All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

hoosnowahokie hoosnowahokie OP
Dec 07, 2025 at 12:40 PM ET
They did the right thing. Put Miami in over ND. I didn't believe it could
Actually happen.

13 Replies

techer1983 techer1983
7mo
Was Miami put in over ND or was JMU put in over ND? Tulane had the
automatic bid since they were the highest ranked Group of 5 Conference champs, I believe is what I heard/read, and they opted to take 2 Group of 5 Conference champs, but didn’t take an independent team. Or was it stated somewhere that they took Miami over ND? Miami is 10th in the CFP with both Tulane and JMU ranked below them. I didn’t get a chance to watch the selection show which is why I am asking who was placed over ND.
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
Top 5 conference champions receive automatic bids regardless whether they
are a P-conference or a G-conference. Since UVA didn't do the its job last night to secure the bid for the ACC, that opened the door for 2 G-conferences to receive automatic bids. In theory, all 5 automatic bids could go to G-conferences if they happen to be the highest ranked conference champions in the final FBS poll.
H
Hokie`79
7mo
😂 I didn’t think that it would happen either. I still remember 2000, when
ND was selected over a higher ranking VT team for The Fiesta Bowl. I have not pulled for ND football in any game since then.
S
solareye
7mo
Committee just didn't want the ACC to be excluded
This was the way to do that given the implosion of the ACC champ game.
V
Vippie1
7mo
And they preferred to punish ND
for not being in a conference
V
Vippie1
7mo
Preferred it be Bama left out.
Freaking Saban doesn't care about the health of college football. Leaving out the G5 for 3 lost SEC teams etc.
bigbadbird bigbadbird
7mo
Bama is the worst team in the playoffs
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
Most experts would probably disagree with you. They would say the
Sun Belt champion and AAC champion don't "deserve" to make the field because they wouldn't have achieved their record playing Alabama's SEC schedule with their Sun Belt/AAC players. They probably don't think JMU has any chance leaving Eugene with a W. So they will spend as little time talking about the preview for that game so they can spend a lot more time talking about Alabama vs. Oklahoma. SEC vs. SEC, 2 historic blue bloods squaring off, what more could audiences ask for?
bigbadbird bigbadbird
7mo
well right- it's a beauty contest for teams like BAMA- they sell alot
of tickets - and I am no expert - on anything that I can think of
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
That's the problem when the fox is allowed to guard the hen house. In a
perfect world, whichever network(s) get to broadcast the FBS Playoffs should be 100% neutral when it comes to which conferences receives bids to it and how many bid(s) each conference receives. Unfortunately, we don't live in a perfect world where the networks (ESPN in this case) operate with a separation of church and state (if you will). I doubt Fox, CBS, or NBC would be any different if they were in ESPN's shoes. IIWII at this point in time.
MaryWashGrad MaryWashGrad
7mo
Saban has forgotten that if G5 was not included then no 12 team playoffs
The P4 had to provide access to the playoffs to get the 12 team system approved
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
He probably doesn't even know that all FBS conferences and Notre Dame are
co-owners of the organization that runs the FBS Playoffs.
bigbadbird bigbadbird
7mo
if they didn't they basically are saying the games don't matter