All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

N
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 2,340
Likes: 1,995
Subscriber

Been a good thing so far in MLB. Looks like about half get overturned.

But, in most cases we are talking fractions of an inch making the difference. If anything, it should give people increased appreciation for the precision required to make these calls perfect every time. However, I would expect there a lot more variance in college ump calls because they are not going to be as good as MLB umpires. And even a little more variance in softball. One thing I will be watching is how home crowds react to reviews. Sometimes their complaints will be validated and naturally cheers and pats on the back will abound. Sometimes calls will be upheld. Hard to yell "be consistent" and fume at a computer. From watching a few games on TV, about half of the calls home crowds question look like good calls to me. About 30% could go either way. And about 20% were calls that were wrong. One thing that is difficult for umps is this concept of "their strike zone". Teams always say that as long as the umps are consistent they can adapt to a strike zone from ump to ump. Which is fair now. But, won't be the case anymore. Every umpire will have to have the SAME strike zone. Which is good but might be challenging at first. ** Edited by nkhooch at 5/5/2026, 2:55:17 AM ** Edited by nkhooch at 5/5/2026, 1:22:47 PM
Posted: 05/05/2026 at 02:24 AM ET
(In response to this post by VTChip)

Thread Replies (16)

Full Thread →
A bit OT: SEC baseball to try ball/strike challenge system during SEC Tourn
VTChip 05/04/26 10:50 PM ET
This is my single biggest gripe about college softball
Hokie Koooster 05/05/26 11:13 AM ET
There was a horrendous called 3rd strike on Sam Grube Sunday. It ended up
VTBAMA 05/05/26 08:43 AM ET
Nor would I.***
Catbird132 05/05/26 07:24 AM ET
Maybe we could donate $1 to Poppin' It! for each reversed call
TomTurkey 05/05/26 09:09 AM ET
If the technology is in place the computer should be calling balls/strikes
MidloHokie 05/05/26 07:08 AM ET
Been a good thing so far in MLB. Looks like about half get overturned.
nkhooch 05/05/26 02:24 AM ET
SEC baseball tournament is a neutral site, so hard to gauge reaction
VTsportscaster 05/05/26 01:31 PM ET
A friend who I umpired with had a "pitcher's" SZ. I had a"hitter's" SZ.
TomTurkey 05/05/26 09:31 AM ET
Interesting. I have never umped,
nkhooch 05/05/26 01:37 PM ET
Not perfect, but a human official is just part of the game.
TomTurkey 05/05/26 01:46 PM ET
This can’t start soon enough. But how hard is this to setup? And does it
HOKIE SEAN 05/04/26 11:32 PM ET
It would have to use the dimensions of the batter or it won't
nkhooch 05/05/26 02:45 AM ET
And the rules say "normal stance."
TomTurkey 05/05/26 09:34 AM ET
Great points. Jordan Lynch stands very close to the plate. And she
nkhooch 05/05/26 02:01 PM ET
There is an ongoing discussion of the upper part of the "zone."
TomTurkey 05/05/26 02:15 PM ET
I think its probably already set up in most places
VTChip 05/04/26 11:45 PM ET