All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

BG Hokie
Joined: 12/13/2005
Posts: 48,083
Likes: 14,262

Oh, now you're just trolling me. Tom Sawyer and Roundabout by Yes are the

worst songs of all time. Earlish days of XM Radio was my classic rock phase and I loathed those two songs. Honestly, Tom Sawyer is probably 90% of the reason I have a negative opinion of Rush. The other 10% is that I was able to needle a couple of Rush fans about it on this very board a mere 20 years ago or so....
Posted: 01/28/2026 at 04:28 PM ET
(In response to this post by Atlee Hokie)

Thread Replies (96)

Full Thread →
what's your "there I said it" hot take of the day?
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 10:08 AM ET
"Charlie; don't, surf!!!"**
bourbonstreet 01/28/26 07:32 PM ET
Tried 5 times but couldn't get past page 50 of "The House of Seven Gables"**
TomTurkey 01/28/26 05:53 PM ET
as an aside, just finished "Handling Sin" a little longish but enjoyed it.**
`lag 01/29/26 06:20 AM ET
We read "Fathers and Sons" for VT English Lit
TomTurkey 01/29/26 09:19 AM ET
Maybe they should have stuck with six gables.**
EDGEMAN 01/28/26 06:19 PM ET
I've only seen parts of Game of Thrones and just don't like it.**
UTPr0sim 01/28/26 05:10 PM ET
I've only heard 30 seconds of "I Am The Walrus", but the Beatles are crap.**
HokieNoVA 01/28/26 06:41 PM ET
I dislike those that dislike the Beatles....**
UTPr0sim 01/28/26 05:02 PM ET
Die Hard IS, without a doubt, a Christmas movie**
MAHokie69 01/28/26 05:02 PM ET
Proof...**
Brown Water 01/28/26 05:30 PM ET
All the people on the lounge are losers
turkeywinghokie 01/28/26 02:05 PM ET
Oh the irony; you can't even spell "looser" correctly.**
Tank 01/28/26 03:53 PM ET
Thinks they are a grate speller though.....**
RTFC 01/28/26 04:10 PM ET
I agry**
TomTurkey 01/28/26 05:55 PM ET
💥**
astrohokie 01/28/26 04:05 PM ET
No argument here. **
Hurley09 01/28/26 03:31 PM ET
American Psycho is a stupid movie. **
Hurley09 01/28/26 02:02 PM ET
😱😱😱😱😱😱**
capitals1 01/28/26 02:07 PM ET
Dude looks like a lady.**
MikeVT85 01/28/26 02:01 PM ET
Beer sucks. All of it**
HokieAl 01/28/26 01:32 PM ET
All the zennials agree. Bunch of dudes these days drinking seltzers...**
BG Hokie 01/28/26 05:48 PM ET
Duuuuddeee 🍻!!**
astrohokie 01/28/26 04:08 PM ET
Not a huge beer fan but the German stuff I've had was pretty good**
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 02:08 PM ET
I can't stand AC/DC and Aerosmith--by the way, I'm listening...
vthhhi 01/28/26 01:14 PM ET
*shakes fist***
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 02:09 PM ET
Blazing Saddles is overrated...as is Monty Python.
Tank 01/28/26 12:58 PM ET
How dare you!**
HokieGator 01/28/26 04:23 PM ET
These are fighting words...
MBHokie90 01/28/26 02:09 PM ET
Co-sign**
hoosnowahokie 01/28/26 01:05 PM ET
Farts aren't all that funny**
JoesterVT 01/28/26 12:56 PM ET
Especially lumpy ones...**
ShortFatHokie 01/28/26 05:49 PM ET
My farts are. Other peoples….nope. **
HokieGator 01/28/26 02:55 PM ET
Titanic (the movie) is nothing more than Lady & the Tramp.**
Spud 01/28/26 12:38 PM ET
James Cameron pitched it as 'Romeo and Juliet on a sinking ship'.
HokieDan95 01/28/26 12:49 PM ET
Every politician should be drowned in their own excrement. All of them.**
Hokebury 01/28/26 12:27 PM ET
That's a hot take?**
MAHokie69 01/28/26 05:01 PM ET
I'd add one word..."professional" politician. Go serve, back to a real job**
RTFC 01/28/26 12:54 PM ET
Include in that all chefs on the Food Network, broadcast journlists and
Hokebury 01/28/26 12:35 PM ET
I don't like U2. Friend said you just don't know you like them. I said, no,
soldcokesatLane 01/28/26 12:05 PM ET
I'm a fan
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 02:56 PM ET
Never got 'em either. Asked some kids once...
`lag 01/28/26 02:42 PM ET
this is a test**
`lag 01/29/26 05:56 PM ET
I'm with you. U2 is really overrated.**
MCL3 Hokie 01/28/26 02:32 PM ET
Bruce is not anybody’s boss. Once a jerk, always a jerk.**
PhotoHokieNC 01/28/26 12:02 PM ET
Ditto... right place, right time IMO**
WestyHokie 01/28/26 12:01 PM ET
Neil Young is a hack**
bigbadbird 01/28/26 11:52 AM ET
I skimmed over this and thought it said "Neil Young is black." "I never
Hurley09 01/28/26 02:01 PM ET
Many of today's TV commercials use the good old Motown hits I grew up with**
HokieHi71 01/28/26 11:24 AM ET
Rush is proof that technically proficient music that is more boring than a
BG Hokie 01/28/26 11:03 AM ET
+ Geddy's voice**
HokieDan95 01/28/26 05:46 PM ET
I like Limelight, but that's about it.**
HokieNoVA 01/28/26 05:31 PM ET
I like "Tom Sawyer"**
Atlee Hokie 01/28/26 04:07 PM ET
Oh, now you're just trolling me. Tom Sawyer and Roundabout by Yes are the
BG Hokie 01/28/26 04:28 PM ET
Not trolling. I do like it.**
Atlee Hokie 01/28/26 05:13 PM ET
!!boring!! 🫤 Que up "The Camera Eye" & tell me you were bored!**
astrohokie 01/28/26 03:59 PM ET
I am a dude but I have always liked Duran Duran's music.**
OrlandoHokie 01/28/26 10:59 AM ET
Rare 80s pop that has actually improved with age
Beerman 01/28/26 12:40 PM ET
Beatles so so but like the Dude I can't stand the Eagles. Their music
jdkhokie 01/28/26 10:48 AM ET
Can add one song - Stone Temple Pilots Interstate Love Song it was
jdkhokie 01/28/26 11:10 AM ET
I'll see your Beatles and raise you one Dave Matthews. Never figured out
HeisenBurg13 01/28/26 10:36 AM ET
Isn't he a Hoo?**
TomTurkey 01/28/26 05:58 PM ET
I know he hails from Hooville, but I don't know if he identifies as one. **
HeisenBurg13 01/28/26 05:59 PM ET
Long time ago I worked with a group of guys that loved on DMB like they
HokieDan95 01/28/26 03:24 PM ET
This^^^^**
Spudnut 01/28/26 11:11 AM ET
I never thought Jennifer Aniston was all that...there I said it**
capitals1 01/28/26 10:29 AM ET
oh my!**
UTPr0sim 01/28/26 05:04 PM ET
I agree with you 100%**
BWS 01/28/26 01:50 PM ET
^^^outta whack^^^**
Chris ColemanAdmin 01/28/26 01:42 PM ET
... and she doesn't seem to be aging much.**
Atlee Hokie 01/28/26 04:05 PM ET
Inconceivable!**
TomTurkey 01/28/26 02:21 PM ET
I know I have studied her for many a year! Sometimes hours at a time!**
vthhhi 01/28/26 01:40 PM ET
You take that back!**
Brown Water 01/28/26 11:27 AM ET
And I thought the Billy Joel & Beatles posts were wacky, but this???? ^^^**
RhinoVT 01/28/26 10:38 AM ET
Pearl Jam, Grateful Dead, Rolling Stones. Don't hate 'em, but all very meh
Late 80s Hokie 01/28/26 10:18 AM ET
Always thought the RS had a whiff of fraud about them...
`lag 01/28/26 02:06 PM ET
This is a test</>**
`lag 01/29/26 05:54 PM ET
popularity doesn't necessarily equal quality - people are idiots after all**
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 02:15 PM ET
Has to be top 3**
TomTurkey 01/28/26 10:20 AM ET
The Boss, sounds excruciatingly generic to me **
astrohokie 01/28/26 10:17 AM ET
That's a biopic that I have zero interest in seeing.**
Jackie VT 01/28/26 01:43 PM ET
yeah, at least with the Dylan one you had a lot of lore...
`lag 01/28/26 02:57 PM ET
nothing more than an American Bryan Adams**
JoesterVT 01/28/26 12:46 PM ET
Adams had 1.5 good albums and then turned in crap for 30+ years**
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 12:52 PM ET
You ain't rong, I stand by what I said**
JoesterVT 01/28/26 12:55 PM ET
Yep, always sounds like he's constipated**
Hokerer 01/28/26 10:43 AM ET
Some great songs but I've been annoyed by the band worship over the years
HokieDan95 01/28/26 10:12 AM ET
I am similar to you with Billy Joel (can semi-tolerant Piano Man at most)**
Tuckahokie 01/28/26 10:11 AM ET
We do strictly 80s Joel sir**
ValveHokie 01/28/26 05:28 PM ET
OK I'm curious - how much of his discography have you listened to?
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 10:38 AM ET
A good amount...I have no major issue with the man, just not much into his
Tuckahokie 01/28/26 03:49 PM ET
He writes his own stuff and 95% is A+ .**
PhotoHokieNC 01/28/26 12:05 PM ET
Billy Joel wrote almost everything himself. He has like 1-2 co-writer
RhinoVT 01/28/26 10:40 AM ET
and their collab "Code of Silence" is great**
HokieMacDaddy 01/28/26 10:53 AM ET
It's hard to choose, but that might be 1 of his top 5 songs. **
RhinoVT 01/28/26 10:57 AM ET
I've hated 'We Didn't Start the Fire' since its release because it pretends
HokieDan95 01/28/26 10:18 AM ET
Billy said it's his least favorite song
KeithHokie89 01/28/26 11:38 AM ET