All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

Maybe so, but it would also make it more difficult for programs on the rise

to gain the exposure that typically comes with being ranked. Schools like Ohio State, Notre Dame, Nebraska, Oklahoma, UDub, etc. have the benefit of either being a blue blood program or in that next tier right below the blue blood programs. For the other programs, what will entice someone living in Why, AZ to watch the Backyard Brawl or the K-State vs. IA State game on TV if the rankings isn't an option and the person is unfamiliar with the history of the rivalry? For some of the rivalries that have been on an indefinite pause, enough time has passed where people may not know the history of the rivalry unless they are connected to either school or at least live in the area to be able to interact with fans from either school. Then there are some rivalries (i.e. the Border War - KU vs. Mizzou or Colorado St vs. Wyoming) that were overshadowed during the "glory days" of college football rivalry games because attention was given to bigger rivalries on a national stage. Rankings is one way to increase the exposure for those rivalries. I suspect more people watched the Border War on TV during the few years when KU and Mizzou were ranked in the Top 10-15 for that reason alone. If the rankings went away, then what tools to do the networks have to entice viewers to watch that game than another game going on at the the time that involves at least 1 team with a slightly higher profile? The other thought that crossed my mind is if rankings went away and/or teams aren't penalized for OOC games, then at some point a HC will try to game the system. For example, play all the conference games at the beginning of the season and save all the OOC games for the end of the season. Since the team at the end of the season isn't the same team at the beginning of the season, then it shouldn't matter when a team plays its OOC games because it won't impact a FBS Playoff bid or bowl bid. If anything, playing OOC games late in the regular season may help a winning team because the game is more fresh in the voters mind when trying to compare how 2 conferences stack up to each other for voting purposes.
Posted: 08/14/2025 at 05:34 PM ET
(In response to this post by Big12 guy)

Thread Replies (25)

Full Thread →
As long as we have a Group of 5 AD…
ombandit 08/13/25 12:54 AM ET
JMU with far less money, smaller stadium is preseason ranked above us, let
Stech 08/13/25 05:42 AM ET
I place zero weight on AP or Coaches preseason polls
cvillehokie92 08/13/25 04:04 PM ET
Agree, they are not always accurate, but they think more of them has never
Stech 08/14/25 05:44 AM ET
I think the preseason polls are a scam. It creates
Big12 guy 08/14/25 11:45 AM ET
A purpose for preseason polls is to generate interest for Week 0/Week 1
VTHokie2000 08/14/25 02:53 PM ET
I understand the premise, and how they come up
Big12 guy 08/14/25 02:58 PM ET
If you understand the purpose and still want to change it, then what is
VTHokie2000 08/14/25 03:09 PM ET
With the consolidation of the conferences, it
Big12 guy 08/14/25 04:31 PM ET
Maybe so, but it would also make it more difficult for programs on the rise
VTHokie2000 08/14/25 05:34 PM ET
I think they should wait too, but this has never happened in our history,
Stech 08/14/25 01:20 PM ET
JMU's success is not a negative for VT IMHO. Toledo
Big12 guy 08/14/25 01:30 PM ET
Comparing the JMU-VT relationship with Toledo-Ohio State may be an apples
VTHokie2000 08/14/25 03:02 PM ET
JMU also has a plan in works for expanding Bridgeforth Stadium. Renovating
91HokieBob 08/13/25 12:54 PM ET
So are Tulane, Liberty, Toledo, Memphis, Army and ULL**
CrystalCoveHokie 08/13/25 12:03 PM ET
But they do have a Buc-ee's**
manassashoo 08/13/25 10:21 AM ET
best bathrooms east of the Mississippi**
HokieAl 08/13/25 10:35 AM ET
disagree they give a token ranking to a group of 5 team
1947Sunbowl 08/13/25 09:03 AM ET
So the AD bears ZERO responsibility, yeah SURE…
ombandit 08/13/25 08:12 PM ET
Whit’s presentation on August 18th should have been done day 1 of his job.
Stech 08/13/25 02:04 PM ET
It is the job of the AD to lead
VT ChemE 1986 08/13/25 12:43 PM ET
He is not a ......
2hhoop3 08/13/25 12:53 PM ET
his experience was only assistant AD when we hired him?
HokieAl 08/13/25 01:14 PM ET
No.....
2hhoop3 08/13/25 01:24 PM ET
No, Whit was Cincinnati's AD. Ironically, he was known as a fundraiser and
91HokieBob 08/13/25 01:21 PM ET
It's not exactly an exclusive club though.**
Pylons 08/13/25 06:30 AM ET