All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Maroon Baboon
Joined: 10/14/2003
Posts: 30,199
Likes: 22,204

Agree totally. I think creating a system of relegation and promotion

would deal with tons of the current problems. Some people look at it as high risk for schools. But I look at it as the opposite, because it is fluid and dealt with by on field results. True competition is what draws interest and viewers. Placement should be based on winning, not based on arbitrary things like TV markets, alumni base, AAU membership, and what not. The problem is, very few people want to even consider such models. It's myopic thinking. It's also greedy and anti-competitive. But even trying it on a smaller scale as you suggest would be a good start (unless the model is so flawed that it is doomed to fail). At present, you could do it with the Big XII and ACC for football. Make 3 tiers. Top tier makes close to P2 money, second tier makes near current ACC-B12 payouts, and third tier makes closer to G5 money. About 11 teams at each tier (5 home and 5 away). You's have to find a way to split the tiers up initially and possibly grandfather clause the money for a temporary period, but this isn't hard to do.
Posted: 07/26/2024 at 09:37 AM ET
(In response to this post by jesuisvtguy)

Thread Replies (7)

Full Thread →
Big 12 vs ACC
Two4VT 07/24/24 12:10 PM ET
The ACC should be invading the B12, not the other way around, but…**
Stech 07/24/24 06:23 PM ET
We are long past the time of making a legit P3 conference out of
Maroon Baboon 07/24/24 05:18 PM ET
I'm not sure it is long past, but agreed the ship likely sailed...
jesuisvtguy 07/26/24 08:39 AM ET
Agree totally. I think creating a system of relegation and promotion
Maroon Baboon 07/26/24 09:37 AM ET
I think that would only work if the top teams from both leave and form a
wwhokie1 07/24/24 01:58 PM ET
I hate to advocate for Dook
obguthr 07/24/24 01:19 PM ET
There is no good reason for any ACC school to leave for the Big12
tarheelblue 07/24/24 01:01 PM ET