All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

laphroaig
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 77,683
Likes: 83,198
Subscriber

Another factor - most pro athletes play one specific position.

IMO we've come to expect too much of that in college sports. Couldn't do that with a smaller roster and reduced scholarships. At the college level it shouldn't be abnormal to see some baseball or softball pitchers batting, or some football players going both ways, or the second or third string center doing the long snapping, or a wide receiver who also punts, or a right fielder who throws in the high 90s coming in to close a game. Your comment about pitchers on a roster reminded me of Earl Weaver's theory about the number of starting pitchers he felt comfortable with. He believed 4 starters was ideal when other managers liked 5. Earl wanted his top four pitchers to pitch more often. He didn't like the idea of the #5 guy taking a start away from his #1 guy in the rotation. In most cases, 3 games/days of rest should be fine outside of the occasional doubleheader when he would use another starter who might be a long-reliever type pitcher. Why play your 5th string guy when your #1 guy is ready to go? Really his theory followed the old saying - you play your best players.
Posted: 05/25/2024 at 06:10 AM ET
(In response to this post by RJHokie)

Thread Replies (32)

Full Thread →
Here's an interesting twist on the NCAA settlement
VTChip 05/24/24 10:53 PM ET
Fully expect us to match what our peers decide to do here, at least with
VTScoop 05/24/24 11:58 PM ET
I would disagree on the football scollies- I think we would stick with the
sacramento hokie 05/25/24 01:38 PM ET
IIRC, Duke (private school) currently has an advantage with schollies for
IB4TECH 05/25/24 11:18 AM ET
Yes, privates and any public that has large endowment dollars that can help
VTScoop 05/25/24 03:31 PM ET
They give free tuition to all lower income students
UpperQuad 05/25/24 03:09 PM ET
Curious to why you think 85 scholarships is more than we need for football
st_andrew 05/25/24 08:31 AM ET
Sorry just responding. Have been tied up today. While I was just
VTScoop 05/25/24 03:12 PM ET
WRT the NFL's roster, the 53-man is the active roster. However, the NFL
VTHokie2000 05/25/24 06:16 PM ET
FCS schools play football with 63 on the roster
UpperQuad 05/25/24 10:56 AM ET
Keep in mind FCS football scholarships are equivalent, so technically a
VTHokie2000 05/25/24 06:13 PM ET
Think what could be done with those 22 other scholarships.**
laphroaig 05/25/24 01:39 PM ET
Sharing revenue will cause rosters and scholarships to be reduced. There's
laphroaig 05/25/24 10:21 AM ET
In-state Tuition
HLTW! 05/25/24 08:20 AM ET
Have not heard how the progress on that front has gone. I need to
VTScoop 05/25/24 03:20 PM ET
Great post. That is a huge disadvantage for Virginia schools**
VTChip 05/25/24 10:58 AM ET
My biggest fear is cutting scholarships for Men’s Olympic Sports, are you
Stech 05/25/24 08:00 AM ET
Sorry for any confusion, I am saying Olympic sports would be getting more
VTScoop 05/25/24 03:26 PM ET
your last sentence says it all Chip
gelded turkey 05/24/24 11:20 PM ET
Mr. Chip
rberry7676 05/24/24 11:17 PM ET
NFL teams have like 45 players. Why should CFB be different?
Jethro Tull 05/25/24 09:51 PM ET
Valid point**
rberry7676 05/25/24 11:03 PM ET
Yeah, but they also have practice players, the waiver wire,
RJHokie 05/25/24 10:34 PM ET
The number may be high......
2hhoop3 05/25/24 10:26 PM ET
Really? CFB is just a farm system for the NFL
Jethro Tull 05/26/24 03:53 PM ET
Yes really......
2hhoop3 05/26/24 04:32 PM ET
Been saying for years - limit football rosters and scholarships to 70.
laphroaig 05/25/24 05:32 AM ET
I don't really disagree with your thoughts
VTChip 05/24/24 11:44 PM ET
As you say, 20 or less is fine for softball.
RJHokie 05/24/24 11:24 PM ET
Another factor - most pro athletes play one specific position.
laphroaig 05/25/24 06:10 AM ET
It worked for Weaver . . . **
MidloHokie 05/25/24 09:06 AM ET
I can appreciate that response
rberry7676 05/24/24 11:35 PM ET
CBS Sports with a similar story
VTChip 05/24/24 10:58 PM ET