All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Seikoh_04 Seikoh_04 OP
Dec 09, 2025 at 08:15 PM ET
Interesting concept:
Restructure all of college football into a 128 team league. Play a six game schedule to establish seeding into a 128 team triple elimination playoff. Crown the champion!

11 Replies

B
Baltimore_Hokie
7mo
Who makes the six game schedule, and what's the methodology there?
Seikoh_04 Seikoh_04 OP
7mo
Similar to current conference schedules
Teams will want to keep rivalry games. The first 6 games establish a seeding for the initial 128 team bracket. Beyond that you would have a middle and lower bracket to begin filling with one and two loss teams respectively. Winner of top bracket plays winner of the champions in the lower brackets. There are challenges. Worst team might only play 9 games. There could be games added for eliminated teams. Who gets home games? Could get very skewed. One team in the championship will have zero losses. Is it win or go home at that point? Football isn't known for a series. It would be a complicated mess since it isn't a strict single elimination bracket.
B
Baltimore_Hokie
7mo
I like your concept. Here's mine:
We have geographically defined conferences of around 9-10 teams each. Each team plays every other team in their conference and 3-4 OOC games. No conference championship games; conference champions are defined by conference record with a H2H tiebreaker. After everyone plays their 12 game schedule, we let bowls invite whichever teams they'd like to invite, and then those teams can decide which bowl to accept. Bowl champions get big, shiny trophies. After all those bowl games are decided, and bowl champions crowned, we can all discuss and argue about who was the best team that year. It's a weird idea, but I think people would like it.
V
Vippie1
7mo
Yeah but then everyone's football budget would have to 30 percent less
and schools couldn't afford large NIL budgets, bloated and expensive coaching staffs, or even waterfalls and putt putt courses for players.
Seikoh_04 Seikoh_04 OP
7mo
Sounds familiar. We didn't know how good it was.
I was a big fan of the 4 team playoff at the time. I wish it would have never expanded beyond that.
B
Baltimore_Hokie
7mo
The older I get, the more I recognize how great things were when the-
"NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP" was just a general idea that people talked and argued about, and not an actual thing. Everything just meant a lot more. There was no "opting out" of anything, let alone a bowl game. The Madison Avenue people have really screwed it all up.
B
Big12 guy
7mo
That ship sailed. Expand the playoffs to 24, give
the top 8 bye's and guaranteed home game, and let the other 16 play into it. The portal and players being paid is what changed things. It's just coincidence that the expanded playoff format changed around the same time.
B
Baltimore_Hokie
7mo
I agree. The FCS model is the only way. Everything else is gatekeeper BS.
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
If the FCS had a few more conferences, then it probably could get away
with expanding to a 32-team field like DII or DIII is currently now. I think 1 may even be 40 or 48 (if my memory is correct). 32 always seemed like the perfect number to me because every conference could receive an automatic bid that wants one and every team in the Top 25 should be able to make the field.
B
Big12 guy
7mo
I'd be way OK with that. While a 64 seed in
basketball will never win it all, they will still have to be beat on the court. Probable the same if football expands to that level, but the National champion will have to win it on the field, not in the polls. The way it should be.
VTHokie2000 VTHokie2000
7mo
FWIW unseeded Illinois State beat #1 North Dakota State in the FargoDome
this past weekend 29-28. The Red Birds are the only unseeded team left in the field this year, so you may get an example of an unseeded team winning the NCAA DI Playoffs in football. I suspect if I went through all the playoffs, then I probably would find a year where an unseeded team won it all. Heck FAMU may have even been unseeded when it won the first one in 1978.