All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie OP
Jun 20, 2026 at 01:53 PM ET
Engineering rankings….Thoughts….
Offhand…..GT, VT, Purdue, JHU, UCSD, Mich and Wash too low. Harvard, Columbia, NYU, Yale and Penn too high. Duke should be on list. ** Edited by CrystalCoveHokie at 6/20/2026, 1:53:44 PM

18 Replies

ColoVT82 ColoVT82
1mo
In my 38 years, I worked with many top engineers. Not a one from Berkle
Berkley, Harvard, Michigan or Penn state. In fact, one aero engineer from Penn state didn't know what a areynolds number was, or a froude number.... MIT, caltech? Sure
VaTechie VaTechie
1mo
LOL, I prefer this ranking
Link: xxxxx
CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie OP
1mo
This one is better….
RTFC RTFC
1mo
I like this one
Link: CE
PhotoHokieNC PhotoHokieNC
1mo
Too bad there's no access.
J
jdkhokie
1mo
Some info and more info on this bull****.
Niche is a Pittsburgh-based education review and ranking company, sir. Here's the rundown: It's an American company that runs a ranking and review site, headquartered in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. It started life under a different name — Niche.com was formerly known as College Prowler, founded by Luke Skurman in 2002 as a publisher of print guidebooks on U.S. colleges. Skurman is still the founder and CEO. It rebranded to Niche and shifted from print guidebooks to free online content around 2009, then expanded well beyond colleges — today it covers K–12 schools, colleges, cities, neighborhoods, and companies across the United States. Claude says: A ranking that weights acceptance rate and student-survey vibes most heavily is measuring how hard a school is to get into and how much students like being there — not whether the engineering education or research is any good. Those are different questions, and Niche conflates them. That's why a brand-heavy Ivy with a modest engineering school can outrank Virginia Tech, which is a genuine heavyweight by the measures that actually track engineering output: research expenditures, ABET program depth, PhD production, and recruiter reputation. The fault is as much on anyone treating a campus-satisfaction grade as if it were an engineering-research assessment.
CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie OP
1mo
It’s not Niche, it’s QS
J
jdkhokie
1mo
QS doesn't do letter rankings if it is QS it was redone by someone else.
Niche is the only one that does letter rankings which is why I assumed it was Niche. I would question someone taking information from QS and reformatting. ** Edited by jdkhokie at 6/20/2026, 9:17:43 PM ** Edited by jdkhokie at 6/20/2026, 10:07:53 PM
CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie OP
1mo
It was simply taking the ratings of US schools and grading them….
In blocks of 5s.
bourbonstreet bourbonstreet
1mo
"D" is fo' diploma?
seems a bit O&M low... tho' Holden/MINE biased here, mea culpa... b.street
chumley chumley
1mo
…dees get degrees
V
Va AandM
1mo
QS is done by a Brit analytics firm. Very research (publication) centric
I think it overweights academic research if one is considering strength of undergrad teaching. Different if considering a grad school. In my discipline, picking your mentor meaning prof running your project mattered equal and likely more than the school. From their site: What the Rankings Measure The rankings evaluate over 1,500 institutions worldwide using a standardized methodology based on the following key indicators: Top Universities +2 Academic Reputation (30%): Global surveys of academics evaluating research and teaching quality. Employer Reputation (15%): Surveys assessing how well an institution's graduates perform in the workplace. *Research Impact & Citations (20%): *Measures of the average research impact per faculty member. Faculty/Student Ratio (10%): An evaluation of teaching resources. International Outlook (10%): The proportion of international students and faculty. Sustainability & Employability: Modern metrics evaluating environmental impact, social responsibility, and graduate career success.
Link: From QS
UTPr0sim UTPr0sim
1mo
Very ivy league centric. Pretty sure the small ivy's aren't doing the
amount of research that the publics are. And who even knew Columbia, Penn, NYU, Yale and Northwestern had Engineering programs.
E
EDGEMAN
1mo
Wow, the D tier? Seriously?
PhotoHokieNC PhotoHokieNC
1mo
Really. Who’s ranking again?
E
EDGEMAN
1mo
Noticed all of the Ivys are ranked higher than VT.
Didn't even know they offered engineering classes. Wonder if most of their engineering students have to take remedial math when they arrive?
PhotoHokieNC PhotoHokieNC
1mo
The popular saying is, “They said there’d be no reading!”
astrohokie astrohokie
1mo
Wait, no uva?