All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

Even if all athletes are ruled as employees, I would think there would

still need to be rules in place and some entity (i.e. association) in place to monitor those rules. I'm trying to picture how the NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB, or MLS would function if there were no rules in place. In theory the NCAA could still exist even if all athletes were ruled employees. All that would need to happen is to modify the bylaws to be compliant with any court ruling or changes in the laws. Now the schools could debate on whether each sport should have its own association like what we currently see with the pro leagues now or whether it could remain consolidated like how the NCAA is currently structured. There are pros and cons with both options and I don't know which would be the better option for the schools.
Posted: 02/23/2024 at 11:57 PM ET
(In response to this post by Stech)

Thread Replies (26)

Full Thread →
Tenn Federal Judge just froze NIL rules. Stated NIL rules cause irreparable
Stech 02/23/24 05:30 PM ET
Why did Virginia AG join Tennessee AG in this lawsuit??
mjfhokie 02/27/24 11:17 AM ET
The VA AG went to JMU for undergrad and seeing as how the NCAA planned to
VTFan29 02/27/24 01:02 PM ET
My guess is he doesn’t want Tech and UVA left out of the P2.**
Stech 02/27/24 12:42 PM ET
Why the NCAA wanted to keep this door closed
Colonel Jessup 02/24/24 06:43 AM ET
POWER, keep their power and money!!**
Stech 02/24/24 05:10 PM ET
Next up, NCAA player eligibility rules will be thrown out by the same logic
tarheelblue 02/23/24 05:44 PM ET
Could the Power 2 take down the NFL?
MVIII 02/27/24 10:33 AM ET
I don't disagree with this**
VTCALS72 02/23/24 09:13 PM ET
P2 wants to make their own rules, and this will go a long way in helping.**
Stech 02/23/24 06:25 PM ET
Sounds like the only rule will be that there are no rules.**
JohnsonCItyHokie 02/23/24 10:07 PM ET
It sure does.**
Stech 02/23/24 11:04 PM ET
I can't wait to see a VT defender tackle an opposing player through a table
VTHokie2000 02/24/24 12:36 AM ET
Sounds like Iike a libertarian paradise to me.**
PadrosWindup 02/24/24 10:18 AM ET
In other words, pay for play is on!!**
Stech 02/23/24 05:32 PM ET
If I'm a wealthy booster, I'm loving this.
PadrosWindup 02/24/24 10:46 AM ET
It’s called professional sports, and not amateur sports. Gambling makes it
Stech 02/24/24 07:32 PM ET
Also basically made the NCAA unable to enforce their rules.**
Stech 02/23/24 05:34 PM ET
* For a reason other than incompetence**
WestyHokie 02/24/24 10:35 AM ET
The money has destroyed the NCAA
DMV Gobbler 02/23/24 11:41 PM ET
Even if the P2 want to do their own thing, how does the rest of DI, DII,
VTHokie2000 02/23/24 07:57 PM ET
I don't think anyone cares
DMV Gobbler 02/24/24 08:56 AM ET
I doubt money is the driving factor for the NCAA DII, NCAA DIII, NAIA DI,
VTHokie2000 02/24/24 01:06 PM ET
Dartmouth athletes are ruled employees by NLRB, now this ruling, the NCAA
Stech 02/23/24 09:07 PM ET
Even if all athletes are ruled as employees, I would think there would
VTHokie2000 02/23/24 11:57 PM ET
Agreed they will have some rules, the question is what will be the rules &
Stech 02/24/24 12:08 AM ET
Even if it ends up being another organization or organizations, then do you
VTHokie2000 02/24/24 12:31 AM ET