All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Calamitous
Joined: 10/08/1999
Posts: 3,858
Likes: 1,835
Founder

I wonder if a non NCAA college football organization could end up…

like the old AFL and NFL in the late 60s when they only played one another in preseason or the Super Bowl. The Big Ten could add 2 more schools to have 4 five team divisions and the SEC to add 4 teams to make their 4 five team divisions. The Big 20 could just play one another and have their own championship. The SEC could do the same. And then the Big 20 champ plays the SEC champ in the CFB Super Bowl. The Big 20 could neatly have 4 divisions by adding UVa and UNC to join PSU, UMCP and Rutgers in the East. OSU, MSU, UM, IU and Purdue in the Midwest. NW, Illinois, Iowa, Wisconsin and Minn to the Central. And Nebraska, USC, UCLA, Oregon and UW for the west. A Big 24 with 4 6-team divisions could add Syracuse or Pitt to the east, shift NW to the Midwest, shift Nebraska and add Kansas to the Central, and add Stanford and Cal to the west. The SEC-20 might not be as neat because they need 4. But a potential Big 12 exclusive version could be FSU, Clemson, GT, USC-e and NCSU in the Coastal. UF, UGa, UTenn, Vandy and UK in the East. Bama, Auburn, Ole Miss, MSU and LSU in the Deep South. And aTm, UTex, OU, Ark and Mizzou in the west. A SEC-24 with 4 6-team divisions could shift USC-e to the East, remove USC-e and add WVU and VT to the Coastal, add Ark to the Deep South, and shift Ark out and add TT and Ok St to the west. Every team plays only within their conference much like the old MLB until the 2 conference champions play in the CFB Super Bowl. Each division plays one another every year and they play 2 teams from the other 3 divisions every 3 years if they are 24 team conferences. I hate what college football is now, but if they can get back to more regional divisions it might be salvageable. I would miss a lot of the G5 and left out power schools though.
Posted: 01/15/2026 at 11:25 PM ET
(In response to this post by Big12 guy)

Thread Replies (28)

Full Thread →
A really good opinion piece by
Big12 guy 01/15/26 05:46 PM ET
#5 and #7 are good arguments FOR a super league. **
RandomAsianGuy 01/16/26 07:17 PM ET
I thought the same. It is all about 5 and 7.**
Femoyer Hokie 01/16/26 09:22 PM ET
The writer doesn't know the difference between a "Super League" and the PL
Maroon Baboon 01/16/26 01:48 PM ET
The only way what this author describes comes to fruition is the-
Baltimore_Hokie 01/16/26 12:45 PM ET
100%, and is why the rest of football needs to call the P2's bluff. **
Big12 guy 01/16/26 02:27 PM ET
#6 and #1 are the ones that stand out to me
HokieAl 01/16/26 09:49 AM ET
Used 2 think B1G wanted S League, but 16 were ready 2 sign long GOR, 2 not.
Stech 01/16/26 08:18 AM ET
Currently, the P2 conferences hold the power, and the
Big12 guy 01/16/26 09:13 AM ET
You’re talking about where they are right now, that’s not what my post was
Stech 01/16/26 10:28 AM ET
Ya, I get that. What I was implying is that it will not
Big12 guy 01/16/26 10:35 AM ET
Gotcha, I agree w/ that, I don’t think that happens if the playoff goes 24,
Stech 01/16/26 10:45 AM ET
If they form a different league, I think they
Big12 guy 01/16/26 10:56 AM ET
Thought that too a year ago, what advantage would ESPN have to split it?
Stech 01/16/26 04:58 PM ET
I wonder if a non NCAA college football organization could end up…
Calamitous 01/15/26 11:25 PM ET
Keep wondering if NFL just creates the P1, many of the processes in place.**
Stech 01/16/26 06:07 PM ET
Why would the NFL owners want to take on the additional cost associated
VTHokie2000 01/20/26 01:13 PM ET
Power/Control and they will make money, a lot of it too.**
Stech 01/20/26 01:52 PM ET
That was true 10, 20, and 30 years ago. Multiple leagues have tried to
VTHokie2000 01/20/26 02:01 PM ET
You're right they may not want it, but it was the best TV numbers ever and
Stech 01/20/26 07:05 PM ET
I'm not sure a NFL minor league can maintain that connection with the
VTHokie2000 01/21/26 10:32 AM ET
I don't want it to happen, so I hope you are right.**
Stech 01/21/26 10:56 AM ET
FWIW there are examples in the world where a college is either the primary
VTHokie2000 01/21/26 11:20 AM ET
Former ND football player**
TerryD 01/15/26 09:06 PM ET
IYO would ND join the Super League if this happens, or stay Independent?**
Stech 01/16/26 08:09 AM ET
No idea
TerryD 01/16/26 09:03 AM ET
If ND joins the Super League, they will no longer be independent, League or
Stech 01/16/26 10:34 AM ET
Yes, but I would rather ND, if forced, ......
TerryD 01/18/26 08:29 AM ET
Interesting, what if they go to an NFC AFC model? NFC is SEC & AFC is B1G?
Stech 01/18/26 09:14 AM ET