All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

CPVT3 CPVT3 OP
Dec 06, 2025 at 09:26 PM ET
How have Tulane, JMU, Duke etc excelled with lesser recruits compared to VT
I just don't get it. Is it purely coaching? Other teams with worse recruiting classss and less money even before this recent uptick have competent football plays, or at a minimum, some semblance of an offensive and defensive identity, and VT can't even get close to scratching the surface for several years. I just don't get how we can't even have a passable offense (no pun intended) yet other programs can, with lesser investment and recruiting. I'm super hopeful for some sort of coaching competency with Franklin. (And maybe my statistics are wrong or I don't understand something. Just wild VT has sucked for SO LONG. You'd think one year we might get lucky in spite of ourselves)

9 Replies

3
3Manysons
7mo
Different answer in each case
Some combination of QB play, better university and alumni support relative to peers, schedule and deep reliance on transfer portal suggesting far more money and probably some coaching.
4
40ozDistrict
7mo
Great question. Answer has to be coaching. Not just game day but all year
setting expectations. Instilling discipline. Motivating each player. In a word "leadership". At least that's what I learned and experienced in the US Army. Saw it and the lack of it throughout my work career afterwards.
VictoryTurkey VictoryTurkey
7mo
QB Play
CPVT3 CPVT3 OP
7mo
Just sad we've whiffed so hard on QBs
Or development Or both ** Edited by CPVT3 at 12/6/2025, 10:45:09 PM
GCHokieof91 GCHokieof91
7mo
How good are the coaches at evaluating talent
and finding diamonds in the rough? That’s a big part of it.
W
WKHOKIE
7mo
It's coaching, coaching leadership, and staff experience.
CPVT3 CPVT3 OP
7mo
God we've had some bad coaching then.
Tank Tank
7mo
Poor leadership...top to bottom. And some are still around. Disgusting.
CPVT3 CPVT3 OP
7mo
Like really really bad. Even a broken clock is right twice