All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

R
RandomAsianGuy OP
Jan 16, 2026 at 07:30 PM ET
Will the SEC break away?
From Ross Dellenger For some, a solution is emerging: Each conference should govern itself, enforce its own rules and, perhaps even, compete solely with its own members. “If the CSC is not going to enforce the House settlement, if the NCAA is not going to enforce tampering rules and if Congress is not going to pass the SCORE Act, then it leaves the SEC in a position that we have to go our own way to create some rules and a level of responsibility,” Georgia president Jere Morehead, a former chair of the NCAA DI Board of Directors, told Yahoo Sports earlier this month. … Sankey cautions any suggestion of the long-discussed “breakaway” by the SEC and other power leagues. Nobody wants to “rush there,” and the SEC remains committed to a “national organization,” he says. However, “there are limits to that,” Sankey said. “The frustration level is building. I anticipate that there’s a lot of people that are saying, ‘This might not work for us.’” —————- From SBJ article (B12 fan posted) Fifth: Antitrust pressure makes a breakaway almost necessary With a player salary cap disguised as revenue sharing already here, and private capital already in play for some conferences like the Big Ten, the sport is walking into a professional future that will require roster limits, contracts, cost controls and collective bargaining. You can’t run any of that under the current NCAA umbrella without the risk of a lawsuit, but a breakaway league could. That’s why every major pro league is a closed system. ____________ If the SEC and/or the B10 wants a professional model and the governance that comes with it, a break-away does seem like a possible option. They don’t have to form a single Super league. They can separately breakaway but coordinate for a playoff or media deal.

26 Replies

R
RandomAsianGuy OP
6mo
The SEC/B10 breakaway scenario (but not a Super Leage)
I guess technically the SEC can break away alone, play 11 conference games, and participate in the CFP, which is independent of the NCAA. Eleven conference games mean the SEC can expand to 20 and play 3-8-8. If the B10 breaks away and goes to 12 conference games, they can expand to 22 and play 3-9-9. A 24-team format mean 1-11-11 ir less frequent match ups and may involve four divisions. The eight best teams (or the top two teams from each division under a 4-division model) would play play-in games during the CG week. The four winners would join the 12-team playoff (which is basically a 24-team playoff counting the play-in game participants). I believe that’s what the B10 wants. Alternatively, the B10 can set up its own 8-team playoffs. All playoff games will be on campus and televised on Fox, and the B10 will collect all of the playoff money except for the B10 championship game, which will be held in the Rose Bowl. The SEC can do the same and set up their own championship game at the Sugar Bowl. Finally, the B10 champ and the SEC champ will play one last game. That will be a de facto CFB championship game (technically not, because non-P2 teams are participating).
B
Big12 guy
6mo
That could all be well and good, but the other
championships will continue to be under NCAA control. They will not break away, it's a big bluff. I say, call their bluff, and let the NCAA set up their own football championship the day the current media contract ends for the existing set up. Do you REALLY think the Big 10 and SEC will separate from the rest of college athletics? I suppose they theoretically could, but I just don't see it. ** Edited by Big12 guy at 1/17/2026, 1:16:27 PM
R
RandomAsianGuy OP
6mo
I'm taking about football only breakaway.
Calamitous Calamitous
6mo
Would the NCAA let the Big 18 and SEC to play their other…
sports as part of the NCAA if there were a football breakaway?
R
RandomAsianGuy OP
6mo
I believe so. On what ground can the NCAA stop such move?
Calamitous Calamitous
6mo
Seems like they could do this for basketball too…
although the revenue for bball wouldn’t sniff what football would do. As long as the schools all stay in the same conferences and don’t do the weird ND independent approach, I guess that could work albeit a bit hypocritical on the power school’s approach.
B
Big12 guy
6mo
Why should they share the tournament money with schools that will
not share the football/playoff money? While it's a simplistic comparison, the NCAA could have their own football championship. In the old days, the NIT (private) was the premiere basketball tournament. Today, the football playoffs (private) is the premiere football "tournament". As fast as things are changing, the more I see it coming back around to "student" athletics. One can't put the lid back on the jar of athletes being paid what they are worth to the institutions paying them. I don't think that will change. Education, credit hours, and degrees is what I think could settle this wild west show. Let the athletes make their money, and transfer as much as they want. What the NCAA needs to do, it apply transferable credit hours to the portal, and require athletes to have enough credit hours to keep on playing. The trade off could be eliminating the eligibility rules from "years" to credit hours, and maybe give a 6 year window to achieve their 4 year degree.
L
Lakeridgehokie
6mo
They are upset since they can't get away with the under the table that
occurred for years. Now everyone can legally do what they did for years illegally. Texas oil money will always trump anything Bama, Auburn, Florida, etc. can produce.
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
6mo
And not just oil money. Lots of billionaires out there looking to support
their respective alma maters. When I saw Mark Cuban out here through the playoffs supporting IU, it started to make sense. I didn’t even know he was an Indiana alum. He might not have any club head speed, but he has enough cash to outspend a million Alabama fans who would skip their daughter’s wedding if it interferes with a Tide kickoff time.
S
Stech
6mo
SEC schools saying Conference Only Competition eventually coming, 🤔 ND.
As we all know, this is about what makes Disney and Fox the most money, I could see their money going up if they only play each other in the SEC during the regular season. I am an ACC Conference guy since my school is in the ACC, but I have to admit watching SEC Rivalry games other than Virginia Tech, are very entertaining to watch. That would be a money game changer, and I think they can keep it a national sport by just having the playoff, much like the NCAA 🏀 tournament where many times the teams/conferences have never played each other during the regular season.
Calamitous Calamitous
6mo
No one ever wants to admit it, but SEC football games….
are way more entertaining even though it feels like the fix is in with most of their games and you can almost predict the outcomes. Their fans are loud. ESPN mics up their bands to make them obnoxiously loud. There always seems to be some spectacular play. Even though the score of a game is 3-3 at the end of the 3rd, the final ends up 38-31 after the 2nd OT. And college football is a religion in the SEC. Disney and ESPN already love them and it’s a matter of time before there is a break. The SEC won’t do this until the Big 18 is ready though. The SEC and Big 18 need a set up like the old AFL and NFL where the SEC can play only SEC teams and the Big 18 can only play Big 18 teams, with only one College Super Bowl game when the SEC plays the Big 18. I think the SEC and Big 18 need 4 divisions each in their conferences. To go to 4 5-team divisions, the Big 18 just needs 2 ACC schools and the SEC needs 4 schools from either the ACC or Big 12. They might have to go bigger than 20 teams (24 or even 28) though because the ACC will need to properly implode if it happens before the ACC GoR renewal date.
S
Stech
6mo
Go to 28/28 56, 4 divs of 7, u play own division plus another division home
and away for two seasons. Then rotate through other divisions every 2 years. That means you’re playing each team in the other divisions twice in 6 years. That’s way better than what they are doing now for playing teams in your conference. Right now the P2 has 34 teams. Here are the 22 teams that I would add from the ACC, B12 and Independents. ACC: Miami Florida State Clemson Virginia Tech Virginia North Carolina North Carolina State Georgia Tech Pitt Syracuse SMU Stanford Cal B12: WVU Kansas Kansas State Arizona Arizona State Colorado TCU UCF or South Florida Utah BYU Independents ND if they will join, if not, add the Florida school above that got left out between UCF or USF The left out schools are mostly basketball first schools, have a Big East and Big West version of the same thing. They with the G6 can have their own football national championship playoff. However, keep the NCAA for all other sports, including the basketball tournament that goes to 96 with some of the first rounds games on the campus of the highest ranked teams. Just like the football playoff! The TV ratings would be off the hook for almost everything if not everything above. 💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵 ** Edited by Stech at 1/17/2026, 10:29:02 PM
Calamitous Calamitous
6mo
This might be along the lines of what you’re thinking…
Of course this is spitballing. K-State isn’t exactly southern but they need a spot. And there are a lot of schools absent like WSU, Oregon State, Pitt, Syracuse, BC, Wake, Duke and a decent contingent of the newer Big12 schools. BIG 28 Rutgers Penn State Maryland Virginia North Carolina Virginia Tech NC State Ohio State Michigan Michigan State Indiana Purdue Northwestern Illinois Iowa Wisconsin Minnesota Nebraska Colorado Iowa State Kansas UCLA USC Washington Oregon California Stanford Utah SEC 28 Miami Florida State Georgia Tech Clemson South Carolina West Virginia Louisville Florida Georgia Tennessee Vanderbilt Kentucky Alabama Auburn Mississippi Mississippi State Louisiana State Arkansas Missouri Kansas State Oklahoma State Texas A&M Texas Oklahoma Texas Tech Baylor Arizona Arizona State
1
1947Sunbowl
6mo
pasturing,, it should be all or nothing
If you are going to play only SEC on football. THEN, there should be a universal no play these programs for men's women's basketball, soccer baseball, softball track. etc and also put high penalties to non SEC programs that play them. I guess the South is known for SEPARATE BUT NOT EQUAL.
T
TerryD
6mo
Empty theat. Posturing, like most such things
Wake me up when it happens. I would laugh if it did, but with an ND exception. :)
S
Stech
6mo
Haha threat got em control of playoff Months ago, I wouldn’t underrate them
or overrate their affinity for Notre Dame. As you like to say, they are going to look after themselves first.
H
HouClone
6mo
Hey look, another SEC threat?
S
Stech
6mo
Keep getting stuff too, got control of the CFP and $ less than a year ago.
If we stay with 12 in the playoff, it will be because the SEC doesn’t want it. Every other conference is ready to vote for it. They probably don’t want any other conference to get multiple bids. If Indiana wins Monday night, especially if another blowout, they are going to be very very unhappy IMHO. SEC power is real though, even if they haven’t made the National Championship game in 3 years, 2 of them during the expanded playoff.
2
2hhoop3
6mo
Just the SEC.....
bellyaching because it has now been three years since they scratched and everyone is doing legally now what they always did under the table before.
3
33laszlo99
6mo
Sad, but true. I'm sure I'm not the only one who saw this as the reason
Saban bailed-out when he did. Money schools in The SEC, like TX, T-A&M, Florida, Georgia, will have no trouble keeping up. We'll see if Ole Miss can be consistent annually. Or is this just a fluke? Same question applies to Indiana and perhaps Texas Tech. The good news (at least for me) is I think The SEC has finally realized that they need to expand the footprint beyond the Southeast. I expect to see two very large conferences who will require additional media partners (streamers).
2
2hhoop3
6mo
Nick's the old guy......
who was once very good even if the field was not level but, he got out recognizing the future fight was going to be far more even and on terms he was not comfortable with.
3
33laszlo99
6mo
Yeah, not like I'd disrespect NS. I am grateful for all he gave to Bama.
But college asked him, at his age, to be more than he wished to be. He demanded to supervise every minute detail. That's part of why he was able to replace assistants so easily, so often. NIL and transfer portal overwhelmed him. I am disappointed that The Tide has seemed to slip a little (who knows for how long). But fans need to simply show some gratitude.
2
2hhoop3
6mo
He went out on......
his own terms and often legends have a hard time recognizing when it is time to go. No disrespect intended on my part. A guy with that many crystal footballs is free to do as he pleases IMO.
S
SpeakToDamien
6mo
Miami and Texas Tech are saving the p4
Miami is is going to be really, really good next year, and Texas tech is not going away. We really need to break the myth of invincibility of the sec.
Maroon Baboon Maroon Baboon
6mo
Translation: schools with filthy rich alums can now legally outspend them.
Now they're big mad.
Calamitous Calamitous
6mo
I feel everyone in the ACC and Big 12 are out to save themselves….
more than to save their conferences. The next 4 to 6 years (whenever the next wave of conference destruction takes place) will be a beauty contest where the prettiest football schools will be invited to either the SEC or Big 18. Not sure what those qualifications will be anymore because everything seems on the table. Five to six years ago I would have automatically assumed those schools would be the large flagship and land grant schools with rabid football fans. Now I’m not convinced that Clemson, Virginia Tech and NC State have any better shot at achieving SEC or Big 18 status as SMU, Duke and Stanford do. NIL and the transfer portal have destroyed predictability and any schools ability to build a team over sustainable long periods. To your point about the SEC invincibility myth, I think SEC dominance will return. Those schools have way too much money and pride to be usurped by the “lower” power conferences. Football is a religion down there and they will figure out how to stay on top, much the way the Big 18 will. I just hope my Hokies aren’t left in the dust playing in the AAC with Memphis and ECU a decade from now.