All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

H
HokieAvalanche OP
May 15, 2026 at 07:53 AM ET
So which pitcher do we start today? Save Mazz for LSU and start Bree?

20 Replies

2
2hhoop3
2mo
I think reasonable and supportable......
opinions and arguments can be made and have been made for different scenarios in this thread. The only thing I would add in a tourney scenario is the old adage "you do what you can to win TODAY and worry about tomorrow when it comes.".
HolidayInnHokie HolidayInnHokie
2mo
I would start Avery today. Jags are a light hitting team. She’ll do well.
Further build up her confidence and save Mazz + Bre (if available) for LSU. With any luck, VT wins in 5 innings but I won’t count on that. Feels like a 4-1 type of game to me given how good their pitcher is. Assuming we beat the Jags, that Game 1 vs. LSU obviously becomes enormous. We need to think about what happens if Bree is unavailable or not effective due to injury. Who is our #3 pitcher in that case after Mazz and Avery? Is it Sophie? Seems like it based on her getting some action at Syracuse. We haven’t seen Fisher or Grizzard in months but they are at least dressing out for every game.
B
BEST2VT
2mo
I wonder if Avery might get the start. Maybe plan to start Mazz tomorrow,
limit Bree’s innings but have her when needed.
Will Stewart Will Stewart
2mo
Haven't had a chance to catch up ... do we know that Bree is healthy?
I don't mean coach-speak and player-speak smoke screens ... do we know for a *fact* that Bree is healthy?
VTChip VTChip
2mo
I believe Bree is fine. It’s a problem she has had back to travel ball
Her family wasn’t panicking so I’m not going to either.
MidloHokie MidloHokie
2mo
OK. That's revealing. By definition that's a chronic issue. Some . .
. . . type of overuse syndrome that is episodic. Probably somewhat unpredictable but related to total workload on the arm. She's almost certainly had a greater workload this season than any time since travel ball. What the coaches know (and her parents) is whether this had flared up during her time at VT and how it has been managed.
MidloHokie MidloHokie
2mo
No answer but having been a very good pitcher's Dad who . .
. . . went to coach D1 and has taught privately for 15 years I can say that I was very concerned about Bree leaving the Duke game in tears. I know it's reported she had forearm tightness. Tightness producing tears suggests a situation that likely chronic as opposed to acute. She may be fine altogether of fine for limited innings. Either way, there's likely some overuse situation that's not likely to subside completely in the course of few days.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
Or upset for having to leave an important game.
Or a little of both.
MidloHokie MidloHokie
2mo
Yep. And having experienced all this with my daughter we may not . .
. . . know unless Bree has a 7-inning outing this weekend. That said, our NEVER knowing would be the best outcome indicating the issue was acute and not chronic.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
True. Hoping she's okay for her sake. We know she wants to pitch.
TomTurkey TomTurkey
2mo
Noting confirmed here
YorkHokie YorkHokie
2mo
I'd start Bree
and let Avery finish up if we have a decent lead. Then Mazz can start tomorrow with Bree available for relief work if needed.
C
Chesapeake_Hokie
2mo
I’d actually consider starting Layton (more)
giving Bree an extra day of rest for her arm/hand
MidloHokie MidloHokie
2mo
I'd go with Layton regardless. Odds are you are going to have to beat . .
. . . LSU twice in the next three days. We saw what happened last week with Mazz on her third consecutive day in the circle. You can't, with confidence, know how many innings you're going to get from Bree (see injury discussion above). S. Alabama is a decent team with a competent pitcher but the best chance of advancing is to get at least 5 innings from Layton today.
V
vt49701
2mo
A dissenting opinion
Layton is certainly very talented, was lights out against FSU, and has a very bright future here at VT. However because today is essentially a must win game to (hopefully) enter the winners bracket, there’s definitely a rationale to go with the top of the rotation, which is either Mazz or Bree. In baseball there have been numerous examples of teams trying to “save pitching” against a “lesser opponent” and then suddenly finding themselves in a dogfight. That’s kinda how Liberty went … we were kinda off from the beginning as if we took our foot off the gas. Bottom line - it feels like we’ll need everyone in the circle at some point this weekend, but gotta make sure you get into the winners bracket. And to me who a coach sends into the circle has the biggest impact on the game. Go Hokies!
Atlee Hokie Atlee Hokie
2mo
So you believe the team has been downplaying or covering up Bree's injury?
C
Chesapeake_Hokie
2mo
yes. Talked with her father in C-ville.
he said she'd be "fine" with a little rest. I didn't press for details
hokiepro hokiepro
2mo
I know she wasn’t able to go on Saturday vs FSU. Was sitting in bleachers
Right beside the bullpen. She tried warming up a couple times. Once she left bullpen to dugout, came back and was visibly upset, sat there a while then tried again to throw a few. She wasn’t needed then it turns out (more offense was) but she couldn’t go on Saturday
hokiepro hokiepro
2mo
I’d go with Bree
2 reasons 1) need to minimize walks 2) see early how she feels so Pete knows how much he can use her/change strategy as needed The way Avery was throwing I expect we see her for at least one trip thru order Hopefully Bree gives us a complete game 5 IP though I seriously doubt we can score 8 on S Alabama pitcher
R
RJHokie
2mo
I expect Bree to start today.