All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

G
Joined: 12/12/2004
Posts: 8,207
Likes: 633

I have recently retired from VT after a 35+ years career here.

It has been my experience that that best teachers are also among the best researchers at VT and elsewhere. There are exceptions, but talented faculty usually take great pride in their mission, whether research, teaching or extension. Those exceptional faculty with large research programs also offer great research/learning opportunities to undergrads. As a land Grant University, VT must address 3 missions - teaching, research, and extension. Appointments are typically joint between teaching-research or extension-research. The type of research that normally contributes to higher rankings of research universities is basic research, which attempts to improve our understanding of a particular phenomenon, study or law of nature. Basic research is designed to learn how processes or concepts work and often creates a foundation for applied studies. The federal government funds these from grants made from agencies such as National Institutes of Health (NIH), National Science Foundation (NSF), Department of Energy (DOE), Department of Defense (DOD). Applied (or translational) research is designed to discover practical solutions to problems. Such research is often not valued as highly as basic research in the rankings of research universities, but land grant universities perform much of this research through their colleges of agriculture, natural resources, engineering, urban affairs, transportation, etc.. Such research is a bulwark of faculty who have extension-research appointments, as their research must directly inform their clientele's (e.g., farmers, foresters, land managers, health and nutrition specialists, civil and environmental engineering firms, local government, and the citizens of the Commonwealth) practical questions. However, many well-designed applied/translational research includes components of basic research so that the graduate students who conduct these studies develop a foundation for both basic and applied discovery. Federal agencies, such as DOE, DOD, Department of Agriculture (USDA), Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Department of Transportation, Department of Commerce, etc. may be large funders of applied-translational research. Land Grant University research ratings can be hamstrung by their need to perform applied research, but many of the highest ranked research universities are land grants nonetheless, e.g., MIT, Texas A&M, Michigan State U, Univ of California-Davis, Purdue, Univ of Wisconsin. I have often been asked why universities so value research at the expense of teaching. The answer is complex, but realize that textbooks and other teaching resources can only be written and updated from contemporary research. An end to research will result in an end to new teaching knowledge. Because basic research often provides the foundation for applied/translational research to solve practical problems, the federal government must fund such research because private companies typically are interested in applied research from which they can profit. Most of the great advances made by private sector research have their basis in prior government-funded research. The continued reliance on both is necessary for a prospering economy and quality of life. ** Edited by Gadfly at 4/14/2024, 8:40:27 AM
Posted: 04/14/2024 at 08:21 AM ET
(In response to this post by wwhokie1)

Thread Replies (29)

Full Thread →
Questions about "Research". Re: B1G, AAU, research grants, etc.
Maroon Baboon 04/13/24 02:53 AM ET
I understand VT recently was denied AAU status again. I don’t get it **
3TechFanz 04/15/24 01:04 PM ET
I look at the list of AAU schools and maybe I'm being too elitist
HokieNoVA 04/15/24 02:18 PM ET
There's more than just research numbers.
HouClone 04/15/24 04:36 PM ET
You’d think Tim Sands - a Berkeley guy - would get this done **
3TechFanz 04/15/24 04:34 PM ET
For #3 and the last bit of 4,
Pylons 04/14/24 01:09 AM ET
Well it is in a different level of research that can be offered
DMV Gobbler 04/14/24 07:50 AM ET
Your last sentence gets at the crux of this
Pylons 04/14/24 09:30 AM ET
Some professors are brought in mostly because of their research potential.
wwhokie1 04/13/24 04:19 PM ET
I have recently retired from VT after a 35+ years career here.
Gadfly 04/14/24 08:21 AM ET
One of the most informative posts I have seen on TSL. Thanks!**
pine52x 04/15/24 05:43 PM ET
That's a reason positions like
Pylons 04/13/24 06:33 PM ET
100% correct. **
VTownie 04/13/24 04:31 PM ET
I have worked in the business side of science for the bulk of my adult life
VTownie 04/13/24 02:25 PM ET
Very helpful. Thank you. Interesting that you describe it as an "arms race"
Maroon Baboon 04/13/24 03:52 PM ET
Universities take a percentage of each grant to “manage” the funds.
VTownie 04/13/24 04:30 PM ET
Wasn’t it a requirement for AAU to have an on campus med school
Marooned 04/13/24 06:09 PM ET
No. There are no specific requirements.**
Pylons 04/14/24 12:55 AM ET
It's more difficult for some rural land-grant universitiies to have...
Old Line Hokie 04/13/24 08:25 PM ET
Cornell’s is in NYC.**
RJHokie 04/13/24 08:41 PM ET
Yep. Ithaca is similar to Blacksburg but further from a decent sized city.**
Old Line Hokie 04/13/24 08:46 PM ET
I believe U Va has the only major medical center not located
RJHokie 04/13/24 08:49 PM ET
FWIW I work for a bureau in the Department of the Interior (DOI) as a
VTHokie2000 04/13/24 04:17 PM ET
i was primary liaison between a DOI bureau and its state of FL
daveinop 04/15/24 07:31 PM ET
I bet the circus wasn't as bad as the sex scandal out of the Denver office.**
VTHokie2000 04/16/24 05:31 PM ET
that was MMS, right?
daveinop 04/17/24 10:41 AM ET
Yes, that was MMS. About 6 months or so prior to Deep Water.**
VTHokie2000 04/17/24 07:34 PM ET
I think my most meaningful contribution was
daveinop 04/18/24 09:08 AM ET
In general, I agree with you federalizing a spill is probably not the best
VTHokie2000 04/18/24 09:28 AM ET
I had my chance to make the case, but it wasn't realistic and that's not
daveinop 04/18/24 05:23 PM ET