All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

MP4VT2004
Joined: 09/09/2007
Posts: 24,522
Likes: 26,027

I have a similar setup.

We don't have natural gas service on our street, so tankless really isn't a feasible option for us. The last time our electric tank-style water heater died, I paid one of my plumber buddies to come over and replace the old gate-style shutoff valves with new quarter-turn ball valves and braided, threaded flexible connections to a new electric tank that I furnished. I would have done it myself, but we were getting ready to leave for vacation at the time, and I didn't trust my soldering skills to be left unattended for a week immediately following the installation. Also, I wasn't crazy about the thought of using Shark Bite fittings on a valve that is going to see occasional manipulation...they would probably have worked just fine, but I just worry about their longevity on anything that is going to experience some external forces. Anyway, the next time I need to replace the heater, I'll be able to do it without having to call any tradesmen.
Posted: 02/05/2025 at 07:39 PM ET
(In response to this post by FrederickHokie)

Thread Replies (20)

Full Thread →
Water Heater is crapping out...is Tankless the way to go now? Tanks in
Tuckahokie 02/05/25 10:13 AM ET
My LP tankless is mounted on an exterior wall - no venting required. Also,
VT72 02/05/25 06:43 PM ET
Couple things. 1) In my experience there is more of a delay getting hot
DonHo-kieHi 02/05/25 06:20 PM ET
Replaced ours a few months ago.
FrederickHokie 02/05/25 03:15 PM ET
I have a similar setup.
MP4VT2004 02/05/25 07:39 PM ET
Nope. Read Consumer Reports
C67VTCC 02/05/25 02:33 PM ET
I’ve never cleaned mine. Whoops. Have some reading to do I guess. **
GreenvilleVT 02/05/25 02:42 PM ET
We love ours. Only thing is if power goes out, hot water is out immediately**
ModerateHokie 02/05/25 12:40 PM ET
It is if you have natural Gas. Otherwise not as economical.**
UTPr0sim 02/05/25 12:13 PM ET
I've had both. Tankless is expensive especially on propane. Tanked water
Hokebury 02/05/25 11:48 AM ET
what if you have two daughters and a wife who like scalding hot showers?
HokieAl 02/05/25 12:35 PM ET
Peels the wallpaper
TomTurkey 02/05/25 12:58 PM ET
For gas tankless be sure to have your exhaust vents and gas
Sportn 02/05/25 11:43 AM ET
Re. Water Heater is crapping out...is Tankless the way to go now?**
Tank 02/05/25 11:30 AM ET
I put in tankless, lp gas, a couple of years ago. I like it, but it
75Hokie 02/05/25 11:06 AM ET
hot water recirculation system will solve that for a minimal cost. **
VTENGR 02/05/25 01:50 PM ET
Yes I like the on demand of tankless hot water
HOKIE 02/05/25 10:57 AM ET
I think currently only if you have natural gas. I believe electric tankless
Stork 02/05/25 10:47 AM ET
I've looked into it a couple of times. Tankless prices needed to come down
Late 80s Hokie 02/05/25 10:47 AM ET
For minimal people, yes. A family of 6? No
hoosnowahokie 02/05/25 10:23 AM ET
You can get bigger tankless options that can handle
ElbertoHokie 02/05/25 10:33 AM ET