Lots to unpack there...
You listed 4 groups, but in reality there are an infinite number of reasons for transferring. Transferring to be closer to home, transferring to escape an abusive coach (Mike Rice, Lonergan, etc), transferring to be closer to a gf/bf, transferring because of life circumstances (having a child, etc)
Where you either make a mistake or make an unintentional distinction is thinking that any of the reasons for leaving are represented equally in the number of transfers.
For instance, you listed 4 categories...those categories are not split 25%, 25%, 25% and 25%.
Tons of kids who are cut do find homes. 100% of the kids we cut in my decade as a coach found homes. We lost a total of 2 who wanted better opportunities...in a decade.
But I can guarantee you that the 45% of people who didn't find homes were cut. Being good enough that a coach wouldn't want to cut you, transferring anyway and no one else finding you worth a scholarship simply doesn't happen.
In order to prove this. Please name someone who transferred willingly and didn't find a home. It just doesn't happen.
So 45% is guaranteed to be cuts. So all I need for my statement to be absolutely true is for 25% to be cut, but find a new home. That's less than half of the remaining transfers who did find a home.
It is very easy to find that to be true. Come up with any number of players who left their school willingly and I'll provide 2 players who were cut.
Cutting players is the overwhelming majority of players who enter the transfer portal...that's not an opinion
Thread Replies (50)
It sounds as though on net, inferior players are being run off. If so, why
-- TDVick
Aug 23, 2023 at 10:11 AM ET
TDVick
•
08/23/23 10:11 AM ET
The extra COVID year has affected supply and demand in the portal.
-- nvpbrown
Aug 17, 2023 at 10:13 PM ET
nvpbrown
•
08/17/23 10:13 PM ET
This post by PhotoHokieNC removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by Palmetto Hokie removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by WestEndHokie39 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GreenvilleVT removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GreenvilleVT removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by vtbball80 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by GCHokie34 removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by TomTurkey removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
This post by hokieinparadise removed by Tech Sideline admin
Overwhelming majority of players are in the portal because they were cut...
-- GCHokie34
Aug 17, 2023 at 04:42 PM ET
GCHokie34
•
08/17/23 04:42 PM ET
Well more than half 55% did find a new home so overwhelming majority may be
-- vtox1
Aug 23, 2023 at 09:08 AM ET
vtox1
•
08/23/23 09:08 AM ET
Had a friend who played at Tech before the TP was even dreamed of.He was
-- uber hokie
Aug 26, 2023 at 09:06 AM ET
uber hokie
•
08/26/23 09:06 AM ET
The NCAA made it legal to cut players within a certain period of time...
-- GCHokie34
Aug 26, 2023 at 09:10 AM ET
GCHokie34
•
08/26/23 09:10 AM ET
We hear a ton about coaches not liking the portal. I call hogwash and
-- IronBlood
Aug 17, 2023 at 04:11 PM ET
IronBlood
•
08/17/23 04:11 PM ET
Taking advantage of it doesn't necessarily equate to liking it.
-- Pylons
Aug 18, 2023 at 02:38 PM ET
Pylons
•
08/18/23 02:38 PM ET
Pretty high percentage of players enter portal involuntarily because they
-- icelus
Aug 17, 2023 at 03:10 PM ET
icelus
•
08/17/23 03:10 PM ET
Every team probably has half the rooster not getting all the playing time
-- uber hokie
Aug 26, 2023 at 08:52 AM ET
uber hokie
•
08/26/23 08:52 AM ET
And fans never complain about those transfers**
-- vtbball80
Aug 22, 2023 at 12:08 PM ET
vtbball80
•
08/22/23 12:08 PM ET
Were many able to stay where they were or were bridges burned?**
-- JRHokie73
Aug 17, 2023 at 02:50 PM ET
JRHokie73
•
08/17/23 02:50 PM ET
In some cases, the coaches suggested the transfer portal.
-- HokieJack
Aug 17, 2023 at 03:14 PM ET
HokieJack
•
08/17/23 03:14 PM ET
I don't think that's less painful.
-- Pylons
Aug 18, 2023 at 02:50 PM ET
Pylons
•
08/18/23 02:50 PM ET
A suggestion goes something like this. (Yes, it is painful)
-- HokieJack
Aug 18, 2023 at 03:11 PM ET
HokieJack
•
08/18/23 03:11 PM ET
Well, that's pulling the scholarship, not really "suggesting the portal"
-- Pylons
Aug 18, 2023 at 03:25 PM ET
Pylons
•
08/18/23 03:25 PM ET
Of course, football and basketball are head count sports.
-- HokieJack
Aug 20, 2023 at 03:04 PM ET
HokieJack
•
08/20/23 03:04 PM ET
I think it's pretty well established that players get cut.
-- Pylons
Aug 20, 2023 at 03:38 PM ET
Pylons
•
08/20/23 03:38 PM ET
I think we will see a drop when covid eligible players are gone. **
-- vthhhi
Aug 17, 2023 at 02:40 PM ET
vthhhi
•
08/17/23 02:40 PM ET
there were a lot more kids with eligibility left than normal, more to push
-- Vienna_Hokie
Aug 17, 2023 at 08:45 PM ET
Vienna_Hokie
•
08/17/23 08:45 PM ET
Some players want a lower conference in order to play more and have better
-- DGHOKIE
Aug 17, 2023 at 01:28 PM ET
DGHOKIE
•
08/17/23 01:28 PM ET
Maybe there are some regulatory changes
-- soflahokie
Aug 17, 2023 at 01:16 PM ET
soflahokie
•
08/17/23 01:16 PM ET
So where do they end up?JUCO?Div.2?Playing in some obscure overseas league?**
-- HokieBrazil
Aug 17, 2023 at 01:14 PM ET
HokieBrazil
•
08/17/23 01:14 PM ET
Is there anybody out there educating the players about the risk
-- VT ChemE 1986
Aug 17, 2023 at 12:56 PM ET
VT ChemE 1986
•
08/17/23 12:56 PM ET
The risk they are taking by being cut?**
-- GCHokie34
Aug 20, 2023 at 01:39 PM ET
GCHokie34
•
08/20/23 01:39 PM ET
in a lot of cases, I doubt it. Young people make dumb decisions. **
-- VT Pez4Life
Aug 17, 2023 at 12:59 PM ET
VT Pez4Life
•
08/17/23 12:59 PM ET