All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

T
Tailgate Guru OP
Aug 04, 2023 at 09:49 PM ET
Conference realignment just plain sucks
College football and college athletics has gone totally off the rails during the past 20-30 years. As some know, I grew up a Mountaineer and became a Hokie by choice. When I learned to love college football, WVU was an independent but might as well have been a conference member. Virtually every football schedule consisted of Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Maryland, Virginia Tech, Rutgers, Temple, Boston College, two punching bags from the MAC or similar conference, and a rotating collection of ECU, Miami and others. Those games were fun and they mattered because your family knew someone who had a connection to most of those schools. Tech in those pre-Big East days was different. When I got to Tech in 1985, the schedule was a mish-mash. UVa, WVU and Clemson were regulars. Maybe another nearby ACC school, Vandy or Kentucky. There was still a smattering of Richmond and William & Mary along with random opponents like Memphis State. Tech was somewhat of an outsider in the Big East but at least it had “family” that became genuine peers. And later the fit with the ACC was even better, even if the football wasn’t. I remember going to a conference in Colorado Springs in the fall of 1994. I drove up to Boulder and got a ticket to see Colorado play Kansas State. CU was a top flight program with Kordell Stewart and Rashaan Salaam, who won the Heisman that year. K State was on a parallel track with the Hokies in Bill Snyder’s early years. It was a really good game and I remember thinking I would probably never see either team play again. Now Colorado and Kansas State are conference games for WVU. WVU is in the same conference as BYU and Texas Tech, for heaven’s sake. And when WVU opens the season in Happy Valley, it will be the Mountaineers’ first game against Penn State in 30 years. WVU went 11 years between games against Pitt and the schools are 70 miles apart. I don’t know what the future holds for Tech. I just don’t think it will be in the ACC as we now know it. Maybe Tech wins the lottery and ends up in the Big Ten or SEC. Maybe Tech ends up in the Big 12 or some remnant league of former ACC and Big 12 schools. Tech will probably always play UVa; but, old timers probably said the same thing about VMI. Whatever the future is, it won’t be better. Membership in the Big Ten or SEC sounds great and it would be for a while. It would be cool to see Penn State, Michigan, Tennessee or Georgia come to Lane Stadium for a conference game. I thought the same thing when Texas and Oklahoma first started going to Morgantown. But although WVU has a lot in common with the Big 12 schools and though the fans and competition in that conference are great, once you’ve seen some of those opponents two or three times the novelty wears off. So while regular games against Penn State or Tennessee sounds awesome, what the heck would a game against Iowa or Auburn mean the second or third time around? There is no real connection with most of the schools in the Big Ten or SEC. And playing Tech will never ever mean much to those traditional conference members. And if Tech is left out of the P2, then what? There’s a good chance of playing WVU regularly again, maybe with regular games against NC State and a couple other ACC schools we haven’t played often enough. But we are also likely to see more frequent games against opponents that never did or no longer stir the soul, like BC or Cincinnati. And God help us all if we are playing conference games in Arizona and Utah like WVU will be the next few years. It just sucks. And the money does nothing for the common fan. The game has become about the television networks and the people who sit in box seats (no offense, I would sit there too if I could afford it). The rest of us are just cattle given 6 to 14 days’ notice of when to show up, jump up and down for three minutes, and then provide background scenery for ESPN or Fox. The only hope I have is that maybe someday the television bubble will burst and someone in Columbus or State College will ask why in the hell they are sending a volleyball team to Oregon, or someone in Austin or Tallahassee or Knoxville will start asking why they have to play the football equivalent of the 1927 Yankees every weekend. Maybe then common sense will return, conferences will return to 8-10 member groups with round robin play, and I can regularly watch Tech-UVa and WVU-Pitt with a smile on my face. ** Edited by Tailgate Guru at 8/4/2023, 9:55:18 PM

6 Replies

W
WarHog38
Entering a New Conference
I have lived that as a Hog fan and I don't agree with one angle about conference moving as you laid out. That about playing teams in close proximity is the ideal structure to be sure. However the Hokies would develop rivalries with the schools in the eastern half of the SEC over several decades. Even with Auburn, that is way over on the east side of Alabama near the Georgia line. I know the Razorbacks had South Carolina on the yearly schedule several decades until the Aggies entered in 2012. That South Carolina game got to be enjoyed by Hog fans over all those years. It would be the same way if the Hokies entered the B1G. Maryland is an old ACC foe. Penn State & Rutgers and even Ohio State are relatively close. Virginia Tech would develop rivalries with those B1G schools over a few years. The Hokie fan base would enjoy those games. I don't know what the future holds for college football. The game is radically different from what I remember as a young man. Amateur athletes and everything done for the good of the team. Those concepts have went down the toilet like so many other things that were the better part of this society. College football literally in the end depends on the fans open wallets. Who knows if college football can weather all those drastic changes in the years ahead?
L
LeadingEdge
God bless you. Epic post.
W
WarHog38
Thank you, may God also bless you.
M
Marooned
Neither choice is really appealing actually
Option A: Stay in a lesser conference and have your coaches and the most elite recruits bail on you when money gets thrown around, while watching your former conference foes get the notoriety. Option B: Jump to one of the P2 and spend a fortune on travel, facilities, salaries just for a puncher’s chance at having a memorable year.
W
WarHog38
Gold Chains & Lamborghinis
Is that an appealing Option for an 18 year old to have? Is the size of the wallets in the alumni or fan base the true measure of champions? That world is apparently dead ahead for college football. Nobody is going to beat the Aggies on the oil mogul donors. However the Razorbacks have Waltons, Tysons & Hunts plus Jerry Jones. All billionaires many times over and very loyal to the program. The top rated athlete facility buildings on the Arkansas campus all bear there name plus the Reynolds Foundation that has given millions to build hospitals within the state plus Razorback Stadium. I only give you the Arkansas credentials because I know them the best. Arkansas with the money backing can probably compete better in the new SEC. Arkansas never had a license to cheat punched by the SEC front office like some of the most successful SEC football programs. Cheating made legal may actually help the Razorbacks in the future. I don't know the Virginia Tech pedigree as far as whales with billions running out their ears. The Hokies would need those whales to compete in the SEC.
V
VPI_1998
Truly a dilemma with 2 outcomes that probably aren't good
Nebraska, Maryland, and soon to be others chasing dollars in another conference just to be mediocre or less? No thanks. I know at this point the time bomb for the ACC has now officially been set and it's just a matter of time before it falls apart. May take 8 years but it's heading there. I have some small hope that the ACC can improve itself over the next 5 years and remain, but more than likely we are going to see UVA, VT, NCST and UNC in 3 different conferences in a decade, with non-sensical conference opponents.