All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Will Stewart
Joined: 09/18/1999
Posts: 93,035
Likes: 137,337
Founder Subscriber

We've gotten to where we don't see the point.

Andy interviewed him in December, as did Bill Roth, and the resulting conversations didn't make me feel better about anything. Whit is so imprecise when he speaks, that I come away from interviews without much new knowledge or confidence. NIL has been a thing for almost four years now, and at no point has the athletic department, either through the written word or through interviews, definitely, clearly, and confidently planted their flag in the sand and said, "Here's what we're doing, here's why it's going go work, and we need you behind us. Let's go." Nor have they made inspired, impressive hires, nor have they expressed organizationally, in clear terms, how they're going to function in modern college athletics. Whit muddled along without a CFO for *four years* and they still haven't hired a dedicated head of the Hokie Club who is an experienced, accomplished fundraiser. Having Whit on the podcast as a guest isn't going to help/solve any of that. Interviewing him is very pressure-packed, because you're trying to get clarity on things, and you're looking for answers, but in the end, you ... don't. And it's frustrating. I don't like saying these things, because Whit has always been really good to us, and I like the guy. But as an organization, it's where we (TSL) are. ** Edited by Will Stewart at 3/11/2025, 8:41:46 PM
Posted: 03/11/2025 at 08:40 PM ET
(In response to this post by VTHokie2000)

Thread Replies (36)

Full Thread →
Tech & NIl changing landscape
RiverVT 03/11/25 11:53 AM ET
If all of this is true and "we" are not doing anything for whatever reason
astrohokiebob 03/12/25 10:34 AM ET
There has been more of the kind of outreach you mention above
Nelsonia Hokie 03/12/25 09:16 AM ET
I agree, but how do we know VT isn't engaging donors on NIL?
Will StewartAdmin 03/11/25 07:14 PM ET
Do you really think Babcock is that Proactive
RiverVT 03/11/25 08:42 PM ET
Good points about.....
2hhoop3 03/11/25 08:21 PM ET
Any possibility of having Babcock come on as a guest during the summer?**
VTHokie2000 03/11/25 08:07 PM ET
We've gotten to where we don't see the point.
Will StewartAdmin 03/11/25 08:40 PM ET
And actually, this excerpt from the Bill Roth interview ...
Will StewartAdmin 03/12/25 09:55 AM ET
Your post, at least IMO,......
2hhoop3 03/11/25 09:20 PM ET
You're nice guy.... too nice. I wish someone would verbally rough him up
TDVick 03/11/25 09:01 PM ET
It's a shame because NIL is just 1 of many problems on VT's plate and the
VTHokie2000 03/11/25 08:51 PM ET
There is a "Current strategy to address those issues" in existence?
Atlee Hokie 03/12/25 10:59 AM ET
Even if there is no formal plan, technically it is still a plan called the
VTHokie2000 03/12/25 06:26 PM ET
That's fair, Will. Bit you really don't sound sincere about it.
saret 03/11/25 07:28 PM ET
Exactly. In this era of college athletics when VT appears to behind
VTHokie2000 03/11/25 08:07 PM ET
What if being open will not instill confidence?
VTCALS72 03/11/25 10:02 PM ET
To be honest, if Big Media saId such a thing, i'm kind of MEH.
saret 03/12/25 10:25 AM ET
And posts like your suggest VT can never do anything better than they
NokieHokie 03/12/25 08:56 AM ET
What do you have to say about @Will Stewart post above.
Atlee Hokie 03/11/25 11:20 PM ET
I make the very same point over and over, you guys lay way more at WB
VTCALS72 03/12/25 08:46 AM ET
CALS, I can agree with all that. However, Whit has allowed, albeit lead,
saret 03/12/25 10:19 AM ET
I keep asking you the same question, and you keep ignoring it.
Atlee Hokie 03/12/25 09:48 AM ET
I understand where you are coming from, but
pine52x 03/12/25 09:39 AM ET
I think most posters on here realize VT, in its current state, isn't ready
VTHokie2000 03/12/25 06:55 PM ET
Nice post.**
saret 03/12/25 10:40 AM ET
All Whit did WRT revenue generation was just rearrange deck ...
Atlee Hokie 03/12/25 10:13 AM ET
The Advancement division of VT works with VT Athletics on fundraising.
pine52x 03/12/25 10:37 AM ET
See @saret post concerning Advancement and the HC.
Atlee Hokie 03/12/25 11:04 AM ET
In theory, you are right. But the siloing between the HC and
saret 03/12/25 10:50 AM ET
Then it sounds like the leadership needs to work on its sales pitch. I'm
VTHokie2000 03/11/25 10:27 PM ET
Good post. As you know, CALS is prone to mis-stating, red herrings,
saret 03/12/25 11:32 AM ET
If people have followed my posts on this topic over the years, then they
VTHokie2000 03/12/25 06:42 PM ET
They can't even spell PLANN.**
saret 03/11/25 08:43 PM ET
Maybe @VTScoop can chime in on that.**
NokieHokie 03/11/25 07:16 PM ET
I can chime in on that, but I need to think about the best way to do so....
VTScoop 03/11/25 10:30 PM ET
Thank you, kind sir!**
NokieHokie 03/12/25 08:55 AM ET