All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Vienna_Hokie
Joined: 09/16/2002
Posts: 17,623
Likes: 12,575

I read 96 hour supply...but, looking at pictures, I think that depends

From what I've seen, it is not carrying a bunch of compressed air (which makes sense given the depths where they are going to have to mix all sorts of gases, plus the weight would be unsustainable). Nuclear subs create air to breath by separating O2 from the seawater, but that is only possible because they can produce so much power with the reactor, don't think that's an option for a vessel that is running on batteries. So, they are likely using a closed circuit rebreather type setup. I'm not an expert on those, especially in a sub like application, but the general theory is that small bottles of gases (the air we breath is only 18% O2, and we only use a tiny bit of that with each breath, so they carry straight O2 and add small amounts back in through the process) to supply air and then recirculated through a medium that is a lot like kitty litter to capture the CO2. The limiting factor is the amount of O2 AND the filter medium which will eventually saturate with CO2. What I don't know is if the system they use requires power (likely it has sensors adjust the inputs that do at least) or is passive like an old style SCUBA Rebreather where the operator adjusts the mixes manually. If they had a failure and lost power as part of why they lost comms with the support ship, they could have lost their air supply very quickly or if there was an issue with the gas mixing, they could have all been impacted by CO2 poisoning or Nitrogen Narcosis (Narc'd) which would make them loopy and who knows what someone would do wrong in that state, or too much O2 which can kill you when in a pressurized environment. (Link below is how a rebreather works if you're interested) So many potential failures in an environment where a tiny failure is likely catastrophic.
Posted: 06/20/2023 at 07:47 PM ET
(In response to this post by ColoVT82)

Thread Replies (17)

Full Thread →
Why didn't the OceanGate Expeditions Titan submarine have a boat follow it
MrBayAreaHokie 06/20/23 02:46 PM ET
I would think there would be a thought-out contingency for any possible
MikeVT85 06/20/23 06:48 PM ET
It uses a video game controller for navigation. You really think Plan B was
UEMcGill 06/20/23 07:07 PM ET
It's an intuitive, ergonomic computer interface. Don't get hung up on that.**
JoesterVT 06/20/23 08:27 PM ET
as noted earlier, the US Navy uses XBox controllers on subs
Vienna_Hokie 06/20/23 07:50 PM ET
Contact with the support vessel (mothership) lost. What, 96h emergency O2?**
ColoVT82 06/20/23 03:44 PM ET
I read 96 hour supply...but, looking at pictures, I think that depends
Vienna_Hokie 06/20/23 07:47 PM ET
There was a boat "tracking" it.
hookie 06/20/23 03:35 PM ET
I have lots of questions around this accident
VT Pez4Life 06/20/23 03:18 PM ET
I wonder how many takers the company will have for their next submarine...
EDGEMAN 06/20/23 03:49 PM ET
Well, likely the CEO won't be one of them. Isn't HE on this trip? **
HOKIERIT 06/20/23 07:55 PM ET
No idea. Haven't seen the manifest.**
EDGEMAN 06/21/23 07:05 AM ET
I don't know either. Everything I hear is different. I've seen several->
HOKIERIT 06/21/23 09:33 AM ET
Same for me. I keep hearing conflicting reports about who was on board.**
EDGEMAN 06/21/23 10:52 AM ET
Rich people will be dying to do it.**
reestuart 06/20/23 04:18 PM ET
And they won't be under water after paying for it**
Brown Water 06/20/23 04:21 PM ET
That will be like a breath of fresh air**
turkeywinghokie 06/20/23 05:16 PM ET
the next tour is the wreckage of a fool proof submersible **
bigbadbird 06/20/23 03:56 PM ET