All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

Could Indiana have hired Cignetti though without the Big Ten money to pay

him and his staff? Would Cignetti still find the job as attractive as he did if Indiana didn't have the Big Ten money to pay him and his staff AND Indiana had not already completed those major capital projects (including upgrades to the football stadium)? If so, then what is the proof to support that opinion? Until a non-P2 non-blue blood wins the FBS national championship or at least makes it to the championship, then I don't believe there is any proof that the road not take (aka Indiana being to hire Cignetti without having Big Ten money and still winning a FBS national championship under him) would still lead to the same destination. Which is essentially what you are suggestion will happen if a non-P2 school non-blue blood follows the map Indiana created this past season. Even if non-P2 non-blue blood is able to duplicate what Indiana did this past season, it still may not resolve the debate. I say that because then the discussion can easily shift to was it once in a blue moon type of event vs. a more common event.
Posted: 02/04/2026 at 08:35 PM ET
(In response to this post by Big12 guy)

Thread Replies (20)

Full Thread →
Do you feel that this is a trial run for many programs not in the P2?
The_VT_Rock 02/04/26 03:33 PM ET
It’s a semi open race for a few spots
RandomAsianGuy 02/04/26 11:04 PM ET
This entire discussion assumes no govenment interference
Vippie1 02/05/26 09:36 AM ET
Even if the non-P2s are pushed to the edge, Congress may still decide to
VTHokie2000 02/05/26 10:18 AM ET
yep the P2 could still do their own thing but
Vippie1 02/05/26 11:03 AM ET
I don't disagree that having antitrust exemption makes the situation much
VTHokie2000 02/05/26 11:41 AM ET
You dont go in tentative All the way,
1947Sunbowl 02/04/26 07:48 PM ET
Exactly. Whatever decision VT makes in terms of which path at the fork in
VTHokie2000 02/04/26 11:24 PM ET
In my humble opinion, I think we all put
Big12 guy 02/04/26 04:52 PM ET
Agreed - particularly in the ACC
VT ChemE 1986 02/05/26 12:31 PM ET
But for how long will those top teams want to remain in the ACC though?
VTHokie2000 02/05/26 02:40 PM ET
Could Indiana still have "overachieved" without the Big Ten money though?
VTHokie2000 02/04/26 06:23 PM ET
You’re leaving out IU’s Mark Cuban money. Also, billionaire Ken Griffin
HokieNeal 02/07/26 12:59 PM ET
I found another article that talked about the upgrades Indiana did to the
VTHokie2000 02/08/26 10:36 PM ET
I believe Cuban's money is more recent though. My post was referring to
VTHokie2000 02/08/26 10:24 PM ET
When you break down the players, I think the answer
Big12 guy 02/04/26 07:02 PM ET
Could Indiana have hired Cignetti though without the Big Ten money to pay
VTHokie2000 02/04/26 08:35 PM ET
Wait. You guys just paid big money to hire a coach without P2
Big12 guy 02/04/26 08:43 PM ET
A reason VT and UNC made the coaching decisions is because they are trying
VTHokie2000 02/04/26 11:12 PM ET
I think some are trying to get in the P2...
The_VT_Rock 02/04/26 05:03 PM ET
I can only speak for some in the B12. they
Big12 guy 02/04/26 05:16 PM ET