted a P1, you keep posting like I did
Stech 02/19/26 06:44 PM ET
I was referring to the truth, and an opinion. I
Big12 guy 02/19/26 06:51 PM ET
If your truth is I predicted a P1, then your truth is false. **
Stech 02/19/26 06:56 PM ET