All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

HokieGator HokieGator OP
Jan 29, 2025 at 07:01 PM ET
Car buying question...
I found the truck I want. They have a new '25 model here locally. It's a bit more than I'd like to pay. They do have a similar '24 model on the lot (that doesn't have all the bells and whistles)...They gave me an estimate and the '24 qualifies for quite a bit more discounts than the newer '25. But... I found the same truck (or close to it) in a '24 model that has all the bells and whistles at a different dealership in North Carolina. The price they have listed for the '24 there is the same as the '25 here. I'm wondering if I should approach my salesman about seeing if he could get that one here and I'd buy that (I'd assume he could give me the same incentives since it's a 24 model.)? Or do I just contact the place in NC and tell them about the deal I'm getting here and see if they can give me better?

25 Replies

mtnrun mtnrun
I actually flew out to an Iowa dealership a couple of years ago to purchase
A 2023 F150 Tremor. Even with flight, hotel, and gas driving home I saved about 16,000 off MRSP. If you aren't in a hurry, search the internet. Some deals to be had if you dont mind heading out of state.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
I talked to shelor and my sales person said they work with that dealer
Often and it wouldn’t be a problem. I just wanted to see what my guy at shelor can do. We drove to Kernersville, NC to get my wife’s van, so that doesn’t bother me.
TravelingHokie TravelingHokie
It's unlikely they will give you as good of a deal on a truck they have to
Bring in from another dealership as one sitting on their lot. There will be more negotiation room on a 2024 than a 2025 either way, and that's independent of options.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
Good to know. That's why I wanted to find a 24 that was the same as the 25
in hopes that I can get some more off, even if it comes from a different dealership.
Tafkam Hokie Tafkam Hokie
Based on the links you provided, it looks like
you are in the NRV and the '24 is in Mt Airy. Would it be so horrible to just drive to Mt Airy and buy the truck from that dealership instead of trying to haggle with Shelor and pay the freight? I've driven to NC to buy a car before.
Vtskier1 Vtskier1
I'd buy a Toyota.... :)
HokieGator HokieGator OP
I would, if not for the tiny back seats.
chumley chumley
…I’d give them away but my wife won’t let me
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
My advice: buy the one with the fewest bells and whistles.
That crap will all break just after the warranty ends, and you will be pissed. The more electronics, the more stuff to go wrong, and the more expensive it will be to repair.
E
EDGEMAN
But with the biggest V8. :)
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
Does any 2024 or newer truck come with a V8?
vthokieq vthokieq
Yes, Chevy and GMC both do.
Can also get a few Ford trims with a V8 as well ** Edited by vthokieq at 1/29/2025, 8:40:10 PM
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
Good to know. It's a shame GM's transmissions are so soft these days.
I know two people who have had to replace the transmission in their 2017 or newer GM/Chevy half ton truck before they hit 75,000 miles. I would definitely not purchase a modern GM half ton truck.
E
EDGEMAN
Even their Allison transmissions?
But I think they are on the heavy duty "light" trucks.
vthokieq vthokieq
I’ve owned two Silverados and didn’t have an issue
Had a Tahoe and Avalanche before that. I tend to replace mine between 90-100k though.
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
What years? Seems like it's a more modern problem.
vthokieq vthokieq
Last one I owned was a ‘17 or ‘18…:don’t remember.
Had around 92k miles when I traded it. I’ve got a Ram right now, but I’ll certainly look at the GMC AT4 next go round as I think that’s the best looking truck out right now. I’ve been very lucky I guess, have never really had any major mechanical issues on any vehicle I’ve owned and that includes all kinds of makes.
E
EDGEMAN
Probably not. If Dodge dropped their Hemis, you know everyone else...
...has probably dropped their V8s too.
MP4VT2004 MP4VT2004
Yeah, that's what I thought I had heard.
Still clinging to my '08 Hemi.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
I take it you won't be a fan of the 3.5L Hybrid engine.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
Here's the two trucks for reference.
this is the local one. '25 model. They say they'll sell it for about $60,000.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
and here's the other one.
'nearly' identical. I would think I'd get more discounts on this one and could get it for much less than $60000
astrohokie astrohokie
You already decided
E
EDGEMAN
It doesn't hurt to ask.
I would definitely contact the local dealership you're working with and tell them what you found and if they will match that offer.
HokieGator HokieGator OP
I think the issue is theirs is a '25 and the one in NC is a '24. Salesman
told me there were more eligible discounts on the 24s since they wanted to get them off the lot for the 25s coming in. He was able to get about 10 grand off the 24 model msrp, but only about 5 grand off the 25 model. The 24 model had a $6,000 rebate (off of the listed price of $58,000) but the 25 model only had a $2500 rebate (off the listed price of $66,000).