All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

S
Joined: 07/30/2012
Posts: 13,519
Likes: 11,466

Honestly this view feels myopic and is grasping at a “gotcha”

We hired MY because he was an absolutely perfect fit for what VT needed in 2019, a program builder with a defined track record of success on incredibly lean resources who had a penchant for coaching beautiful basketball. Coming into a team that was EXACTLY how you describe MYs weaknesses, built for a 1 year peak and completely gutted following that 1 year. He came in and was wildly successful with the kinds of players he was used to coaching. Guys who weren’t top recruits that were willing to be coached, has no major egos, and were willing to put the work in. Remember VT is the gum on the bottom of college basketballs shoe, there is no history of success whatsoever here. He made 2 tournaments and has been a bubble team consistently. The concern around “talent” acquisition has torpedoed him. You can’t ask a guy who coaches ego-free ball to all of sudden replace “his” guys with “your” guys and expect the same results. We had good results with poor recruiting, we’ve since gotten average results with the best recruiting we’ve had since Greenberg. MY can recruit, the real question to ask is should he? In a world where we are at the bottom of the pecking order when it comes to NIL, do you really want to be bringing in guys who will jump at their first pay raise? Fire MY and hire an AAU coach for all I care, they’ll certainly feed the egos. Bottom line is MY was a play for sustained success with minimal resources. If the resources aren’t changing then take the MY approach, if they are coming dump him and play NBA style basketball. Whatever you do, don’t ask him to be someone he’s not and complain about the results. Theres plenty of recruiting star talent on this team compared to 2019-2021, I doubt we’d be seeing much more success with another coach. Player retention sucked this year because the admin didn’t deliver on their promises, bottom line. If we aren’t going to fulfill obligations to players, don’t expect them to stick around.
Posted: 12/05/2024 at 04:09 PM ET
(In response to this post by Gobbler Guru)

Thread Replies (24)

Full Thread →
Two things can be true at the same time.
Gobbler Guru 12/05/24 01:55 PM ET
Delete
HokieRat 12/05/24 04:25 PM ET
Honestly this view feels myopic and is grasping at a “gotcha”
soflahokie 12/05/24 04:09 PM ET
In what world is MY a “program builder?” Head coach at exactly one place
JLuge76 12/06/24 06:48 AM ET
Yeah we are a feeder school now. I’d say
GreenvilleVT 12/05/24 08:40 PM ET
No it's not. Laid out nicely and not myopic nor is it grasping at a gotcha
catdaddy 12/05/24 07:51 PM ET
And he is clearly frustrated
SteveInBaltimore 12/05/24 06:17 PM ET
Mark asked how he was going to improve shooting. Asked him for suggestions.
TomTurkey 12/05/24 08:46 PM ET
I don't see why he shouldn't be expected to adjust his approach....
GoldCoast 12/05/24 04:35 PM ET
Overall, the program is a mess
MKD 12/05/24 03:20 PM ET
Add to that, Cassell - especially an empty Cassell - doesn't hold much
501 12/05/24 04:04 PM ET
Hopefully fans keep attending games this year.
MKD 12/05/24 04:23 PM ET
Passing around the perimeter is truly exciting…..a turnover could happen
hokieblitz 12/05/24 06:29 PM ET
Excellent overall macro post which I feel is pretty spot on. **
catdaddy 12/05/24 03:07 PM ET
Given the state of football, we are FUBAR until the ACC gets this divorce
WildTurkE 12/05/24 02:52 PM ET
The ACC is a disaster because of the ridiculous media rights contract **
MKD 12/05/24 03:30 PM ET
I tend to agree that we a stuck at this point football and hoops wise
Vippie1 12/05/24 03:13 PM ET
Yup. I love CMY, but without the full support he needs to run his system,
VT ChemE 1986 12/05/24 02:40 PM ET
I think at this point I’d start at the top, with both revenue programs
NC Hoke 12/05/24 02:24 PM ET
Do you really think a new AD will solve VT's issues?**
marcbvtgm 12/05/24 03:27 PM ET
Well, think about what has changed in college athletics since Whit took
NC Hoke 12/05/24 05:26 PM ET
Yes.**
GoldCoast 12/05/24 04:26 PM ET
Yes, new AD has to be the starting point before coaching changes.**
Gobbler-100 12/05/24 03:05 PM ET
Not to mention we should have zero faith that Whit
Vippie1 12/05/24 03:17 PM ET
I think CMY was a solid hire at the time for what we needed
HokieAl 12/05/24 02:13 PM ET