All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

B
Joined: 10/03/2022
Posts: 2,584
Likes: 4,007
Subscriber

More thoughts in response:

1) The maximum amount of revenue share for schools will be calculated every year, I'm sure based upon some type of CPI-type formula. For this upcoming year, it's 22 million dollars. NIL will still be a thing, but payors and payees will have to demonstrate the deal is for fair market value, and all NIL deals over a certain amount (I think $500) will be audited for FMV compliance by Deloitte, a giant national accounting firm. So, NIL ain't going to be what it is now - completely unfettered pay for play. Collectives aren't going to be able to cut anymore $2 million dollar checks to QB transfers, unless they can demonstrate that the $2 million is FMV based upon the QB's calculated NIL value and whatever service they're providing in return for the money. So, presumably, the majority of pay for football players is now going to come directly from the schools, who have to find that money themselves. Again, do you own research - it's well documented that the majority of FBS schools have just come out and said they won't be able to distribute up to the cap, because they won't have it. Successful programs require good players on their rosters. Let's make this real simple - if team A distributes a payroll of $100, and team B distributes a payroll of $40, which team do you think will be able to attract the better players? Or, look at it through this lens: if company A offers you a $300,000.00 salary to do a job, and company B offers you a $100,000.00 salary to do the exact same job, which company are YOU going to work for? 2) I really don't think playing SMU in Texas twice a decade is going to help VT recruit Texas, and, that notwithstanding, you should ask everyone on this board how they feel about #TX2VT. Given recent history, I doubt you'll get many warm and fuzzies when it comes to the idea of Texas as a recruiting pipeline for VT. And, and this is exactly my point about both SMU and the ACC - SMU playing in the ACCCG and getting into the playoff was not covered like it was any kind of boon for the ACC. No, to the contrary - the media spin was "the ACC sucks so bad that SMU got to the championship in its first year" and then "clearly, SMU didn't deserve to be in the CFP, because they pissed down their legs in Happy Valley." SMU adds NOTHING. Adding SMU to the ACC was like adding capers to a really sad little half-melted ice cream sundae. 3) I'm sure they'll take calls from transfer portal guys, but the state of California is never going to be a recruiting focus for VT, ever. So, again, who cares? 4) Yes, of course, VT has never had billion dollar football complexes with lazy rivers and waterfalls. But, VT has also never had to directly pay players via revenue sharing either. That's a major, major change that's coming this fall, and you're just acting like, meh, "Ohio State has always had more money." That's true, but now schools have a capped amount they have to directly pay players with, and NIL contracts have to prove FMV. That's a MAJOR change - it's daylight and dark when compared to how things have been run since NIL arrived. 5) I'm not arguing that the ACC is better than the B12. If you want to have that argument, then it won't last long, because I don't think the ACC is a better football conference than the B12. 6) I think, at least definitely outside the SEC and B10, we are going to ultimately see a paradigm where individual schools negotiate the media rights for their own home football (and maybe basketball) games, and conference affiliation only exists for scheduling purposes and 2nd and 3rd tier media rights negotiations. If so, that's going to be a major game changer.
Posted: 01/14/2025 at 05:56 PM ET
(In response to this post by Big12 guy)

Thread Replies (35)

Full Thread →
What's going on with the ESPN/ACC renewal?
RandomAsianGuy 01/13/25 09:13 PM ET
There is zero chance Disney decides not to renew the ACC contract.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/14/25 10:34 AM ET
Yes, I believe Disney will definitely renew.
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 01:02 PM ET
The ACC is not going to remain #3.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/14/25 03:15 PM ET
The ACC is the Ottoman Empire c. 1900.
Maroon Baboon 01/15/25 04:33 PM ET
Agree 100%. Anyone that argues otherwise-
Baltimore_Hokie 01/15/25 04:55 PM ET
Disagree. Fantasy worst case scenario. 1 among many scenarios good and bad.**
VTinSC 01/15/25 10:06 AM ET
That's a very nice opinion.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/15/25 12:04 PM ET
It’s all spec and with things ongoing on fb world I would not speculate at
VTinSC 01/15/25 01:34 PM ET
Disagree but I will explain my view later. **
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 07:22 PM ET
I look forward to reading your thoughts.**
Baltimore_Hokie 01/15/25 12:11 PM ET
Started a new thread.**
RandomAsianGuy 01/15/25 01:59 PM ET
I agree that there will not be a clear #3 football conference with
Big12 guy 01/14/25 04:36 PM ET
A couple thoughts in response:
Baltimore_Hokie 01/14/25 05:07 PM ET
Love, love, love all the SMU hate...!!!!
SMU Pony 01/15/25 01:21 AM ET
You're such an idiot, that this all-time idiot post required two responses.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/15/25 12:36 PM ET
Ah, the point about travel, the true tell of a troll...
SMU Pony 01/15/25 08:52 PM ET
You can't read, and even if you could, you can't think.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/16/25 10:11 AM ET
SMU might be in the ACC to stay, but I assure you a lot of programs aren't.
Baltimore_Hokie 01/15/25 12:10 PM ET
To add to your #3, it's also self serving for the ACC staff
HokieAl 01/14/25 05:32 PM ET
I firmly believe that Disney/ESPN are actively trying to break the ACC up-
Baltimore_Hokie 01/14/25 05:58 PM ET
Good response. Lets go backwards on your points.
Big12 guy 01/14/25 05:28 PM ET
More thoughts in response:
Baltimore_Hokie 01/14/25 05:56 PM ET
Why is there so little reporting on an issue this big?
33laszlo99 01/14/25 12:38 AM ET
What would you expect to hear reported?
Pylons 01/14/25 05:20 PM ET
All true. But I see endless reports about coaching changes, PAC/MWC
33laszlo99 01/14/25 09:03 PM ET
After the endless speculation about ESPN dropping the ACC
RandomAsianGuy 01/15/25 12:49 AM ET
I guess it's not just a simple renewal.
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 12:58 PM ET
What will The ACC offer in return? ESPN doesn't have to pay a penny more.
33laszlo99 01/15/25 11:10 AM ET
Don't forget that there are negotiations about uneven distributions. **
Big12 guy 01/14/25 04:54 PM ET
That’s an ACC internal matter. **
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 07:17 PM ET
I agreee, their is a business case for the ACC
1947Sunbowl 01/13/25 11:26 PM ET
Agreed
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 12:50 PM ET
Why is #3 so important to you? It doesn't even come close to
Big12 guy 01/14/25 05:01 PM ET
Because the ACC will need to backfil with certain B12 schools
RandomAsianGuy 01/14/25 07:20 PM ET
That's sort of what I expect.
EDGEMAN 01/14/25 05:45 AM ET