All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

C
Joined: 02/07/2007
Posts: 3,403
Likes: 5,415

That's why it's less accurate. I prefer 247, been around much longer,

well respected, and used heavily by coaches. On3 is fairly new. No way LSU is #1 and TX #2 in 247, and very low ranking in On3 with all the high talent transferring to both teams. No way VT is higher than #1 LSU and #2 TX. Those 2 sites are very far apart in rankings. Just would like to look at ranking/talent of players coming in, that's it, and not include all the other numbers and rankings of outgoing transfer players and NFL potential like On3. I guess it's a matter of preference, thus multiple sites to look at. Glad that VT is ranked high both sites, Franklin is off to a great start. ** Edited by carhokies at 1/15/2026, 3:37:52 AM
Posted: 01/14/2026 at 05:34 PM ET
(In response to this post by hokiepro)

Thread Replies (7)

Full Thread →
Up to 11 in 247’s Portal Rankings after the Grunk!!!**
HoakieBS 01/14/26 03:23 PM ET
247 is more accurrate than On3. On3 includes rankings outgoing portal
carhokies 01/14/26 05:19 PM ET
I like On3 because what they’re doing is comparing outgoing talent vs
hokiepro 01/14/26 05:25 PM ET
I like On3 because
Planner_Hokie 01/14/26 10:03 PM ET
On3 is a comparison. 247 is a ranking. Neither is great but 247 is better
marcbvtgm 01/14/26 08:41 PM ET
That's why it's less accurate. I prefer 247, been around much longer,
carhokies 01/14/26 05:34 PM ET
No rankings are “accurate” when talking recruiting **
hokiepro 01/14/26 05:38 PM ET
Rankings are largely useless,......
2hhoop3 01/14/26 05:46 PM ET