All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

vt90
Joined: 12/12/1998
Posts: 49,912
Likes: 36,278
Founder Lifetime

I think it will definitely go to court ...

POTUS has no authority to do this. Congress holds the purse strings and the 'statute' that they used as their justification will absolutely collapse in court. You can't argue in May for overturning Title 42 by saying 'COVID is no longer an issue' and then say you are forgiving $5 billion in debt because of COVID (despite what they say is a booming economy). Add into that the fact that the CDC relaxed all COVID restrictions before this announcement was made. Some even on that side of the aisle are saying it was done knowing it won't hold up in court but that they wanted to basically say 'well, we tried' to that fraction of their base. And, of course, there is this that is still on video ... “People think that the President of the United States has the power for debt forgiveness. He does not. He can postpone. He can delay. But he does not have that power. That has to be an act of Congress,” Pelosi said July 28 at a press conference.
Posted: 08/26/2022 at 02:25 PM ET
(In response to this post by Vienna_Hokie)

Thread Replies (21)

Full Thread →
Unlikely a court will ever decide legality of $10k giveaway
Vienna_Hokie 08/26/22 02:20 PM ET
As if only taxpayers can deal with this.**
PhotoHokieNC 08/26/22 04:07 PM ET
authority is the issue- not damage
bigbadbird 08/26/22 03:12 PM ET
Who has standing to bring a legal challenge?**
ColoVT82 08/26/22 03:23 PM ET
A bunch of state Attorney Generals are planning a challenge ...
vt90 08/26/22 03:24 PM ET
As I understand things, to bring a case you need particularized injury and
ColoVT82 08/26/22 03:37 PM ET
Not a lawyer so I don't know ...
vt90 08/26/22 03:41 PM ET
Besides. What's another $3-500B? Not Like we talking trillions lol**
ColoVT82 08/26/22 03:44 PM ET
This is America...you can sue for anything!**
vthhhi 08/26/22 02:53 PM ET
reactionaries will be able to do whatever they want in court for 50 years
typed by ben 08/26/22 02:50 PM ET
It could
VTUD 08/26/22 02:36 PM ET
"looks more like a" LOL, really?**
PhotoHokieNC 08/26/22 04:10 PM ET
B: "C'mon, man! I tried!!"
TomTurkey 08/26/22 06:06 PM ET
I think it ends up at the Supreme Court
TabbHokie 08/26/22 03:26 PM ET
Possible**
VTUD 08/26/22 03:27 PM ET
Yea Joe is on shaky ground with this**
fordham 08/26/22 03:04 PM ET
I think it will definitely go to court ...
vt90 08/26/22 02:25 PM ET
Agreed. A Senator or Representative should have standing given the
RoswellGAHokie 08/26/22 02:30 PM ET
I hope so, but the analysis I read said that's not possible
Vienna_Hokie 08/26/22 02:35 PM ET
If you take the article’s argument to the extreme, a President would have
RoswellGAHokie 08/26/22 02:37 PM ET
Great dictator set up!**
fordham 08/26/22 03:17 PM ET
Correct. It is illegal and unconstitutional because ...
vt90 08/26/22 02:46 PM ET