All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

P
PFHokie OP
Jul 20, 2024 at 08:51 AM ET
The best way forward?
I’ve been thinking about the best way forward in the future college football play arena. Here’s what I think we’ll see going forward: 1). Split football from the rest of college sports. Let’s face it, VT swimming versus Kansas swimming is just not worth the travel expenses. Some sports need to be some what regional. I don’t know about basketball. I would need to think about that. 2). Consider lumping all the P5, some G2 and independents into one big league. Then, organize regional divisions. The number of teams and divisions can get sorted out. 3). So, organize it into 9 team divisions. Everybody plays everyone else in division (8 games). Then play 6 out of division games. How to determine which 6 out of division games. I know determination of an equitable out of conference schedule will be difficult but not impossible. It’s being done this year with the national championship playoff tournament. 4). Win your division and move up into a super regional playoff. Move forward until there’s a top 8. That’s your championship playoff. 5). You have to have relegation because not allowing the other schools a chance is going to create an inequity and it becomes an antitrust issue. 6). Each last place team (based on some sort of point calculation), would play an extra relegation game against a non premier regional opponent. Determining a non premier opponent would be difficult but it should start with a point system and then move to a last 3 year average point system so that one bad year by a good team doesn’t get you relegated. I think this is somewhat equitable and keeps some regional flavor. There are a couple of things to figure out like determining the non divisional schedule and various point systems or maybe regional committees for relegation decisions. Let me know what you think. I know this is the Euro futball model but it does have it’s merits.

9 Replies

wwhokie1 wwhokie1
Decisions about the way forward are going to be made at the P2 level.
The SEC and Big Ten have managed to set themselves up with all the power. Everyone else was afraid of them and voted to agree with them along the way. Now we have a P2 that controls the future of college football at the highest level. And with the disparity of money, and a few more invitations to other schools in the future, the P2 will have power over the highest level of all college sports of their choice. They can choose to separate and do their own thing. They can threaten to separate and stay if other conferences yield to their wishes. But whatever happens will happen because the P2 wishes for it to happen.
CrystalCoveHokie CrystalCoveHokie
Privatize, license college name, facility leasing……
Players are employed by private company. Don’t need to be students. Title IX problem also goes away. Money still made through the licensing and leasing. More opportunities for male athletes in sports that are run by colleges. Win/win/win.
V
VT ChemE 1986
So, we go back to the way it was at VT before 1987?
Will’s article series, Season of our Discontent” provides valuable insight. ** Edited by VT ChemE 1986 at 7/20/2024, 10:43:08 AM
HokieAl HokieAl
Equity and merit and regional are not considerations. It’s only money
And the P2 does not want to share their money (or their glory).
P
PFHokie OP
All those have to be considered to make the most money
A particular region is going to have more interest in a regional game. There are only about 4 teams that can pull viewers away from those matchups. You have to have some bows to equity or what other format you put together will end up in the courts.
3
33laszlo99
This is Stage 3: Bargaining
** Edited by 33laszlo99 at 7/20/2024, 9:37:23 AM
V
Vippie1
Agree
Once the dust sort of settles and we know who's in, who's out, and there are agreed upon governance and player rules/compensation going forward- then it becomes relatively easy to move schools around into more geographically sensible groups. But we are still a long way from that.
O
ombandit
Drink heavily
P
PFHokie OP
I already do
** Edited by PFHokie at 7/20/2024, 9:53:45 AM