All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

wwhokie1
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 5,263
Likes: 5,030
Subscriber

Let's make the P2 really mad and do a 10-6 model.

10 conference champions, six at large bids. And let's make them even madder and say that the six at large bids all have to come from different conferences or ND. The reasoning being that if you are only the third best team in your conference, how can you be the best team in the country. The third best team in a conference doesn't deserve a shot at the national championship. People will argue that a lot of weaker conference champions don't deserve a shot at a national championship either. And that is true enough. But let's be honest, there are not 16 teams in college football each year that deserve a shot at the national championship. Realistically we should have probably stopped at 4. Rarely are there more than four teams that distinguish themselves as being worthy of a championship. When we expanded to eight and more, that was just a money grab. So if we are going to include teams that are really not good enough, why not go ahead and reward all conference champions? Once we have expanded to 16, how many of those 16 have a realistic shot at winning a championship? Most will not. So let's spread the money around and reward all conference champions, not just a bunch of P2 teams. ** Edited by wwhokie1 at 6/6/2025, 11:25:03 AM
Posted: 06/06/2025 at 11:23 AM ET
(In response to this post by hokieZ71)

Thread Replies (24)

Full Thread →
We will eventually end up with a 4–4 – 2–2 – whatever scenario.
hokieZ71 06/06/25 07:13 AM ET
P2 won't go to 20. Only one school available that will bring the existing
PadrosWindup 06/07/25 12:36 PM ET
There becomes a law of diminishing returns and even a law of negative
Maroon Baboon 06/08/25 02:14 PM ET
This "new" development has not played out yet. We only have one year as a
Big12 guy 06/08/25 07:06 PM ET
I think we end up with a ratings based model
HokieAl 06/06/25 11:33 AM ET
Let's make the P2 really mad and do a 10-6 model.
wwhokie1 06/06/25 11:23 AM ET
Based on this argument, which I don't necessarily disagree with the logic,
VTHokie2000 06/06/25 03:56 PM ET
Basketball and football is apples and oranges.
wwhokie1 06/06/25 06:10 PM ET
As the P2s continue consolidating top tier teams, there will come a point
VTHokie2000 06/07/25 05:21 PM ET
Deal me in
Maroon Baboon 06/06/25 03:05 PM ET
I don't think it will be arranged that way.
Maroon Baboon 06/06/25 09:20 AM ET
No conference championship games. And your second point is incorrect
hokieZ71 06/06/25 11:00 AM ET
My point isn't incorrect. It's just highly unlikely. And I concede that.
Maroon Baboon 06/06/25 11:51 AM ET
If and when the P2's have 20 teams each, then there is
Big12 guy 06/06/25 08:36 AM ET
Yeah, definitely won't be a 4-4-4.
hokieZ71 06/06/25 08:59 AM ET
Honestly, until this shakes out, it is not a
Big12 guy 06/06/25 09:04 AM ET
I'm not making it a Big12 vs ACC thing. The Big 12 and ACC are equals.
hokieZ71 06/06/25 09:08 AM ET
Except the ACC makes more money, sends more schools to CFP, and has own TV**
RandomAsianGuy 06/07/25 12:32 PM ET
That and $3 gets you a cup of coffee at Starbucks. The monies
Big12 guy 06/08/25 09:58 AM ET
Yeah, I've noticed that
RandomAsianGuy 06/08/25 01:07 PM ET
Not yet, but it's moving in that direction. **
Big12 guy 06/06/25 09:11 AM ET
Someone get Don King on the phone so he can promote the PPV ACC vs. Big XII
VTHokie2000 06/06/25 03:47 PM ET
It's wishful thinking that the P2 will surrender any money or power...
EDGEMAN 06/06/25 08:48 AM ET
That's why they will offer 4-4-2-2
hokieZ71 06/06/25 09:07 AM ET
Concur 100% **
Big12 guy 06/06/25 08:59 AM ET