Login | Sign Up
TechSideline

All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Men's Basketball Board
◀ ▶
L
Joined: 01/01/2022
Posts: 1,794
Likes: 1,270
LXNTN_HOKIE
Subscriber

Some players are transferring every year. There needs to be some limit.

After you've transferred once, you should have to sit out a year after 2nd transfer. Or at least sit out after 3rd transfer.
Posted: 04/14/2023 at 03:02 AM ET
(In response to this post by TomTurkey)

Thread Replies (98)

Full Thread →
Alleyne back on the portal market **
millmtnhokie • 04/13/23 01:57 PM ET
A few of the UCONN fans are humorous, they just won a natty and complaining**
Tuckahokie • 04/14/23 11:00 AM ET
Must be a nice problem to have. **
VaTechHokiesACC • 04/14/23 09:17 PM ET
One possibility is that there’s a certain graduate program he wants…
ombandit • 04/14/23 06:44 AM ET
Yeah you’re onto something. Mens BB unicorns do exist**
JackDSML • 04/14/23 09:09 AM ET
Adam Smith is about the only player I've every seen do that
hoosnowahokie • 04/14/23 08:30 AM ET
Pamplin has few VT athletes in the Data Analytics Masters program
UpperQuad • 04/14/23 09:49 PM ET
It's starting/playing time. He wants more minutes to showcase his talent**
HokieRat • 04/14/23 08:14 AM ET
It’s always about playing time. Ask any coach. Signed A Coach**
JackDSML • 04/14/23 09:17 AM ET
Love the back to VT tweet.**
atlhokie1 • 04/13/23 10:01 PM ET
The portal and NIL have completely killed college athletics
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 08:50 PM ET
No, just changed the traditional form of college athletics
NC Hoke • 04/14/23 11:30 AM ET
No. The transfers done and money made by everyone but the players
Gator Hokie • 04/14/23 09:35 AM ET
Quite the opposite. The portal has brought better parity
hoosnowahokie • 04/14/23 08:26 AM ET
Of course this assumes parity makes sports better - which IMO it doesn't
marcbvtgm • 04/14/23 09:38 AM ET
Great games happen when the teams are evenly matched
soflahokie • 04/14/23 11:56 AM ET
NIL just put (almost) everything that was under the table, above the table.
WholeLottaHokie • 04/14/23 08:52 AM ET
Angela Reese is raking in $1.3M**
HokieDan95 • 04/13/23 09:43 PM ET
So you have proven my point...
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:15 PM ET
So you begrudge her making bank now
hoosnowahokie • 04/14/23 08:29 AM ET
Yes, the portal killed a billion dollar industry...
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 09:29 PM ET
Yeah sure, so college b’ball is an “Industry” now,you just made his point**
ombandit • 04/14/23 12:39 AM ET
It has been an industry for 50+ years...
GCHokie34 • 04/14/23 11:17 AM ET
It became an industry long before the portal or NIL, so don't see how the
BG Hokie • 04/14/23 09:34 AM ET
An athlete is not fired and kicked out of school for poor performance
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:27 PM ET
Players are kicked off a team for bad performance every yr at every school
GCHokie34 • 04/14/23 11:19 AM ET
No but their scholarship might not be renewed. CMY seems to have sent
atlhokie1 • 04/14/23 08:06 AM ET
You’re correct money corrupts everything sooner or later. If you can’t see
uber hokie • 04/13/23 10:43 PM ET
Viewership has remained the same or grown since the Portals inception
GCHokie34 • 04/14/23 11:20 AM ET
Wouldn't viewership......
2hhoop3 • 04/14/23 06:00 PM ET
Proof source ?? Just finished reading articles with numbers from last
uber hokie • 04/14/23 05:18 PM ET
Viewership =/= attendance
GCHokie34 • 04/14/23 05:55 PM ET
Money is the root of all evil.**
LXNTN_HOKIE • 04/14/23 02:46 AM ET
The love of money is the root of all evil. **
millmtnhokie • 04/14/23 06:48 AM ET
Yes, this comes from the most
GCHokieof91 • 04/14/23 12:19 PM ET
1 Timothy 6:10
millmtnhokie • 04/14/23 01:22 PM ET
Thanks for making the correct statement**
VTCALS72 • 04/14/23 06:57 AM ET
Money don’t talk, it swears! **
ombandit • 04/14/23 06:42 AM ET
How in God's name could you ever be in support of the portal?**
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 09:41 PM ET
Freedom of movement. They aren’t indentured servants.**
Femoyer Hokie • 04/14/23 11:25 AM ET
It’s not just the portal it’s the NIL also. **
uber hokie • 04/14/23 05:21 PM ET
Fans only complain about the portal when they lose players that they want..
vtbball80 • 04/14/23 10:44 AM ET
Because every college student can transfer whether they want.
st_andrew • 04/13/23 09:46 PM ET
I went in and out of the portal several times during the completion of my
IB4TECH • 04/15/23 01:46 PM ET
I liked it better when players had to sit out a year.**
LXNTN_HOKIE • 04/14/23 02:48 AM ET
I wish they would bring that rule back.
NC Hoke • 04/14/23 12:09 PM ET
You are comparing apples and oranges**
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:16 PM ET
So people who
st_andrew • 04/14/23 06:34 AM ET
Take out the CAPS
VTCALS72 • 04/14/23 07:03 AM ET
Ahhh the old company scrip argument
st_andrew • 04/14/23 07:06 AM ET
What a crock. You are saying the payment for a college education
VTCALS72 • 04/14/23 07:13 AM ET
I'm like you. I don't understand the
133303Hokie • 04/14/23 06:56 AM ET
Being against NIL is un American **
st_andrew • 04/14/23 06:58 AM ET
Not every student has signed a contract for a grant in aid
GusDaMan • 04/13/23 10:21 PM ET
But that's exactly what it has become...
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:18 PM ET
Athletic Scholarships are year to year, they can and have been revoked.
Stech • 04/13/23 10:40 PM ET
And fans can leave
TomTurkey • 04/14/23 11:32 AM ET
You are comparing student athletes vs. employees
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:19 PM ET
The Supreme Court with Justices from both side of the aisle changed that.
Stech • 04/14/23 08:45 AM ET
I won't profess to understand all of (i.e. any of) the labor law. I find
HokieEngineer • 04/14/23 12:29 PM ET
That is really the heart of this discussion
VTCALS72 • 04/14/23 07:12 AM ET
Sure. As I said I don't have anything against the portal
GusDaMan • 04/13/23 10:45 PM ET
Gotcha, that’s an interesting idea.**
Stech • 04/14/23 08:38 AM ET
I like that idea.**
LXNTN_HOKIE • 04/14/23 02:52 AM ET
Same way I'm 100% in favor of you being able to leave your job**
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 09:41 PM ET
Again, comparing two very different concepts that are truly not relatable **
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 11:20 PM ET
Then go ahead and explain how they arent...**
GCHokie34 • 04/14/23 11:21 AM ET
I think we need to distinguish.....
2hhoop3 • 04/13/23 08:54 PM ET
Correct**
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 09:41 PM ET
Good grief C.B.! **
ombandit • 04/13/23 05:50 PM ET
Who wants a 30% three point shooter!**
HokieHoopzThe2nd • 04/13/23 04:46 PM ET
More to his game than that **
VaTechHokiesACC • 04/13/23 07:26 PM ET
what exactly? He is a replaceable piece, not a difference maker
Vienna_Hokie • 04/13/23 09:40 PM ET
I could see him playing closer to home for his final year. Maybe GT or Ga.**
LXNTN_HOKIE • 04/14/23 02:56 AM ET
Plays great D.**
atlhokie1 • 04/13/23 10:02 PM ET
Indiana, South Carolina and Georgia so far...
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 05:38 PM ET
Then he ends up at Georgia Tech, puts 20+ on us and folks will wonder who
HokieBrazil • 04/13/23 06:37 PM ET
maybe put up 20+ bricks on us**
Windows NT • 04/13/23 10:52 PM ET
Queue up Rick Nelson, 🎶I'm a traveling man...🎶**
TomTurkey • 04/13/23 04:39 PM ET
Some players are transferring every year. There needs to be some limit. ◄
LXNTN_HOKIE • 04/14/23 03:02 AM ET
Guess Alleyne knows you can't please everyone, got to please yourself.**
KCHokie2 • 04/13/23 06:43 PM ET
Why? **
VT ChemE 1986 • 04/13/23 02:45 PM ET
Well it probably wasn't due to Twitter trolls :-)**
WildTurkE • 04/13/23 06:16 PM ET
Because this is.......
2hhoop3 • 04/13/23 05:24 PM ET
Go after the best freshman transfers.
NC Hoke • 04/14/23 11:51 AM ET
What I can't/don't understand is with all the transferring how are these
TWHokie • 04/13/23 08:12 PM ET
Ask the Vicks how they meet requirements. They were not students **
JackDSML • 04/14/23 02:36 PM ET
Athletes are not the same as regular students in this regard
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 09:41 PM ET
They ain't come here to play no school**
LonghornHokie • 04/13/23 09:37 PM ET
silly Hokie, thinking school and classes have anything to do with this
Vienna_Hokie • 04/13/23 09:23 PM ET
Did you think academics ever mattered? lol...not sure Ike Whitaker
flhokie25 • 04/13/23 08:52 PM ET
Justyn Mutts transferred twice...**
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 09:47 PM ET
He transferred up a level twice.**
atlhokie1 • 04/13/23 10:03 PM ET
And?
GCHokie34 • 04/13/23 10:08 PM ET
And, you’re not supposed to use examples that hurt the disgruntled argument**
hokieZ71 • 04/13/23 10:40 PM ET
What disgruntled argument? Maybe you shouldn't project your feelings.
atlhokie1 • 04/14/23 08:04 AM ET
Sigh....**
VT ChemE 1986 • 04/13/23 05:43 PM ET
That seems to be the ? From most. Only NA knows. **
millmtnhokie • 04/13/23 03:01 PM ET
Hrm...**
WildTurkE • 04/13/23 02:23 PM ET