All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

You may be right that it is more complicated and most ADs treat it that way

At the same time many of those same schools may have been involved in the NCAA's fight to try to get Title IX repealed. Even if the ADs aren't intentionally treating it as a zero sum game now, they may be doing it on a subconscious level though particularly in some of the narratives ADs give publicly when they announce the cutting of men's sports and the addition of women's sports. Here's an example from 2006 when JMU decided to cut 10 teams that I think supports their premise. "In late September of 2006, the Board of Visitors at James Madison University announced a plan to cut a total of ten teams (7 men’s and 3 women’s), effective July 1, 2007 in an effort to address what was described as an “insurmountable challenge” to comply with Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 due to the athletics program being “unusually large for a public university” of its size (Staff, September 29, 2006). The decision will affect 144 athletes (eight of whom are on athletic scholarships) and 11 coaches (three full time and eight part time). With assurances that every avenue had been explored prior to reaching their decision, associate vice-president of communications Andy Perrine elaborated, “We would not have done it [cut teams] if not for Title IX. There was just about no way we could add more women’s programs and afford it and be in compliance” (Redden, 2006). Citing the ten point gap in the percentage of women within the student body compared to women in the athletic program (roughly 61% to 51%), vice president for finance and administration Charles King wrote in his November 2006 newsletter, “We could not continue to be out of compliance with this important federal law, which requires institutions to have a percentage of varsity athletes that is about the same by ratio as the student body. At JMU, this means that approximately 60% of our varsity athletes must be women.” https://sportslitigationalert.com/james-madison-universit...
Posted: 06/02/2022 at 03:39 PM ET
(In response to this post by 2hhoop3)

Thread Replies (36)

Full Thread →
ACC mens Lacrosse
Sunsetunderground 06/01/22 03:02 PM ET
LAX to me is the least enjoyable game of all of our games to watch. The
IB4TECH 06/08/22 11:04 AM ET
Title IX**
VT ChemE 1986 06/02/22 08:02 PM ET
100%**
Vippie1 06/03/22 12:15 PM ET
I do not think........
2hhoop3 06/02/22 01:50 PM ET
ACC Schools have been adding Women's LAX lately.
HOO86 06/01/22 06:48 PM ET
Add them all at once!
Truthahn 06/02/22 01:27 PM ET
Given that Title IX is the law of the land, do you think those 5 schools
VTHokie2000 06/01/22 07:34 PM ET
Old Article on Louisville suggests adding women's gymnastics
Truthahn 06/02/22 01:17 PM ET
Clemson is in process of adding Women's Gymnastics
HOO86 06/02/22 02:27 PM ET
Even if the article is outdated, it does present a reasonable justification
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 02:15 PM ET
No I don't advise cutting anything.
HOO86 06/02/22 09:22 AM ET
Oh I agree with you. I hate seeing a school cut a men's sport (or sports)
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 02:32 PM ET
Probably because it requires adding another women's sport
EDGEMAN 06/01/22 04:16 PM ET
We should get a couple of teams to do it at once to avoid that.
Truthahn 06/02/22 01:28 PM ET
I would love to see how Army and Navy
Sunsetunderground 06/02/22 12:47 PM ET
I think academies match their student body ratio
Truthahn 06/03/22 11:50 AM ET
Correct. The rule is not a 50/50 split of opportunity, it is
Pylons 06/04/22 07:07 PM ET
This would be true for anything added.
HOO86 06/01/22 07:32 PM ET
Here are 2 DI bylaws that may address the topic.
VTHokie2000 06/01/22 08:09 PM ET
Unlike soccer, where you an go international...
EDGEMAN 06/01/22 07:48 PM ET
That all depends on who the coaches are
HOO86 06/02/22 09:25 AM ET
I found a website which claims lacrosse is played in 78 countries.
VTHokie2000 06/01/22 08:28 PM ET
Or go the Richmond route: add men's Lax, cut men's soccer AND men's track.**
J-Dub 06/01/22 04:34 PM ET
IMO........
2hhoop3 06/02/22 01:35 PM ET
According to The Meadowlarks, most DI schools have been treating this issue
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 02:42 PM ET
Not sure .....
2hhoop3 06/02/22 03:27 PM ET
You may be right that it is more complicated and most ADs treat it that way
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 03:39 PM ET
That's not happening **
VaTechHokiesACC 06/01/22 11:58 PM ET
Agreed. VT isn't adding men's lacrosse.
J-Dub 06/02/22 08:56 AM ET
Not financial prudent in this environment
Mercury 06/06/22 09:16 AM ET
Richmond added it recently and is doing well.
Truthahn 06/02/22 01:37 PM ET
With the transfer portal and an excellent coaching hire....
Old Line Hokie 06/02/22 02:58 PM ET
Isn't lacrosse somewhat popular in the Richmond area (at least among the
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 02:54 PM ET
Lacrosse has.....
2hhoop3 06/02/22 04:26 PM ET
I agree there are still things VT would need to overcome. I was just
VTHokie2000 06/02/22 04:34 PM ET
Why would VT (or any school) want to cut a sport that it is competitive and
VTHokie2000 06/01/22 05:53 PM ET