All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

S
Joined: 10/07/1999
Posts: 29,141
Likes: 9,087
Founder Subscriber

More

My co-workers know me in the context of work, so they know that I BRING a lunch to work every day. [I live alone but let's say I lived with family or roommates]: Someone that lives with me knows that I TAKE a lunch to work every day. Now if another person from neither work nor home asks me whether I take/bring my own lunch to work, either might be appropriate. They might be thinking of me as a worker and wonder if I eat sitting at my desk (so do I BRING a lunch?), or they might be wondering if I buy stuff for the lunch and prepare it each morning and pack it and it goes with me to work (so do I TAKE a lunch?). So there are situations where both is appropriate. But no one is ever going to say "what night do you bring out the trash"? They'll ask what night do you TAKE out the trash. Unless they happen to live right where you bring the trash to so their perspective is solely that you occasionally come out of the house with trash and leave it near them.
Posted: 12/14/2023 at 11:44 AM ET
(In response to this post by SteveInBaltimore)

Thread Replies (27)

Full Thread →
Bring vs. Take
JoesterVT 12/14/23 08:54 AM ET
Well, people talk about "taking a poop" when they're really leaving one 🤷‍**
Will StewartAdmin 12/14/23 07:31 PM ET
Maybe they just don't give shiRt**
statmanfromHCyrs 12/15/23 08:15 AM ET
I'd be dropping it off. ? or would I be handing it over?
Riverguy 12/14/23 04:59 PM ET
Both sound completely normal. Bring feels "more" correct.**
BG Hokie 12/14/23 01:53 PM ET
IMO,'bring' implies you're going there anyway. 'Take' is a specific reason
Dan1993 12/14/23 01:36 PM ET
Both are acceptable uses. But you can take it for what its worth. Just
Hokebury 12/14/23 01:29 PM ET
It’s hard to bring it every day so sometimes I just take it.**
OrlandoHokie 12/14/23 11:42 AM ET
You take something FROM somewhere, you bring something TO somewhere
SteveInBaltimore 12/14/23 11:38 AM ET
But to amplify...
SteveInBaltimore 12/14/23 11:40 AM ET
More
SteveInBaltimore 12/14/23 11:44 AM ET
just saying....
JoesterVT 12/14/23 11:47 AM ET
just so weird to routinely hear weirdos say....
JoesterVT 12/14/23 11:44 AM ET
I don't usually hear that in that context.
SteveInBaltimore 12/14/23 11:46 AM ET
I take things somewhere. Someone else brings them to me.**
hoosnowahokie 12/14/23 10:09 AM ET
Another one - who says "take the trash off"?
LaneRat 12/14/23 09:47 AM ET
I just use FedEx**
B777Fr8Dog 12/14/23 09:43 AM ET
Locally here they (we?) "carry" people to the doctor.
TomTurkey 12/14/23 09:11 AM ET
It depends on who you are talking to. If I am talking to someone in my
Femoyer Hokie 12/14/23 09:08 AM ET
Sure...in my scenario if I had to talk to the pharmacist on the phone...
JoesterVT 12/14/23 09:24 AM ET
Right... depends on who you're talking to
WuhBuh-DC_Hokie 12/14/23 10:52 AM ET
Yep... all depends on the context
WuhBuh-DC_Hokie 12/14/23 10:29 AM ET
Will this help ?**
PhotoHokieNC 12/14/23 08:59 AM ET
I 'send' it with someone else going in that direction ...
vt90 12/14/23 08:58 AM ET
Go full send and bring it! 😜**
Vtskier1 12/14/23 09:33 AM ET
If someone you weren’t worried about threatened you would you say,
PhotoHokieNC 12/14/23 09:01 AM ET
LOL Start pulling out that wallet. **
TomTurkey 12/14/23 09:12 AM ET
I always use take in this type of situation. Bring only comes to mind for..
Alan11 12/14/23 08:58 AM ET