Login | Sign Up
TechSideline

All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Football Board
◀ ▶
F
Joined: 10/30/2003
Posts: 1,583
Likes: 944
Flanker

Most schools only play one QB so it would be hard to keep them all content.

I like watching Scott Fisher on youtube go over the prospects each year and he'll focus on various position groups or overall top players. QB is tough because most teams only play one QB. Fisher's 2017 analysis is below. I might have to an analyis of the Elite 11 and the finalists. I believe the guys who make it to the Elite 11 have to win a bunch of competitions so it's not like it's based totally on inaccurate rankings. A lot of them look overrated to me because RECRUITING RANKINGS ARE BS!
Link: Scott Fisher 2017 Top 10 QB's
Posted: 05/31/2026 at 05:28 PM ET
(In response to this post by V333T)

Thread Replies (25)

Full Thread →
Misc Elite 11/VT nuggets posted elsewhere on Bourque, Grunk and Bryce B
V333T • 05/31/26 01:53 PM ET
I don't think PB is in the "QB room" in 2026
MaroonMark • 06/02/26 02:24 AM ET
Thank you for the corrections
V333T • 06/02/26 06:16 AM ET
Peter during the 7v7 today
La Gargola • 05/31/26 04:00 PM ET
Yeah, I just caught that. Ruminations he’ll place overall in top 5 or
V333T • 05/31/26 04:18 PM ET
Agreed **
La Gargola • 05/31/26 04:24 PM ET
Rivals has him at #2 overall Link
V333T • 05/31/26 06:54 PM ET
I saw
La Gargola • 05/31/26 06:56 PM ET
Plus a rating pop and extra star. He beat a 5* Will Mencl who finished #5.**
V333T • 05/31/26 06:59 PM ET
He beat the 5 star from Alabama as well**
La Gargola • 05/31/26 07:04 PM ET
It's interesting to look back and see the participants.
Flanker • 05/31/26 03:58 PM ET
2020 Kyron Drones, 2017 Quincy Patterson II, how did those work out for us?
HoakieBS • 05/31/26 09:34 PM ET
True, but did you watch both of them back then and Bourque now and
BoozVT • 06/01/26 03:38 PM ET
IIRC, I read that QPIII won the event?!**
HoakieBS • 06/01/26 03:58 PM ET
Elite 11
jphelan133 • 06/02/26 09:29 AM ET
Oh yeah, didn't mean it like that. I loved QPIII and was hoping he'd
BoozVT • 06/01/26 04:35 PM ET
I hope against every pessimistic bone 🦴 in my Hoakie body, you are correct**
HoakieBS • 06/01/26 07:12 PM ET
Fascinating. Just getting started and I see regional finalists that did OK.
Coach McGuirk • 05/31/26 06:34 PM ET
You can manually change the year to go back to 1999
Flanker • 05/31/26 07:58 PM ET
I wonder how many QB rooms have 3 former Elite 11s simultaneously
V333T • 05/31/26 04:50 PM ET
It is nice to finally see our names mentioned amidst the Blue Bloods.
HoakieBS • 06/01/26 10:01 AM ET
You can manually type the year and go back to 1999 on the Elite 11 website.
Flanker • 05/31/26 08:05 PM ET
Four. Huhn was a finalist as well...although I think he finished around 14**
VictoryTurkey • 05/31/26 07:08 PM ET
Thank you, I think I knew that, duh.**
V333T • 05/31/26 07:10 PM ET
Most schools only play one QB so it would be hard to keep them all content. ◄
Flanker • 05/31/26 05:28 PM ET
Yeah, I'd think once the depth chart is set, 2 of the guys will jet.
BoozVT • 06/01/26 03:49 PM ET