All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

ElbertoHokie ElbertoHokie OP
Jul 06, 2026 at 08:30 AM ET
This FIFA intervention is blowing up.
UEFA(European Football) is commenting. Appeals by UEFA to have it overturned and to have the decision defended(by USA and CONCACAF) were due 30 min ago. It's turned into an unfortunate distraction. There really SHOULD be a red card appeal process at these tournaments. The fact that there isn't in the age of VAR is kind of nuts. If a panel of refs thinks a decision on the field is harsh after the fact, they should be able to overturn it and leave the missing of a partial game as the full punishment and play on.

16 Replies

Snape Snape
At this point, with all of the uproar and backlash, just bench....
Balogun and be done with it. Don't let him step foot on the pitch until and if they advance past Belgium. The hysteria isn't worth it because even the team and players are being put on blast when those players had nothing to do with this decision. ** Edited by Snape at 7/6/2026, 11:28:23 AM
ElbertoHokie ElbertoHokie OP
You don't get points for being honorable.
Any other major team or contender had this happen to them, they would play the player. We should play Balogun if he's available and if he's a better option than what we have available on the bench(I bet he is). All of the loudest voices screaming about this would do the EXACT same thing and play their guy.
Snape Snape
I can agree with that.
It's just frustrating reading all of the bs and hysterics out in la la land and the blasting of the team. I retract my statement. 😤
TomTurkey TomTurkey
Did last night's CR get his orders? One red card and 2 PKs.
PKs are as usually as rare as hens teeth.
H
Hate2SeeItEnd Hokie
I respectfully disagree. The calls shouldn't be able to be overturned
They need to have a process where a panel reviews the red card On The Spot (immediately after the call during the game.) The idea of changing a call 2 or 3 days later is Begging for Problems. We are already seeing that. It doesn't matter what kind of "process" is out in place after the game that allows for the call to possibly be overturned because that process, no matter how buttoned up or regimented or scientific WILL BE influenced by politics and political power. It will get to the point where you have 2000 people showing up at FIFA headquarters and protesting and fans hackling the Officials at FIFA to where that pressure has major influence. And for a team like Ivory Coast which has less influence and is a long way from Europe, their calls will not be as likely to be reversed. It will be a **** show
E
EDGEMAN
Haven't red cards been decided on the field when it happens, and not...
...on a slo-mo video review?
Nova Hokie 95 Nova Hokie 95
VAR can now review for red cards
I don't believe the use of slow-mo replay in this particular example is best practice, but VAR can indeed review for red card offenses that the referee missed.
ElbertoHokie ElbertoHokie OP
I think it's already a poop show and FIFA is as corrupt or more
corrupt than the IOC. We can agree to disagree but I think an appointed committee of experienced referees that can arbitrate on red card offenses is an appropriate step. Meet daily during the tournament and go over ALL red card offenses and uphold the punishment by the on field ref or strip the suspension part.
H
Hate2SeeItEnd Hokie
We disagree some. But we agree on FIFA being corrupt.
This is why I don't want them to have an additional day or 2 days or 3 days after the game to be able to be corrupted even more with deciding whether to overturn or keep a red card call from 2 days ago. A **** ton of money has surely already changed hands in those 24 or 48 hours.
Freddyburg Hokie Freddyburg Hokie
FIFA is only the second most corrupt sports organization....
They were in first, but they paid the right person to have them moved down in the standings.
Beerman Beerman
This must really be concerning for such an honorable org as FIFA
Hokebury Hokebury
Are there any honorable international sports organizations? Doesn't seem
like it. Too much money involved with sports today. Olympics, FIFA, Cycling, Skating...who am I missing.
V
Va AandM
Old whine in new technology bottles
PhotoHokieNC PhotoHokieNC
As is often the case, rules changes are implemented when
discussions like this begin. Could FIFA have predicted red cards that could be debated and withdrawn and established an immediate avenue of review AFTER a VAR decision? Sure, but they no doubt felt they had provided ample opportunity to determine if a call on the pitch was correct. Has any player or nation ever been happy with a red card? Not likely.
E
EDGEMAN
How about just sticking to the ordinary rules, such as...
Reviews aren't used to determine if a red card should be issued. Until now, that determination is decided by the ref on the field, not the refs in the replay booth.
H
Hate2SeeItEnd Hokie
This!